Best Puzzle:
Time Loop by Fractal Advocate (It was quite cleverly made. You don't see many puzzles like this.)
Funnest Map:
Time Loop by Fractal Advocate
Overachiever Award:
Ghostship by Blitzen (Why? Why couldn't you been an underachiever with and created an actual puzzle instead?)
Biggest Rip-Off:
This is a hard category for this one. No one blatantly lifted anything from a well known (and unique) game!
Shake Fist In Frustration Award:
Ghostship by Blitzen (Yarg! It do be a fetch quest I say!)