Someone pointed out to me that the voting should've taken place in a blog post for the game. They're right. It should have.
I made up categories on the spot, and then submitted my nominations for them. People have since replied to them in the thread, but I hope that they take the time to repost them here for posterity.
Here are my votes:
Best Puzzle:
Setting the Table by Gibmaker
Funnest Map:
Economy Sim by Craze
Overachiever Award:
Liberty for Riddle of 7
Biggest Rip-Off:
Zack's Chip Challenge by kentona
Shake Fist In Frustration Award:
Lazer Su Doku by GameOverGames Productions