[MAFIA] PURGATORY: A MAFIA GAME

I am indifferent on who to vote for. Most of my feeling is somewhat intuition based, and not really backed up on any true facts or anything I can agrue on the reason why.

@muffle I think your problem is that you don't want every person killed to be killed because we can't tell their alignment which I don't remember anyone suggesting.

Or, maybe you're okay with that, but you don't want that to be our sole reason, which is also not an argument I've seen.

You're reading between the lines too much and assuming too much about what today's vote means for future votes.

also, voting for me because I disagreed with you and wanted you to explain yourself clearly is... XD

That's not the only reason I'm voting you Gourd. 1) Bad intuition 2) I thought I had explained myself clearly, I was SURE I had explained myself clearly.

I'm bad at wording things.

And I'm getting a little frustrated because I'm bad at wording things.

And apparently, people don't seem to be understanding what I'm saying.

So basically:

I find it unfair that people would vote someone because they'll still be here and there's no consequence as losing them as a valuable player, assuming they are town.

If you have any other reason than I suppose that is fine, at the beginning people were talking about lynching Cave just because he's been unpredictable before and he'd be a useful ghost assuming he's town.

I find using that as an only reason unfair to the player. Because while they can interact they still can't fully participate.

If anybody else is confused please point out exactly what you're confused about so I can clear questions, because I know I'm stupid and me having to explain myself in different words because I'm not being clear enough when I was 100% sure I was makes me feel even dumber.

As far I as I was able to tell we disagreed on it being unfair. Sorry for getting upset v.v

author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
i'm still waiting on the answer of why lockez asked that question

Regardless of what I hoped to learn, what I actually learned is that you're full of sass and don't trust my methods of intelligence gathering, neither of which is surprising info.

Also I learned something about how Cap sounds to Gourd. That's useful info. Eventually. In some game. Maybe even this one! Or not. One of the two.

author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
it would be a good explanation for why i am never nightkilled, if I died day 1, it's true.

You were nightkilled TWICE last game you dunce. You probably won't get nightkilled this game, but don't act like it never happens.

Ok, this game got quite active.
People bandwagonning on Cave could be seen as a proof of him being a town. Unless he told his packmates to vote him for exactly this effect.
What I would point out here is Jeroen's post. Jero called Cave town in his first posts for his posting style. Personally, I see this as more sketchy than Cave's behaviour.
Goourd's vote was bad and him insisting on his null read is something I dislike too. But him being very active suggests that he's actually town.
Demonlord is also very active. I'm not so sure about Gourd, but I think he wouldn't engage as much if he were a wolf.
Aneko should die tomorrow.

and I think that LockeZ is faking it. His style is usually hostile, but this lacks his usual logic. His muffle case is almost like a paragraph of lorem ipsum. This is not his usual way to policy vote someone. It's too mean and unfair to Muffle.

#lynch LockeZ

Yeah I'll hold my thoughts on the LockeZ x Muffle vote until later. In the meantime: LockeZ, thoughts on demon?

Also, if Cave is alive tomorrow that should town-confirm anyone with a sense of humor because it'd be way too funny to kill him.

author=Cap_H
What I would point out here is Jeroen's post. Jero called Cave town in his first posts for his posting style.

Err, no I didn't? Are you talking about the Cave we know and love thing? He's acted that way in many past games regardless of alignment. I was just talking about him being back to his old self.
It's true I always townread Cave though, and that's exsctly why I don't trust myself to correctly read him and don't want him alive at MYLO/LYLO.

Muffle, I find your insistence on this morality thing very weird. You keep saying people are only voting Cave because there's no real consequence, but you seem to be missing the point, which is that there is a very real benefit to town, namely either killing scum or confirming a strong player. You're also completely disregarding the other argument, which is "Cave is hard to read so I don't want him unconfirmed during important end of game votes"

I feel better about demon after his explanation.