• Add Review
  • Subscribe
  • Nominate
  • Submit Media
  • RSS

Hey guys! REALLY need opinions here!

  • Puddor
  • 03/24/2012 08:53 AM
  • 2621 views
There's a section of the game where I'm doing custom faces and sprites.

But I can't decide on the style, so I need some feedback...mainly because I'm in a rut of self-loathing at the moment.

There's this:


Or I could do this style:


I'm more comfortable with the second style, but the facesets are for these sprites:



So I don't know! D'8
I actually really kind of hate the first one something fierce for reasons I can't place (I didn't sleep last night, which means I've been up for 22 hours now, so that might be it). But yeah. Really need opinions on this ASAP so I can finish up these facesets.

OH! If I do the first style, the emotions will be static rather than having different facesets, which I would do for the second style.
To leave off have some art:

Posts

Pages: 1
I personally like the second one more, I think due to the sharper lines and the use of black for outlining.
They both look good, better to go with what matches more imo, but it's also good to go with what's easier to draw. :)
Puddor
if squallbutts was a misao category i'd win every damn year
5702
Alright then, I think I'll go for the BR style.
Definitely the second style.

IN CASE YOU NEED MORE OPINION.
Puddor
if squallbutts was a misao category i'd win every damn year
5702
haha thanks Penta! *huggle*
That's a tough one! I like the face better on the second one, but I like the outfit that the first guy is wearing better! I guess it wouldn't work if they were combined n' blended . . ..
Second one, I say . . . but it's a tough one.
Puddor
if squallbutts was a misao category i'd win every damn year
5702
Spirit_Young: The first one was actually drawn for this game. The second one is Ralph! Hahahah~ It's just the style.

though I didn't realize how similar their haircuts are until I did a prototype.

whups

i DESIGNED HIM BEFORE I KNEW WHO RALPH WAS :V
I prefer the first faceset in terms of the style, but really you should go for what's easiest (while still looking good, of course)
I vote for the second one, the first one looks pretty over-worked and second look pretty cool even if it is more simple (that is probably the reason I it like more)

I hope my opinion helps ;)
Pages: 1