CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK'S PROFILE

CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
On sunny days, I go out walking
1142

Search

Filter

FF8 Cannibal Mafia

FoSing him is one thing, asking him to roleclaim is another.

FF8 Cannibal Mafia

author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
But if he was, I bet he would be more active in this thread, considering he just made one post that was to lynch Yellow magic and then bounced.



actually, this isn't a great argument since it holds true (although somewhat less so since scum are known to lurk) if he's mafia. Despite get back here

FF8 Cannibal Mafia

The only potential downside to lynching despite is that there's a small chance he's a cop or something.

But if he was, I bet he would be more active in this thread, considering he just made one post that was to lynch Yellow magic and then bounced.

I also don't know why people are trying to get Trihan to reveal at this point.

FF8 Cannibal Mafia

author=Trihan
Happy, I'm pointing out that chana is someone to watch for. I've changed my vote to Despite; I'm not trying to talk you out of that. In fact, my reasoning explained exactly why Despite dying is win-win for me no matter what now.

It's not that chana jumps on bandwagons at the drop of a hat that concerns me, it's the fact that every time it happened it made exactly four votes. That's either a really huge coincidence or deliberate timing.

In fact, considering that chana is likely to be able to give me very considerate and profound answers, why would I do this without a good reason? If I were a cannibal I'd just be setting myself up for a lashing.

It's sad that you're swaying towards me, because I'm honestly doing everything I can right now to persuade you I'm on your side.


Considering that it takes nine to lynch, making it four votes doesn't mean much.

FF8 Cannibal Mafia

I wouldn't call the votes on Despite a bandwagon. There's actual logic behind lynching him. Other people to lynch include Chana for being so swayable.

While I agree with what chana said about wasting a round with nolynch, we might be shortening our numbers FURTHER than one person dying in the night. If we misfire right now we might as well play Russian Roulette with two bullets.


If we don't lynch, someone dies in the night and unless cop has a guilty, we have no information. If we lynch now, we at least have something to go on based on what the lynched person's role turns out to have been as well as who argued for/against lynching that person.

FF8 Cannibal Mafia

"Well, what can I say. The fact the Paranoid Gun Owner didn't reveal his role kind of baffles me, but the outcome could have been worse. What really didn't help is the fact that Despite would only throw around random lynch votes, which actually cost the village the game on Day 5. Despite also could have soft claimed a powerful role from the get-go so that the witches would target him, thus killing one of them in the process. This happened anyway, though, so Despite was somewhat helpful."

yeop, sounds like this dude is a liability either way. Also, Zell avatar.

FF8 Cannibal Mafia

author=Trihan
Wait, why was CAVE talking about a Happy bandwagon? I am the only person who has cast a vote for Happy today. At all. Did I miss something?
I meant Yellow Magic. I get names confused.

Nothing against voting Despite, but why? I think if he were a bad dude he'd be acting up as usual? I dunno. I stand by nolynch. It's day one.


He apparently has a thing for voting randomly and very quickly, trying to lynch anyone, or at least that's what people are saying. I'll review the last game. Regardless, it doesn't seem like he's acting any differently this game, so he's either scum or detrimental to town.

FF8 Cannibal Mafia

What was your reason for voting Yellow Magic?

I feel that I've laid out a good case for why Despite should be lynched, since, according to people who have played with him, no matter what he does he is anti-town.

FF8 Cannibal Mafia

Regardless of whether or not he wants to lynch anyone every round (anti-town action) or if he is a cannibal(anti-town) the only possibility is that he is a liability.

FF8 Cannibal Mafia

author=Happy
Despite doesn't count. start from the person after him.

Why