TRIHAN'S PROFILE

Trihan
"It's more like a big ball of wibbly wobbly...timey wimey...stuff."
3359
Sidhe Quest
When everything goes wrong, it's up to our heroes to go and do a bunch of other stuff!

Search

Filter

[MAFIA] Is this Werewolf?

You've put forward a solid case there Jeroen, and I had my doubts about demon on day 1 when I voted for him. You're right that his acknowledgement of the possibility of bodyguard is worded similarly to mine but reads more as someone surprised that an NK whiffed than learning about a role we thought wasn't present.

#lynch demonlord5000

[MAFIA] Is this Werewolf?

The difference is that the sorcerer's actions are separate from the seer's, so their net is being cast just as widely as theirs is at first. Whereas for every lycan you add, that's another person the seer is going to get a false positive for, and that's one of the most valuable information sources town has so the less reliable the results are the less useful the role is overall.

[MAFIA] Is this Werewolf?

Honestly my money would be on either odd or Atiya being sorcerer and lying about being a lycan; I've been thinking about how having 2 lycans would affect the game, and from Fomar's perspective it would have been a nightmare. Having 2 non-scum players who would show scum when investigated would make seer incredibly unreliable. Would Muffle really cripple the role like that?

[MAFIA] Is this Werewolf?

At least we still have 3 confirmed town, that's a strong position to be in.

LockeZ may have a point about looking at who were the first people to vote for psy. Gonna review yesterday's posts.

[MAFIA] Is this Werewolf?

So either we have a bodyguard who for some reason didn't protect Fomar, or the wolves didn't agree on a target. This just gets more perplexing.

btw, I know my hammer on psy probably seemed to come from nowhere, but he had more votes on him than Emily, we only had an hour left, and since Dudesoft is confirmed town I knew there was no reason to doubt his arguments are anything but genuine, so backing him up made sense at the time.

[MAFIA] Is this Werewolf?

See, now I'm torn, because I agree that *someone* needs to go today but if I hammer psy and he flips town, you're just going to come after me harder.

Fuck it, we don't have the luxury of time at this point.

#lynch psy_wombats

[MAFIA] Is this Werewolf?

One other thing I'm curious about with the sorcerer: their job is to find the seer for the mafia, but they can't communicate with scum; how exactly are they supposed to help with that information once found? Just try to steer a lynch vote in the direction of the person they know is the seer? I guess it's moot now but I was just wondering mechanically how that was supposed to be played.

[MAFIA] Is this Werewolf?

I still have some iffy feelings about Emily's objection to a nolynch day, and voting for you mainly because you read someone else as town doesn't sit right either.

[MAFIA] Is this Werewolf?

Ah, so that's how they find the seer. Interesting.

[MAFIA] Is this Werewolf?

psy, you say demon and Emily are your top picks for scum. Of the two, which one would you say has given you the strongest reading?