I am simply a dangerous tester. Don't believe me? Then give me a game and I'll prove it.

Fear the lord of darkness!



Mafia Championship 2021 - invitation

Just dropped by to add another vote for cap. I think a lot of us on rmn play mafia on a more casual level. I know that's probably one big reason I'm not good at it. I don't really play it anywhere else.

Good luck out there and represent us well.

Sheriff Mafia (GAME OVER)

Cave is the real villain in this story. I was a mere trapper trying to avenge my partner while ridding the land of wild gunmen who might shoot up the town for no reason. Cave stabbed my partner with his blade, and then turned his gaze toward the innocent cowboys living on the land.

Sheriff Mafia (GAME OVER)

I probably should have just not posted before I left for work. I only had enough time to skim the posts, and I figured since psy was the other person I had been after all game the switch would be fine.

Sheriff Mafia (GAME OVER)

Rip. Just got home. I came in as a one team while mostly busy during the day so that affected my playing a bit I think. It's also hard to think of a dummied down role. I should of put more thought into the ranger claim. My other thought was a 1 shot information role but I felt like that would have came off suspicious after going after psy for so long.

I actually did consider killing gourd since I could kill him all at once with my power too. The reason I didn't is because he wasn't a factor at all in me winning the game, and I felt like it was a better idea to reduce the player base as much as possible. Also, if I had lived tonight, I would have not killed anyone. Prob wouldnt of made a difference since I chose a poor claim though.

Sheriff Mafia (GAME OVER)

Quick post before I leave for work. I won't be back until tonight.

Psy's point is exactly why I think scum would not target gourd. Gourd does not count as town in player count conditions, What you just proposed (town, scum, gourd), doesn't scum win in that condition precisely because of the gourd not counting thing? I feel like that's a point scum would defend and you've been defending it all game.

#lynch Psy

Sheriff Mafia (GAME OVER)

I'm a ranger. not a rancher. I guess if gourd dies it means there's no longer a police force. Makes sense since everyone else has had wandering gun and such type roles.

I guess psy's point does make sense. I kind of don't see the value in it though because scum would have to use 2 nk while being down a player to kill someone who doesn't actually matter to their win con. I'm also looking at the current player base. If we were up against 3 scum originally, then a mislynch here and the game is over. If were down to 1 scum we still have an extra day to get it right.

Sheriff Mafia (GAME OVER)

I die when the sheriff dies. I guess I should have posted that too. Also it may be worth considering why it's a different win condition. I guess I am wrong to call it a power, but altiya was town and only had that win condition, and no power and I guess that's what is throwing me off. That and time constraints cause I only have time to post at night.

Anyways that's all I have time for tonight.

Sheriff Mafia (GAME OVER)

I'm a ranger.

I only win if the sheriff is alive. This is one reason I came down so hard on cave, since his win condition conflicts with my own. Cave was far more actively trying to pursue that option than altiya as well. The other reason is I feel like a power to win with the sheriffs death isn't necessarily a town only ability. I think scum could just as easily have it and just keep that little tidbit from their partner. That's my conspiracy theory at least but I could be wrong.

The other person I'm wary of still is psy. Not to say I think he's necessarily scum now, but I don't see the reasoning behind protecting gourd unless he came to the same conclusion as me. There's absolutely no reason for scum to go after him otherwise because the sheriff doesn't pertain to their normal win condition. The problem then is he should be suspicious of either altiya or cave of being scum with said power. One big reason I'm suspicious of cave is he essentially had 2 powers, whereas the rest of us only have 1. I guess dueling does make him more vunerable, but what a play would it be to oust his scum partner right away (and get away with it because it was odd), only to then later win due to his win with the sheriffs death power.

That all said, I'm still more suspicious of cave than I am psy.

#lynch cave

Sheriff Mafia (GAME OVER)

Looks like about 22 hours if I'm looking at that right. Laying a vote down and having 22 hours pass with no other comment on someone who flipped scum I can see as a suspicious point.

Sheriff Mafia (GAME OVER)

I thought it was fine. It was the early stage of the odd vs cave choice, and in a choice between a confirmed role, and a role that you found suspicious elements in, it did make sense at that point. It looks like libby never did post after that. I could see her sticking with it after ozzy's claim. I didn't really look at how much time passed between that and odds hammer so I should probably do that.

I don't think fomar had that anti sheriff alignment. It looked to me that his whole role was revealed on death, even the part where his alignment wasn't supposed to flip which is the part I found strange.

Altiya, what do you think of cave being a duelist on top of having your role?