New account registration is temporarily disabled.

DEMONLORD5000'S PROFILE

I am simply a dangerous tester. Don't believe me? Then give me a game and I'll prove it.

Fear the lord of darkness!

Search

Filter

Sheriff Mafia (GAME OVER)

Not seeing anything that sells me on a liberty lynch. Also thinking on it more, I'm not buying that cave had both a duel and a lynch sheriff power combined all into one.

Unless he really is unlimited duel shot and is making us think he was bluffing by not using it today with the option of winning as non-town with altiya in that scenario. Bit of a stretch but that's current conspiracy theory.

Sheriff Mafia (GAME OVER)

Reread gourds ability. He is protected from one lynch. I still think it's weird cave jumped on it, but I guess it does make the lynch sheriff to win slightly less believable.

I still think cave's claim to have it is weirder though.

I'm going back to reread stuff now that I have some time.

Sheriff Mafia (GAME OVER)

Been busy with thanksgiving. I'd like to add that I do not have a kill gourd to win condition. In fact Altiya made it sound like a lone wolf condition that nobody else would have...which makes me question why cave has it. I didn't really see a cave lynch over someone like Psy or cap until now, but I find that incredibly suspicious. There was nothing like that in Fomars flip either...which makes me think cave just took a big risk, or Altiya is lying. Between those two, it's far more suspicious that cave jumped on it.

I need to check, but I believe the sheriff is bulletproof, not lynchproof, which would give credit to Altiya's claim. I agree it'd be nigh impossible to pull off though.

#lynch cave

Sheriff Mafia (GAME OVER)

I actually think psy's vanilla point is interesting. It doesn't clear the suspicion around psy himself though. I find it interesting that he put her in the scummish category while at the same time stating he didn't think she was scum if ozzy's vanilla claim was real.

I'd say if I were to vote it'd be either Psy or Cap. Psy has been weird all game with some of his comments and the way he voted. The only reason I might spare psy is just to see if anyone dies tonight, but scum psy could easily withhold his kill and not look suspicious by doing so. The odds of scum hitting whoever he protected is also pretty slim since he used it right away and there are a lot of players alive.

As for cap, I'm more scum neutral on him. In other words There are things there that make him feel slightly scummy, but not enough there to where I feel that strongly about it. The town reading gourd stood out the most of me, because it would most likely be scum to not pay enough attention to miss such a big detail. Also of note is him voting cave, changing his mind and saying killing cave is a mistake, only to then not vote odd.

I could throw down a Psy lynch right now, but I'm not actually sure how many votes are on him. We haven't heard from Altiya in awhile so I don't want to avoid hammering someone just yet.

Sheriff Mafia (GAME OVER)

Hey guys! It's truly unfortunate with what happened to jeroen. I was traveling with him to town, and then he took a tumble down the old dusty trail, only to then get dragged into a ditch by his own horse.

On a serious note, this is interesting. Fomar died and had his alignment reveal. Did his alignment reveal on death get blocked?

I also see no reason to go for cave after he killed scum n1. Looks like ozzy, cap, altiya, and psy were the one's to go after caved. Ozzy and cap shifted, whereas altiya and psy stayed on cave.

Not feeling any way or the other about altiya's post. I do feel like psy had rather poor reasoning yesterday.

I was also reading the rules and I think this one generates more discussion. Particularly the: It is possible that not all players in the same faction will have the exact same win condition.

That being said, I think leaving the sheriff be is fine because we were explicitly told that the sheriff is town aligned. This does make me think there is more than just the town and scum factions though.

Eiyuden Chronicle

Figured I'd bump this. For anyone who hasn't been following the kicstarter, they have reached all of their stretch goals, and it also the 3rd most funded kickstarter game. All of the stretch goals that they hit sound amazing too.

[MAFIA] Is this Werewolf?

Well guess that's game as soon as someone hammers me. I'm not going to throw the game and self sacrifice, but assuming there are three scum I'm pretty sure we lose with my death. I'm blaming our bodyguard because fomar was most suspicious of me and would have liked proved my innocence on day 2...but whatever.

[MAFIA] Is this Werewolf?

Forgot to lynch.

#lynch Emily

[MAFIA] Is this Werewolf?

I'm home now. Not much I can really say that I haven't already said though. Here's something to consider though: Notice that emily has been buddying up to me and my points whenever she makes an argument. Do you really think scum is going to do that rather than try to distance themselves from each other? There's also the point that emily jumped on the psy train quickly like I did.

That's pretty much my argument. I don't advise killing me since I'm town, but there isn't really a strong case I can make against it.

[MAFIA] Is this Werewolf?

No lynch would have gave us no information again, and it also looked like we had no bodyguard. If no lynch happened it could have potentially been us down a mason on day 3 with no information and major suspicions on why psy didn't die. I'd argue a no lynch could of been worse for us.