EDCHUY'S PROFILE

edchuy
You the practice of self-promotion
1624

Search

Filter

Monster Hunter Review

Shayoko, congrats on getting your first review accepted! I noticed you've been trying to provide feedback for many games, so this is progress for you. Don't worry, you'll get better in writing reviews the more of them you write. Be aware that some reviews (the ones were you criticize the game and give it a low rating) aren't taken kindly by the developers or fans of the game. That said, stick to your opinions and make sure to justify any observation as well as you can ...

Rust and Blood Review

author=Caz
Yeah I was out past 21:00 in one area and the jazzhand monsters came to get me. :<


The horror, the horror ... :-X

Solar Platypus Review

author=slashphoenix
I only remember a few Atari games, like this little chicken-crossing-the-road one my friend had.

That would be Freeway. There was no winning, losing or score. You just played until you got bored of it!

Channel Changer Episodes 1-3 Review

Wow, Erave you finally commented after all this time! This was among my early streak of reviews during a stretch when I was unemployed and I'd like to think was a pretty decent one. I see you still have that "Last Legend" game in perm development. Although it is a useful exercise to reminisce what could have been, perhaps you could focus your efforts and finish that one.

Pom Gets Wi-Fi Review

Well, it would be nice if somebody were able to replicate the buzz organically. Unfortunately, though, there aren't enough of us regulars to do so even if we all did it at the same time. Perhaps if some of the lurkers and drive by downloaders somehow became active members it might happen someday without outside help. Oh well ...

Pom Gets Wi-Fi Review

Nobody complained about this fair review ... the gameĀ“s no longer in RMN's front page in the "Buzzing Games", although it's still in the top 10. Maybe Pom's craze is finally winding down. And all those drive-by RMN members are nowhere to be seen. Will the game win anything come Misao time? Will there ever be another RMN game with a such a level of buzz within a short period of time (about six weeks by my calculations)?

Pom Gets Wi-Fi Review

Everybody's entitled to their own opinion. It's a matter of how it is expressed. Regardless of whether it's simple feedback or a review, as long as the intent (this is in the eye of the beholder) is to provide constructive criticism, I'm OK with it. Just because we might not agree with someone else's, it doesn't mean we shouldn't treated it with consideration and respect.

Phantom Legacy (Redux) Review

Something tells me I ought to make this my next game to play and review. I'll read this review post factum to see how my impression compares to yours, Sated.

Lunar Wish: Orbs of Fate Review

author=Link_2112
Reviews are opinion and nobody should change their opinion for other people. A game is meant to be enjoyed by others, so it should cater to other people.


Thus, the "utopic" objectivity that people have been preaching for reviews is myopic at best. I'll rather give or receive honest, fair, respectful and constructive criticism, any day. People will have different levels of appreciation of the different elements of the game, which is good and bad since it is impossible to please everybody in every way. The one thing that can be done, though, is to strive to get better and hopefully, in the process, please more people in more ways.

Lunar Wish: Orbs of Fate Review

author=obsorber
Papasan, well said.


Reactions like the ones that this review has produced are one of the reasons which prevent potential reviewers from submitting them. The review and reviewer become the subjects of discussion rather than the actual game.