PSY_WOMBATS'S PROFILE

Dememorize
a 2.5d explorer/horror game about NEURAL-9, a memory disease that spreads via eye contact

Search

Filter

[Game Over] Cheesecake Mafia

Frogge you're physically hurting me.

[Game Over] Cheesecake Mafia

WAS IT UK OR AMERICAN ENGLISH??

[Game Over] Cheesecake Mafia

@Gourd Hahahaha okay yeah if they were pushing it then it was meant to frame Marrend and not a mental slip. I believe you're innocent as well because you wouldn't have mentioned that and would've said it looked like a slip.

@Frogge jesus does this happen like twice a game I swear

[Game Over] Cheesecake Mafia

author=InfectionFiles
See, that's what I was thinking. CAVE said he got a PM. about getting his roles swapped. How exactly do we know that wasn't a butterspreader lie?

Cave's an obvious choice for a role swap. He doesn't know what role he was, so he can't say "Hey guys, I was watermelon announcer. So if anyone flips announcer, they were scum!" So I believe him on the swap. Kloe seems to be making it pretty clear what caused what this game.

@Ratty: What happened to your whole scum-must-be-on-slack thing? Do you still think that's valid reasoning and that YM is scum?

[Game Over] Cheesecake Mafia

author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
the likelihood of marrend using that phrase again and not realising that it could be linked back to him is infinitely greater than someone else pulling off a framejob involving two year old forum quotes

yeah this is why I think if anyone is intentionally incriminating Marrend here, it's Gourd, because who the hell else would remember that?

[Game Over] Cheesecake Mafia

author=Ratty524
How could you come to the conclusion that Marrend is a possible scum when that would mean mafia would basically out themselves? Hinting at themselves would be painfully easy to see, and stupid (I'm assuming mafia isn't stupid, here). Their PMs were deliberate, all right, but I'm almost POSITIVE that it's to draw our attention on non-scum.

It could be accidental and Marrend incriminated himself. It could intentionally incriminating to Marrend in which case it's someone who played piano's game or Gourd just faked it. Both seem reasonable to me. My guess is intentionally incriminating because why else would scum send it? It accomplishes no other visible purpose.

[Game Over] Cheesecake Mafia

@piano Odd named you as the author, of course you thought of your own conversations. Did you seriously jump to that slack conversation just from Gourd's post? I am not at all unsure about Ratty. Based on what Odd has described of his message, do you think that it's a copy/paste of something you said? Or a copy/paste of something Ratty said? Like this is the only reason I have to distrust you right now, this fact combined with that you and Ratty are both trying to push the "Ratty is being framed" narrative. It is very clear to me that Ratty slipped up when Odd named you instead of himself and Ratty jumped the gun on the "it was YM."

I have no opinion on Marrend. I think that's useless to reason about. The information came from scum and they didn't just send a taunting PM to gourd to be smug, they did it for a reason. My guess would be either Marrend or Gourd is scum. Ratty is undoubtedly scum.

[Game Over] Cheesecake Mafia

I think there wouldn't be anything printed if Frogge was blocked. But having Gourd choke and writhe on the floor, and then Frogge sulking or whatever would sure implied that Frogge got the poison there okay but it just didn't work out.

[Game Over] Cheesecake Mafia

author=pianotm
@ IF

Or, following Occam's Razor, what if the Odd Spice Salesman just blocked Frogge's action, which we all expected would happen?

Read Kloe's flavor. He wasn't blocked, the poisoning just failed.

[Game Over] Cheesecake Mafia

@piano: Notice how you immediately know that a bunch of people have had that conversation. That's what makes it a logical leap for Ratty to only think of that exact one time on slack and be so convinced that his exact words were in that PM. You don't see Liberty coming out and saying "I had that conversation! It must be quoting me!" She trusted Odd to correctly identify the sender. So did I. Ratty didn't even consider Odd's opinion and skipped straight to "YM explain yourself."

author=InfectionFiles
I dont understand how mafia sending messages that make it obvious who mafia are is a good idea or role
if Marrend is mafia, why say that? unless he just doesn't really realize how obvious and trackable that is.

It's just a tactic to spread confusion. We can't reason about whether it came from Marrend or not. It could be sent to make us think "only Marrend would send that, so therefore Marrend isn't it." But knowing that, Marrend could've /actually/ sent it to prove his innocence, etc. However, it relies that we search the site for specific mentions of certain keywords. All we can conclude from this is that someone on scumteam played piano's game and saw how LockeZ got nailed, which is a bunch of people.