PSY_WOMBATS'S PROFILE

Dememorize
a 2.5d explorer/horror game about NEURAL-9, a memory disease that spreads via eye contact

Search

Filter

[Game Over] Cheesecake Mafia

Alright, in all seriousness though: Leave Frogge alone. If he scumhunts and kills with us, great, we get an extra daykill for a while. We gain nothing by lynching him as opposed to later. He's as much a threat to mafia at lylo as he is to us.

@Liberty in the original rules, the chef only had 3 doses. It was later changed to a 50% success rate. I highly doubt Frogge is lying. No way he pulls this kind of gambit without some serious coaching and he's responding way too naturally for that.

[Game Over] Cheesecake Mafia

Hahaha we can solve both problems at once if Frogge targets himself tonight.

[Game Over] Cheesecake Mafia

My guess is mafia will take him off our hands long before then.

[Game Over] Cheesecake Mafia

@Liberty I don't think you're scum, I think you're misguided town. I was trying to give an example of day 1 behavior that can lead us to killing off actual scum.

[Game Over] Cheesecake Mafia

author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
alternately we kill the claimed serial killer

Can you explain why we'd do this? He's basically said he wants to be a vigilante.

author=Liberty
If you can't garner any information from a night kill then you're obviously either stupid or not looking to do so... meaning working for mafia.

Last game I straight up assassinated cave because he made the first semi-serious accusation of the game, and against me. No one cared. I'm not saying it's impossible to read, but it's not exactly cut and dry.

author=pianotm
Yeah, Frogge. That role claim was probably not a good idea. It's one thing to claim any of the others, but a serial killer/vigilante role is a huge target. Until I hear counterclaims, though, I'll rule you out as scum. If you're still alive tomorrow, expect me to be very suspicious of you.

Kind of wish you hadn't stated this because now we can't rule out that they left him alive to get us to lynch him. While I definitely would not have advised Frogge to claim, I see no reason not to test him by selecting his target tonight.

[Game Over] Cheesecake Mafia

Not sure I get you, IF. Do you think he's like breadcrumbed or something?

[Game Over] Cheesecake Mafia

Uh Frogge, I see no reason to doubt your claim but you realize you've basically just guaranteed that you'll be immediately nightkilled.

[Game Over] Cheesecake Mafia

We do have some info though Liberty! For instance, you're arguing for a nolynch, which is helpful for mafia! Therefore I can reason that you're more likely than, say, OddRabbit to be mafia! (I'm assuming you do this every game so I won't actually advance that argument) Already though I do have people I think are more likely than others and several people who are straight up exonerated. It's not like we have nothing to work with, and we'll have even more if there's a daykill.

[Game Over] Cheesecake Mafia

I thought the pancake was a vigilante but apparently they just get an extra weighted vote, it's not all that powerful unless by some miracle they survive to the endgame. The only other non-mafia kill we get comes from the bad chef, who has a 50% success rate and is uh like >50% gonna get killed by the mafia tonight.

[Game Over] Cheesecake Mafia

I got ninja'd by like 20 posts and a serial killer confession, welp