PSY_WOMBATS'S PROFILE

Dememorize
a 2.5d explorer/horror game about NEURAL-9, a memory disease that spreads via eye contact

Search

Filter

Last night I had my first stuffed crust pizza since I was a rowdy teen – and it tasted just like the nineties

author=Craze
WHY ARE THERE INCESTUAL OVERTONES

It's a Trump Thing (tm)

[GAME OVER] Spy vs. Mafia

Ahaha yeah after reading all that, that's definitely not you Kloe, sorry.

I haven't had a chance to go back and fully compare Green's complete scumchat log to everyone that's still under suspicion, but here's some stuff:
- Green starts out with English spellings (plus blighter) but drops the 'u' from honor /after/ LockeZ is dead and the chat is compromised. So possibly they're a non-American who cottoned and changed their style, or a non-native speaker
- Orange suggests that the mafia abstain from voting against Ratty. Voting for/against Ratty on day 1 shouldn't be considered evidence
- Green has a habit of not using contractions, see "do not" "cannot," "would not," etc, but still uses the occasional "don't"
- Green has minor usage issues, see "caught out," "who is applicable for death" - and possibly "pestilience"

Isrieri has a pretty distinctive voice so I highly doubt it's him unless he took steps from the start to disguise himself. Gourd also throws around ! ~ ... XD so for the same reason I suspect him less. Gourd is also American so let's not lynch him, okay? My best guess would be NeverSilent at this point, but it's worth noting that on page 1, NeverSilent spells "honour" but Green spells it "honor"... but this is after the scum realize they're being watched. Tungerman is suspicious. YM is vaguely suspicious but ehh.

But I reallly think it's more likely NeverSilent at this point than Gourd. If someone wants to read through every single post in this thread I'm sure they'll be able to find something.

Character Design!

This is pretty informative, definitely consider submitting as an article.

[GAME OVER] Spy vs. Mafia

Hahaha /Liberty/ almost got hammered? She's totally above suspicion. I even thought she was an agent but didn't point it out (agents need to be safe). She was wink/nudging someone about her identity (with the bolding/keywords) well after Orange's identity was revealed. Who was she signaling? She'd be the only mafia left at that point and it'd make zero sense for her. Unfortunately it looks like she might be gone tomorrow -- let's try and get Green right today.

author=Liberty
Mr Green uses Americanised spelling and Kloe lives in England. There's no way she'd drop the 'u' from honour! Thus, I'm sure it's not her. I mean, yeah, Green could have done that deliberately to throw off the scent but I dunno, changing your native spelling of words? It definitely doesn't feel like a Kloe thing to do.

You're right, my apologies Kloe. She wouldn't attempt to disguise something so subtle as the u without disguising the muuuch more obvious things. Plus there are zero exclamation points in that text which is pretty telling haha. We can also rule out YM by the same logic, right?

Anyway, here's why I thought Green sounded like Kloe: lots of questions, shorter and sometimes inverted sentence structure, and using 'shall.' I'm abiding by the no-external-searching rule this go around, but within this thread, the only people using 'shall' are Kloe (twice) and NeverSilent (once)... The sentence structure looks a little weird for NeverSilent at the beginning though, but I could *kind* of see it at the end. Maybe we can guess that Green is disguising their voice to frame Kloe or just being weird in general. The only other quirk I noticed was that Green capitalized 'rabbit' and 'rat' which would be a thing in German but I don't think NeverSilent would make a mistake like that. Who knows. Will think more later.

[GAME OVER] Spy vs. Mafia

Alright last post before bed -- maybe I'll catch up in the afternoon tomorrow, maybe not.

@Ratty are you confident that you know the identity of your fellow agent? Don't say the name obviously but that'd be good information.

I'm curious why on earth the Green in the chatlog votes to kill OddRabbit.

It looks like our options for Green are either YM or Kloe, if by process of elimination if nothing else haha. Thinking YM is guilty requires thinking that he 1) intentionally wrote like Kloe in mafia chat 2) screwed over LockeZ by suggesting we analyze the Orange post 3) left Ratty alone after it became clear he was an agent. Not impossible and I kind of love the irony of the genius-YM-plan-backfires theory, but I think it might be worth considering occam's razor. Thinking Kloe is guilty requires believing that she 1) suggested analyzing mafia time analysis, even though it might incriminate her 2) pretended to be clueless about Joyless. Not /that/ much of a stretch, considering it's her writing style in the chat and refusal to vote against LockeZ. I'll probably look like a huge asshole if I'm wrong about this though.

Something else kind of damning:
author=Kloe
Libby doesn't seem like the oddest choice, I think her writing style could match with Green, but really I would be grasping at straws to explain any sort of way that Libby could be Green.

She posted this /before/ Ratty gave us Green's chatlog. She obviously couldn't check Green's writing style before the post, so this is just plain made up. (...or Kloe's an agent, which is uh unlikely)

She also mentioned earlier that Odd was her preferred random-kill vote. You'll notice Green in the chatlog voting to off Odd.

author=Kloe
Well, my auto correct on my pc does "each-other" so maybe the culprit simply used autocorrect? I hope not but sadly that may be true.

This also seems like fabrication to me. I'll keep an open mind for now though.

[GAME OVER] Spy vs. Mafia

author=Isrieri
What the fu-

Guys. Guys did you not read all that shit back there? Its Yellow Magi-ITS YELLOW FRICKIN' MAGIC.

That's him in the chat there. He's doing a bit. He's behind all of it. It all makes so much sense!

Kloe!? What do you mean Kloe??!

author=Kloe
Tung, not accusing you of anything but I want you to try to be honest with us, did you be a vigillante and kill Joyless last night?


Why would she ask that? If she was mafia she could see the chat! She would know exactly why Joyless died.

Hahahaha so maybe YellowMagic figured out that he could be identified by voice in the mafia chat, so he intentionally chooses a different writing style to incriminate someone else, then suggests that we analyze writing style, knowing we'll eventually find who he's imitating? Then it backfires horribly when we actually guess the other mafia correctly? If this is what really happened then that's just perfect haha.

[GAME OVER] Spy vs. Mafia

I think this might be solvable by not allowing the copying of /any/ private chat messages, similar to how we can't quote PMs from our moderator. It opens up the spelling quirks can of worms plus it can be very easy to identify a voice.

Like, even without metagaming and just reading posts in this thread, that Green chatlog reeks of Kloe. I guess it could be someone else and I could look more tomorrow but uhhh that really jumps out at me. Plus her multiple posts defending LockeZ even after damning evidence, not voting against him, LockeZ sticking up for her in the beginning... Would be interested in the opinions of others who are more familiar.

Thanks for your sacrifice Ratty, you'll probably be RIP tomorrow but maybe we can win before then haha.

[GAME OVER] Spy vs. Mafia

author=Kloe
Well, my auto correct on my pc does "each-other" so maybe the culprit simply used autocorrect? I hope not but sadly that may be true.

Please Hammer Time whoever it is that is left!

^^ because I don't know what to make of this, considering she never did vote against LockeZ. When you're around would be interested to hear your reasoning Kloe.

[GAME OVER] Spy vs. Mafia

@Liberty I'm sorry, really, I wasn't aware there's an unwritten rule about this -- I was just trying to be useful :/

@Isrieri I buy your reasoning, mostly, but YM did point out to analyze the post from Orange, and the content had suspecting LockeZ immediately because of its complexity alone, spelling quirks aside... would seem risky for mafia but who knows

I think we could have luck looking back through LockeZ's posts and figure out who he tried to incriminate and protect. I doubt he'd be looking to misdirect people this early. That exonerates oddRabbit and Ratty, for instance. Very early on he also argued that YM, Liberty, Gourd, Kloe, and Ratty should all be kept alive early so if LockeZ had already figured out who his fellow mafia was, it's probably one of them.

I'm also convinced Liberty is innocent though -- She was the first to vote against LockeZ after I posted, but I think she has the skill to to have gotten my stuff thrown out or me modkilled for metagaming, but voted against LockeZ even if went against her sense of fairness.

Has TangledLion been around a while? Like would he have been able to immediately identify Kloe if she were Green?

[GAME OVER] Spy vs. Mafia

author=TungerManU
Alright! So apparently we hammered LockeZ before letting TL tell us more about Green. That's a shame, but I'm pretty sure we can figure it out anyway.

Joyless's death brings up a lot of questions. She can't have been modkilled, seeing as her alignment has been revealed. However, there doesn't seem to be any reason for scum to target her. Theories?

Possibly the agents have a nightkill sort of thing as well and are just targeting the "least useful" town player. Oh well.