PSY_WOMBATS'S PROFILE

Dememorize
a 2.5d explorer/horror game about NEURAL-9, a memory disease that spreads via eye contact

Search

Filter

JOKER WILD MAFIA (GAME OVER)

#cancel
#vote WaKa

While I'm confident Dyluck isn't town, now I'm just scared he's joker. I know he's paying attention, so the dumb stuff is /weird/ (90% of this is him tying the vote on D2) and it makes me think he's actively trying to draw aggro. If it comes down to LYLO and he's alive, totally kill him, but while there are other people I think have a decent shot to be scum and are definitely not the joker, I'll take those people first.

I also find Clint less likely to be joker after today. If he was joker and saw that his previous strategy was making people think "that guy's the joker," he'd change his strategy. But his gimmick is the same today.

JOKER WILD MAFIA (GAME OVER)

author=Dyluck
If I'm Scum, the only reason I would save Libby is if she is also Scum, right? So if you think Libby is not Scum, then I should also be not Scum.

well, to pull this card, basically -- if you thought you'd be in trouble the next day because you knew she'd flip town

JOKER WILD MAFIA (GAME OVER)

Forgot to refresh and missed Dyluck's Waka vote. It makes me want Dyluck more dead and WaKa less dead.

(also kind of makes me more think Dyluck=joker though, especially with Clint looking less joker-y today)

JOKER WILD MAFIA (GAME OVER)

Not sure why Eggbert has drawn so much attention. They seem fine.

I don't like Waka, if only for the extremely meat reason that he posted immediately at the start of day 2 when it's highly likely that scum used info posted during the night (in the last 90 minutes of the night or so) to target Shinan. So he was awake in the driver seat, but also didn't contribute anything meaningful. I am fine with him dying today and will switch my vote if needed.

I still don't trust Dyluck though. He made a case against Liberty on day 2, pushed her half the day, then at the last second cast a vote that /saved/ her. My first explanation that made sense for this was that they're the scumteam and day2 fighting was an act, (but that would be some really really good acting from both of them?). But at any rate it's just baffling that he was back on her today, after a claim that I found pretty town-y.

so #vote Dyluck, I'd be a lot more confident in that vote if I weren't starting to think he's joker

JOKER WILD MAFIA (GAME OVER)

Can we petition to have everyone who hasn't posted in 48 hours just straightup modkilled

JOKER WILD MAFIA (GAME OVER)

author=Liberty
I did check Dyluck tonight and he did nothing. Boring-ass brat, that one. Doesn't clear him for scum, if there's a two-fer team but I'm more inclined to think he's safe.

I asked about this -- the nightkill does not count as a night action. So even on a one-scum team, you wouldn't see any activity from scum.


Given that, I just don't think spy and alchemist have much utility, regardless of alignment, to the point where Ozzy's claim doesn't ring alarm bells for being strictly negative utility.

I could possibly buy Dyluck=jester just because he's acted two days in a row to drag the game out, but Clint=jester still makes a lot more sense.

JOKER WILD MAFIA (GAME OVER)

If we were in scum-cahoots with Liberty, I sure wouldn't be voting to kill her with only hours left in the day.

And I agree that that's /why/ she posted that, but "trying to appear towny on the brink of death" is a trait shared by both town and scum. I guess though yeah, reconsidering, it does make sense to both claim as spy and nk the doc because it makes the spy claim look 100% legit.

JOKER WILD MAFIA (GAME OVER)

author=Dyluck
However, my biggest sus is still most likely Psy. Plus even though he talked like he was gonna vote Libby when Ozzy was still a possibility, he never actually did vote her until the very end when it was looking bad for Libby and he jumped in and voted. It could be both Libby AND Psy.

I voted when I did because someone needed to die yesterday. You can't win a game without daykilling people (which is why no-kill is anti-town). There's no advantage to keeping people alive if you're unsure of their alignment as it just results in a larger suspect pool when you're eventually forced to vote -- scum kills people who look towny, not suspicious people. I'm worried the game is going to come down to an endgame with like, 4+ posters with 4 posts each still alive and no evidence to decide which among them is scum.

JOKER WILD MAFIA (GAME OVER)

Welp. Before the flip I was 90% convinced that scumteam was Liberty+Dyluck with the way Dyluck leapt in to save her. And while I guess yeah it's possible the PRs aren't specified as town PRs specifically, I now think Dyluck/Liberty is an impossible team because Dyluck was the one to point it out.

Actually, I think Liberty's claim has to be legit. If she was scum, she wouldn't post that then kill Shinan based on that information. She'd just keep shut.

I'm trying to think how the train on Ozzy looks knowing that Shinan is town and Liberty is probably town. It doesn't say anything about EggbertX because they started it. I'm town-y on Ozzy as well (if less a bit now) so guess that's a wash.

@Liberty: did you spy on anyone tonight?

JOKER WILD MAFIA (GAME OVER)

I got clarification -- I am dumb, majority vote will kill even without hammer. So if people are around it is possible to do something that isn't killing Libby -- I think she's a pretty good choice but would prefer Dy.