New account registration is temporarily disabled.

PHOENIX WRIGHT: ACE MAFIA

Posts

I'm new here so...

1)Is day 1 always this quite? Or are the other participants always this inactive?
CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
On sunny days, I go out walking
1142
author=MirrorMasq
as well as you always such agressive and fast with decisions,


Looks like I need a new avatar.

Who do you think is probable town and who do you think is probable scum at this point?


This question is extended to everyone else.

Ivory, it was louder last game, but I have a feeling it will pick up.
Six pages on day one seems plenty loud to me.
Ahh ok thanks.

author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
Who do you think is probable town and who do you think is probable scum at this point?

This question is extended to everyone else.


Well, up until now, only a few has taken part in the discussion so I'd like to see what the others has to say before making a decision.
CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
On sunny days, I go out walking
1142
The problem with that is that someone could easily just say the same thing about you and others, constantly waiting for someone to talk until the day runs out because of a feedback loop of nothingness.
@Shinan
Yeah but the ones doing the talking are mostly cave_dog and zeuzio soooo...

PS: <3 your avvie cave_dog
Ok, tbh, I think you're the most suspicious. Probably because you're aggressive (considering this is just the 1st day). But since YM said you've always been like that in the previous games so meh. *shrugs*
Yellow Magic
Could I BE any more Chandler Bing from Friends (TM)?
3229
Of course there's always the chance that CAVE_DOG exhibits slight changes in his modus operandi. For that reason I'm going to keep an eye on him as he could make a very dangerous Mafia member.
Marrend
Guardian of the Description Thread
21806
I don't really like how Despite isn't playing either, but I figure we can give him 'till the next phase of the game before we lynch him. If he's criminal again, that would be a rather... interesting scenario.

Anyway, I'm going to place my vote to #lynch MrChearlie. I'm kinda hoping my intuition is wrong about him, but if it turns out to be correct, we'll have one less criminal.
Trihan
"It's more like a big ball of wibbly wobbly...timey wimey...stuff."
3359
Okay, I've gotta go back to work soon so this will just be a quick statistics post really:

Posting frequency and role in previous game (people I'm suspicious of in bold):

CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK 23
Zeuzio 12
ivoryjones 11
MrChearlie (Villain) 10
Trihan 10
Yellow Magic (Hero) 9
rabitZ (Hero) 6
Gourd_Clae 5
MirrorMasq (Hero) 5
Marrend 4
Little Wing Guy (Villain) 3
Shinan (Hero) 3
SorceressKyrsty 3
chana 2
Dudesoft 2
Despite (Villain)
ldida1

Voting history with reasons:

1st vote Zeuzio for CAVE_DOG (cancelled) (he was kidding)
2nd vote CAVE_DOG for Zeuzio (cancelled) (thinks he must be scum after so many games of being town, same reason Zeuzio joke-voted him)
3rd vote MirrorMasq for nolynch (doesn't want a senseless day 1 lynch)
4th vote CAVE_DOG for Mirrormasq (seemingly arbitrary) (cancelled)
5th vote Yellow Magic for CAVE_DOG (using CAVE's post about lynching everyone against him) (cancelled)
6th vote rabitZ for Despite (just for tradition) (cancelled)
7th vote Shinan for Shinan (???)
8th vote Little Wing Guy for nolynch (didn't really give a reason)
9th vote Dudesoft for Shinan (to help his suicide)
10th vote Trihan for nolynch (nothing else concrete to go on)
11th vote chana for nolynch (can't see much of anything)
12th vote MrChearlie for Despite (wants him to talk) (cancelled)
13th vote MrChearlie for nolynch (convinced by Gourd saying he'll be executed if he doesn't talk)
14th vote CAVE_DOG for Zeuzio (because of Zeuzio's reaction to Gourd's town-is-overpowered post)
15th vote rabitZ for nolynch (on the back of Zeuzio's post about thinking Despite is town)
16th vote ivoryjones for nolynch (no real reason given)
17th vote SorceressKyrsty for nolynch (because we were absurdly reckless last game)
18th vote Marrend for MrChearlie ("intuition"?)

CAVE_DOG has voted for three different people today. He claims to be trying to hunt scum and for now I'll take him at his word, but I'm keeping an eye on him.

Anyone who has fewer posts than the person running the game is going to draw my attention too. This is the benchmark for the lowest amount of activity I'll let anyone slide with.

ivoryjones...I've got a small warning bell ringing for her because new players are usually quieter than this, but that's flimsy reasoning and not strong enough for a vote. Don't let her slip by just because she's new though.

ldida1 and Despite haven't posted today at all. This is par for the course for Despite, but ldida1 wasn't this quiet last game and it's the biggest thing I have so far. So:

#lynch ldida1
Trihan
"It's more like a big ball of wibbly wobbly...timey wimey...stuff."
3359
Sorry, MirrorMasq shouldn't be bolded.
Okay I will please Cave_Dog because I don't have anything to do
Chana: 2 post, nothing I can said, maybe to quiet for being chana?
Cave: He could be as really helpful as he could be really dangerous even if he is town. He could be town cause he acts the same but he could also be faking, at the end that was mafia do, so I will let the time speaks by himself about him. We could trust on him and lynch Zeuzio to see if he is innocent, if zeuzio is murder that will give me a better feeling about him, but if Zeuzio doesn't it would make me doubt more about what to do, so I pass.
Dudesoft: I can't said anything about him yet.
Marrend: Oh, he reminds me at the last game :P two intuition about sorceress and then Bam, vote lynch against her, it makes me laught that it was so similar. So I am just going to wait and see how he start acting.
Zeuzio: Very undecided, he loves/hate despite, making him the most suspicious for me at this moment, but well maybe he really missunderstood the things.
Little Wing Guy: two post. I can't said anything about him.
Despite:...
RabitZ: Well, he is looking for suspects it's seems. Day one, votes don't have a pretty solid foundation. So I am going to wait how he acts the next days, for now he seems townie.
MirrorMasq: He is the one who looks more townie of all.
Trihan: Well, his review makes me think he is townie
Ldida1:...
YellowMagic: He is being the same than the other games, and also I think he is innocent.
Krysty: two post, not enough information.
Shinan: Suicide is a serious thing and you cannot get conclusions out of it.
IvoryJones: She... seems innocent.
Marrend
Guardian of the Description Thread
21806
I secretly want to be defeated.

On a more serious note, I don't care if people are suspicious of me. I placed my vote where I think it should go and gave what reasons, as flimsy as they are, why I thought it should go there.
rabitZ
amusing tassadar, your taste in companionship grows ever more inexplicable
1349
Wha the hell.
Seems like a lost a lot of the discussion.

Ok, at this point I'm willing to give CAVE the benefit of the doubt.
As I said, even skimming quickly through the topic I don't see so many scumtells yet, but my gut feelings are against Dudesoft and Shinan at this point. They/OneOfThem could be mafia.

Shinan: Very quiet, suicide vote (?) I know he can certainly be aggresive and active if he wants to.

Dudesoft: Helping Shinan suicide (?) Maybe it was a ruse concocted by the two of them?

Of course, I have no way of proving they are mafia, but from what little info I have on everyone. That's my "suspicion" for today.
I’m not sure why you suspect me already Trihan, is it because I’ve put a no lynch, or because I’ve only posted three times so far? Oh well, unlike the last game I’ve got nothing to hide, so I could start flinging votes around without a care, and I can see CAVE_DOG’s point of view too, but that’s not my style. Just because I’ve put a no lynch now, doesn’t mean it’s set in stone.

Anyway, the actual main reason I put a no lynch vote is because of something CAVE_DOG said:

author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
There are eleven people who can be considered "town" for purposes of the town vs. scum votecount since we don't know what alignment, if any, the mystery role is. One of the independents might have killing powers as well, so this game could probably potentially go to LYLO within two days.

^I don't fancy taking a shot in the dark knowing that.

I’ve got no problem with any attention on me in this game. If you have any real reason to suspect me, let me know! I’ll try and keep my posts up a bit more too, but I can’t force myself to post just for the sake of it.
Trihan
"It's more like a big ball of wibbly wobbly...timey wimey...stuff."
3359
Nothing you've done specifically has made me suspect you Little Wing Guy, but I stated that the number of posts made by the person running the game is the minimum I will let people slide with, and you have fewer than that, so you are by definition lumped in with that crowd. It's nothing personal, but if I didn't include you I wouldn't be consistent with my own logic.
CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
On sunny days, I go out walking
1142
author=Trihan
Okay, I've gotta go back to work soon so this will just be a quick statistics post really:


2nd vote CAVE_DOG for Zeuzio (cancelled) (thinks he must be scum after so many games of being town, same reason Zeuzio joke-voted him)


For the record, this was also a jokevote.

As for Idida...you know that he will be modkilled at his current pace, right?
Marrend
Guardian of the Description Thread
21806
Wait, I thought there was no mod-killing?

author=Gourd_Clae
I don't think I'll do anything in particular to lurkers, unless someone else wants to play, I'll just leave them alone.


CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
On sunny days, I go out walking
1142
But later,

author=Gourd_Clae
I'll be honest, town is a tad overpowered. However, if they don't post in 3 day stages they will be executed, that sounds fairish.
author=Trihan
Nothing you've done specifically has made me suspect you Little Wing Guy, but I stated that the number of posts made by the person running the game is the minimum I will let people slide with, and you have fewer than that, so you are by definition lumped in with that crowd. It's nothing personal, but if I didn't include you I wouldn't be consistent with my own logic.


It was actually because you put “Villain” next to my name. I was thinking how it was a really early assumption to make about me. Yeaaah I’ve only just now realised you were referring to my role last game. Derp, dumb me. I might try reading next time. =)