DOCTER MAFIA: STOP THOSE SNATCHER SCUM!

Posts

Dudesoft
always a dudesoft, never a soft dude.
6309
CAVEDAWG, can we protect ourselves if we already have on Day One?
Dudesoft
always a dudesoft, never a soft dude.
6309
You mentioned we cannot repeat actions. I just want to clarify.
rabitZ
amusing tassadar, your taste in companionship grows ever more inexplicable
1349
Hey everyone I'm back, I've hardly been home these past few days. sorry.

I'm sorry "I haven't been too helpful".
what can I do to help dude, you want me to tell who I suspect?

I suspect TBG, Dudes and I'm still not sure about ivory OR liberty. though ivory and liberty are sooo agresive that they might actually be town.
Jeroen and MM pretty unreadable to me so far. Maybe Jeroen's two last games as host have gotten to him???

I think Chearlie's innocent too.
At least he's playing very pro-town.

Give me some time to better read the topic again, folks :)
rabitZ
amusing tassadar, your taste in companionship grows ever more inexplicable
1349
TBG because he claime with a real lot of certainty that he was the paranoic and then now he skimped on his protection and claims to not be sure again.

Since we do have to lynch someone tonight, I want to hear from him one last time before deciding on my vote.
@Mirror: There's been ample time for anyone who was CPR to jump in and contradict me. If there were someone who was CPR that wasn't me, jumping in to point out my so-called 'lies' would be a great move for town. It'd give people someone to band against. Unfortunately for your theory, there is never going to be someone else come forward as CPR because I am the CPR. Besides, once again, they would have killed themselves off on the first night.
'Oh, but maybe they didn't protect themselves!' - the person they protected would have died or gotten some text that points them out.
'Oh, but what if they protected no-one?' - why in the world would the not protect themselves on the first night when NO-ONE knew what kind of doctor they are. They'd want to find out just as much as anyone else.
'Oh, but...' - no. STFU. There's no possible way that I'm not CPR. Are we clear on this yet? Yes? Thank you. Now we can focus on actually catching scum.

And for my first trick I point towards both Chearlie and Mirror. Chearlie was 'confused' about exactly who protected and locked away whom, and the post that Mirror made right after is quite illuminating - basically calling him an idiot. Chearlie later retracts and says he protected Mirror and that Mirror was targeted. The opposite of what he claimed before. (Pages 25 and 26)

Add in that Mirror has repeatedly tried to drum up suspicion and a lynch against me, trying to say that I'm dangerous and should be killed off in case I kill off others... even after I've repeatedly said I'd prefer to not go on protection detail. And I just get a scummy vibe from he and Chearlie.

Lastly, two things that weren't answered:
Why did Ivory push for protecting LWG so hard? Did she find something of use in her protection?
And, what is the so-called plan Mirror wanted to use for someone who was confirmed town CPR?
As I have stated before, being suspicious of liberty is dumb since there is no reason on beleive so, like Liberty and I have said all this time, so leave that subject, also, yes I was confused, Since it said it is mirror Office I didn't analyze and give the fact of him being the paranoic but it was actually me the one who enter and closed the door. Also I understand the reasons of the scummy vibe from me, for the coincidence of Mirror Masq and My confusion, and maybe other things that from you point of view you can see. But I got nothing to prove it than my word. Although I ask you to trust me, if for any reasons you want to lynch me, at least it will confirm mirror as innocent so It wouldn't be so bad (also it is better than no lynch).
LWG's not back. I've wanted to hear from him first if he found anything regarding protecting me.
Dudesoft
always a dudesoft, never a soft dude.
6309
Liberty, for real. Protect me tonight. I'll protect myself. That should theorhetically cancel out your CPR. Then we'll know for sure. Unless of course a DOCTER agent tries to make this a trio party, in which case I'm fucked. At least we will know more than we do right now. I ask you, because you are an aggressive, potent player. Also we were both at the scene of the crime last night. This is the only way I can think of to clear both our names.
Then liberty would be deadmeat if she protects you.
Also, retract all your votes on TBG.
...Dudesoft plan sounds great, although he can be Naive or even doctor, and I am worry about you get being mod killed by repeating an action, but if it is allowed it is a great plan.

Also, reasons to retreact our votes on TBG?
I think he's actually telling the truth about 'vegging out' and not submitting a night action. I think. If he's mafia, I don't think he'd be 'vegging out'.
author=Liberty
Oh, but what if they protected no-one?' - why in the world would the not protect themselves on the first night when NO-ONE knew what kind of doctor they are. They'd want to find out just as much as anyone else.

Exactly. There's a possibility of killing yourself. And it's higher then be killed by mafia.

And yes, there's possibility. And no, I won't shut the fuck up. This is the mafia game and people can accuse you too. Get over it. You're like "I totally can't be mafia you stupid shiats" in every game.
And where exactly Chearlie was confused about who did he protected last night? Can't find it, sorry. And yeah, I'm trying to said you're dangerous. Because CPR is dangerous for town. Do you want to be less dangerous? Protect yourself or nobody tonight. Or at least not me, thank you.
Okay, it's either rabitZ, TBG or Dudesoft today. Those are in top of my list, so I can vote for either of them.
rabitZ
amusing tassadar, your taste in companionship grows ever more inexplicable
1349
What was your reason for thinking I was a good target for linching MM?

At least we agree on 2 out 3 today.
So I'm going to go ahead and #lynch TBG

I'm more interested on who should we protect tonight.
I think Liberty should definitely protect no one tonight, despite what dudesoft says.

Are we still on on the self protect thing?
One of the main questions there is: do we have the insane risk himself or someone else?

We haven't figured out who the insane is, so it might be better to protect ourselves.
author=ivoryjones
I think he's actually telling the truth about 'vegging out' and not submitting a night action. I think. If he's mafia, I don't think he'd be 'vegging out'.


You mean like, why would mafia act that he didn't use his doctor powers because he was vegging out? in other words why would mafia do something that it is not relevant for them?

#Cancel

That is a vague point but it is logical (if that is what you meant), so that leaves Jeroen and RabitZ, I will think about them both, although I am not against Dudes, I don't think he is mafia, and by the way his plan is great but Ivory is right, that would leave Liberty at danger, and otherwise than Mirror, she could be dangerous, that is thruth, but in other games if you find a vigilante you don wish him to be death, that would make mafia happy, not us.

I am trying to think a plan for defend Liberty's although I can't come up with a good plan, the only I have is that 2 persons that we think they are town and useful doctors, protect Liberty, and I will protect one of them, this will make mafia to think who to kill. they won't know who I am going to protect and role block, and they don't know who is the sane doctor (if we choose one) they can chose of 4 persons at the end, and at the end I will be the one who no one is protecting, so if Mafia likes to go safe they would go after me, and you will prove my inoccence as well as Mirror and dudesoft, withouth killing liberty that is a vigilante with powers more important than role blocker, although it is an exagerated plan with flaws, like how we are going to pick those 2 without picking mafia, and I don't think you will want to sacrifice some who actually can protect.

With your pardon, I am going to read the last chapter of Steins Gate VN.
Here's a thought. I could protect the supposed Paranoid and he could protect me back. Then someone could secretly protect him.

Or I could protect Dudes like he wants and he'll protect himself, and someone secretly protects me.

Everyone else just protect themselves. Though personally I think another go at the pairs thing would be good, just with different partners to last night (that's allowed). That way we might flush out more information. Say what you will about last night, be we did get more information, which is what we sorely need if we're to win.
CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
On sunny days, I go out walking
1142
Votecount for Day 3

Liberty: (1) Mirrormasq
thatbennyguy: (2) Ivoryjones Mrchearlie, Dudesoft, Rabitz

With 9 alive, it takes five to lynch. This day ends when a majority is reached or on Monday at 12 PM EST. That's in about 36 hours.

CAVEDAWG, can we protect ourselves if we already have on Day One?

Yes, you just can't do the same thing twice in a row.
Lib I thought about that, problem is, we don't know if someone will protect a paranoid secretly, so we can lose him easily. Also, we can't do it openly, because we'll lose someone else then.