LET'S DISCUSS MUSIC GENRES.
Posts
Pages:
1
Classifying music is too difficult. It's better to compare bands to other bands than trying to make up some obscure word to describe them. That's my opinion.
But I'm all for genres.. they are a pretty interesting way of describing music without saying anything about the instrumentation or theme of the music.
Check it: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_music_genres
From reading this, there's WAY too many types of metal.
most pretentious genre names i've heard: "funkcore", "post-hardcore", "opera metal", "nintendocore"
In my opinion.. genres come in 2 different pieces: The attribute, and the format. The attribute word is a descriptive word that explains how the music 'feels' without dominating the style of music.. usually by ethic and lyrical theme. The format word is what dictates the style and background of the music.. usually by guitar tones, rhythms, and vocal technique.
Attribute words: "core", "black", "doom", "electro", "post", "emo", etc.
Format words: "rock", "metal", "hardcore", "punk", "ska", etc.
There's some downright funny genre names, too. "Crack rock", "Nintendocore", "Stoner metal". I love it.
so.. what do you guys think of music genres? I think they're pretentious wastes of time, but they're pretty helpful sometimes.
But I'm all for genres.. they are a pretty interesting way of describing music without saying anything about the instrumentation or theme of the music.
Check it: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_music_genres
From reading this, there's WAY too many types of metal.
most pretentious genre names i've heard: "funkcore", "post-hardcore", "opera metal", "nintendocore"
In my opinion.. genres come in 2 different pieces: The attribute, and the format. The attribute word is a descriptive word that explains how the music 'feels' without dominating the style of music.. usually by ethic and lyrical theme. The format word is what dictates the style and background of the music.. usually by guitar tones, rhythms, and vocal technique.
Attribute words: "core", "black", "doom", "electro", "post", "emo", etc.
Format words: "rock", "metal", "hardcore", "punk", "ska", etc.
There's some downright funny genre names, too. "Crack rock", "Nintendocore", "Stoner metal". I love it.
so.. what do you guys think of music genres? I think they're pretentious wastes of time, but they're pretty helpful sometimes.
most pretentious genre names i've heard: "funkcore", "post-hardcore", "opera metal", "nintendocore"
None of those genres are metal, except 'opera metal' which isn't really a genre. That would probably be gothic or symphonic metal.
I like music genres. I used to think sub-sub-genres are stupid, (For example - technical death metal) but I have come to appreciate them.
None of those genres are metal, except 'opera metal' which isn't really a genre. That would probably be gothic or symphonic metal.
I like music genres. I used to think sub-sub-genres are stupid, (For example - technical death metal) but I have come to appreciate them.
In my experience genres aren't particularly informative. I mean, sure, you can define a band as this or that genre, but that's not likely to be true about everything the band ever plays, and will probably change over time anyway. So a lot of times I'll find a band that I like and then look for other bands in the same genre, but I won't like any of their songs. I have yet to find a specific genre of music that I can say I thoroughly enjoy (and very few that I thoroughly don't enjoy), which to me makes genres absolutely useless.
Pages:
1















