CYOR: BREATH OF MAFIA GAME THREAD

I really suck at being town

author=wildwes
Sorry Marrend, but I'm pretty convinced that seiromem is mafia. But, then again, mafia probably wouldn't be so... nonsensical, now that I think about it... um
I don't know anymoreeeee
b-but maybe he's being purposefully nonsensical, to make us think that he isn't mafia because mafia wouldn't act like that?! I'm just grasping at straws here aren't I?
you know speaking of which why are you all going along with a lynch started by someone who's been so nonsensical? that doesn't make any sense!

This entire post smells foul. Like the sulfury odor of a bad egg.

So. Should I just go ahead and get the day over with by lynching myself or...?
This wouldn't be first time I've hammervoted myself because I knew I was gonna die anyway. I wonder if I'm a defeatist... Ebeth get in here and tell me to stop being suicidal again

author=wildwes
So. Should I just go ahead and get the day over with by lynching myself or...?
This wouldn't be first time I've hammervoted myself because I knew I was gonna die anyway. I wonder if I'm a defeatist... Ebeth get in here and tell me to stop being suicidal again

If you're truly town, which I doubt, don't self-hammer. In fact, nobody should ever self-hammer if they want to win. Self-hammering is like the second most crippling thing a townie can do, and obviously the worst thing any mafia could ever do.

Though my two cents doesn't matter too much, I think Wes is innocent. I know I said he was our best bet earlier but then seiromem started acting extremely wilily and in the most anti town confusing way possible. Wes's reactions are
making him look town to me and his story fit into place with mine earlier today with no contradictions. While that doesn't auto make him town his confusion was fairly town. I think this is a different confused wes. A town one

I believe that with wildwes it is an honest coin toss. He's guilty of one big thing in my eyes: 1) That is that Liberty didn't get defensive with him when he questioned her posts, and he was one of the folks who didn't want to vote for her. I already said that since PA flipped town, its likely the other mafia tried to lay low when Liberty was under fire. However, given that he and seiromem both appear to have been arguing pretty earnestly I'm almost positive one is mafia and the other is town, trying to get each other killed. wildwes and seiromem are the only town that don't have an alibi of sorts. So they're the easiest targets for the mafia.

seiromem is the more likely bet on that front, and that's just what makes me hesitate: If he is mafia he's doing a terrible job. He tried to get rid of my bulletproof ability. Once done, he said he changed his mind and reconsidered my being mafia. Then he goes off into some non-nonsensical plan and gives no reasons for any of it, so none of the actions line up to any town benefit that I can see. Plus there's not a lot of content that points to him being town. He's really been staying under the radar somewhat, possibly as a result of Happy being his body-double. But now he's jumping into the fray headfirst with no rhyme or reason to any of the points in this plan of his. Its so overtly mafia-like I have to question it.

Either Marrend or Ebeth could be the mafia but only if seiromem or wildwes is not. Marrend has been a lot more vocal since I asked him to contribute more and his posts have seemed more town to me. Ebeth has been the same as she has since the beginning of the game. If either of them are mafia they are doing a good job. I think Ebeth voted for Liberty though, and she also voiced suspicion along with the rest of us, while Marrend wasn't sure. At this point, I don't know what conclusions to draw anymore.

Jeoren is completely new and I can't say anything about him at all. I still think Sooz was town.

If I had to place a vote today it would be wildwes.

However I don't know if its a good idea to vote today or not.

If we don't lynch, who is the mafia going to target? Likely, one of the two teams...but I think they'll go after someone who's confirmed town. That's what I would do. They'll probably try to keep us in as much confusion and disarray as possible. Therefore it may be a good idea to kill wildwes today, because it might buy us extra time and eliminate a source of confusion. If we do lynch him and we're wrong, it means that the mafia will probably try to kill one of the two mason teams.


So that means I have to think really hard about who to protect tonight....hrrrrnrnnnnggggg.

author=Isrieri
If we don't lynch, who is the mafia going to target? Likely, one of the two teams...but I think they'll go after someone who's confirmed town. That's what I would do. They'll probably try to keep us in as much confusion and disarray as possible. Therefore it may be a good idea to kill wildwes today, because it might buy us extra time and eliminate a source of confusion.

Right, unless you guys are actually on board with lynching seiromem (who I still feel is rather scummy) we should indeed go ahead and lynch me. But we should discuss stuff some more first!

Also: so, seiromem, you say that you purposefully acted completely out of the blue and maniacal to see who would jump on you (that being me)? That's a... very unorthodox way of scum-hunting. Honestly I don't think it's a very good way to scum-hunt either because you've been mostly lurking up until the nonsensical posts, and the fact that you tried to get rid of Isrieri's bullet-proof is STILL suspect. Seems like a scum-hunting tactic like that would put a lot of suspicion on you, and though mafia could target that suspicion, a townie like myself would also see it as suspicious and try to jump on it, hoping to kill mafia. Granted, whether this is stupid or I'm actually right about this for once: I still think you're mafia. Sorry, I do. But I think it's fairly obvious that you won't be lynched today anyway...

Welp. It's late here and I need to go bed. I'll keep my vote on Wildwes. I can't really put much emphasis on it though. Though, I could always switch it to seiromem. Actually, Seiromem seems to have kept count and predicted different scenarios in many of his posts. He has systematically counted how many players would remain after each phase, and so forth. Isrieri quoted to one of those posts, too, if I recall right.

In this light:

##Cancel
##Lynch Seiromem