THE COUNCIL OF DEATH - LET THE BLOODBATH BEGIN!
Posts
LockeZ
I'd really like to get rid of LockeZ. His play style is way too unpredictable. He's always like this too. If he ran a country, he'd just kill and imprison people at random until crime stopped.
5958
Oh God, there really is another scum.
One of you has a pretty towny power that you've been using mostly for good, and the other one has been very unaggressive the whole game in a very non-scummy way, agreeing with all the right arguments. Though... saying no one visited Ebeth last night is suspicious as hell? Maybe it's not, maybe Gourd had an invisibility item or power. Jesus, I don't know.
I mean... shit. I am kind of freaking out a little because I don't want to be the person who made the wrong decision. I've never survived to only three people alive in a mafia game before. Too much pressure!
God, I don't even know who I'm trying to convince. Both of you know whether you're scum or not.
One of you has a pretty towny power that you've been using mostly for good, and the other one has been very unaggressive the whole game in a very non-scummy way, agreeing with all the right arguments. Though... saying no one visited Ebeth last night is suspicious as hell? Maybe it's not, maybe Gourd had an invisibility item or power. Jesus, I don't know.
I mean... shit. I am kind of freaking out a little because I don't want to be the person who made the wrong decision. I've never survived to only three people alive in a mafia game before. Too much pressure!
God, I don't even know who I'm trying to convince. Both of you know whether you're scum or not.
LockeZ
I'd really like to get rid of LockeZ. His play style is way too unpredictable. He's always like this too. If he ran a country, he'd just kill and imprison people at random until crime stopped.
5958
Ugh, I had an argument all planned before the lynch, where if Majoracanking was scum, I was going to be able to prove that Gourd_Clae was innocent based on the fact that Majora tried to steal an item from him on day one.
But it occured to me over the next 24 hours that there was a logical fallacy with that, which is that he could have actually used a defensive or buff item on Gourd on day one. For some reason the possibility of a defensive/buff item hadn't crossed my mind earlier. If he did that then it would be easy to fake the knowledge Majora had about Gourd's antidote getting stolen, since they'd have been talking to each-other.
Mind you, I still think Gourd is probably innocent. I just can't prove it like I was hoping I'd be able to. Mrgrgrgrgr.
But it occured to me over the next 24 hours that there was a logical fallacy with that, which is that he could have actually used a defensive or buff item on Gourd on day one. For some reason the possibility of a defensive/buff item hadn't crossed my mind earlier. If he did that then it would be easy to fake the knowledge Majora had about Gourd's antidote getting stolen, since they'd have been talking to each-other.
Mind you, I still think Gourd is probably innocent. I just can't prove it like I was hoping I'd be able to. Mrgrgrgrgr.
I wish Gourd would talk to us, he's still suspicious in my mind until hetalks to us.
After all, we know zero about his role or anything. Which points to scum or lord.
After all, we know zero about his role or anything. Which points to scum or lord.
LockeZ
I'd really like to get rid of LockeZ. His play style is way too unpredictable. He's always like this too. If he ran a country, he'd just kill and imprison people at random until crime stopped.
5958
Guh. Maybe he's just lurking and waiting to see if one of us posts about the other so he can jump in and hammer the moment they do.
OR MAYBE YOU ARE.
OR MAYBE YOU ARE.
OR YOU ARE
I can play this game too.
At this point it's just which of these two is evil?
Unless you're scum, which would be lynch anyone but, lynch anyone but me.
I can play this game too.
At this point it's just which of these two is evil?
Unless you're scum, which would be lynch anyone but, lynch anyone but me.
Okay, so I'm here~
I am the actual last lord and Ebeth was my bodyguard pretending to be me because she wanted to protect me. Coincidentally, she died of poison and being attaccked last night! Anyway, one of the two of you is scum. Let's get down to the heart of the matter though.
SuNa has a coin. Which means he cannot be lynched. So if we waste a lynch on him we're giving scum the game.
I have a coin. If we waste a lynch on me, we're giving scum the game.
Basically, we have to vote for LockeZ and hope he's evil. Honestly, I'm inclined to believe suna is evil but that doesn't really matter at this point.
Oh, and LockeZ, even if you do claim having a coin, it'd be a very convenient claim after suna and I both already claimed having coins. Much more likely that you're lying and if you had a coin, it wouldn't matter anyway.
#Lynch LockeZ
I am the actual last lord and Ebeth was my bodyguard pretending to be me because she wanted to protect me. Coincidentally, she died of poison and being attaccked last night! Anyway, one of the two of you is scum. Let's get down to the heart of the matter though.
SuNa has a coin. Which means he cannot be lynched. So if we waste a lynch on him we're giving scum the game.
I have a coin. If we waste a lynch on me, we're giving scum the game.
Basically, we have to vote for LockeZ and hope he's evil. Honestly, I'm inclined to believe suna is evil but that doesn't really matter at this point.
Oh, and LockeZ, even if you do claim having a coin, it'd be a very convenient claim after suna and I both already claimed having coins. Much more likely that you're lying and if you had a coin, it wouldn't matter anyway.
#Lynch LockeZ
I also find it very suspicious that LockeZ is skeptical of Ebeth not being visited considering she was visited. I also think his "oh god I'm a noob woah" attitude right now is an act. It's a little ridiculous too considering LockeZ's personality.
I originally believed suna was scum because he has a no lynch coin. I stole my no lynch coin from YM who was mafia.
I've been using the items people claimed to have to determine if they were lords for most of the game. Piano had the same items as me. I suspect cave did too before I killed him night 1~<3
I've been using the items people claimed to have to determine if they were lords for most of the game. Piano had the same items as me. I suspect cave did too before I killed him night 1~<3
LockeZ
I'd really like to get rid of LockeZ. His play style is way too unpredictable. He's always like this too. If he ran a country, he'd just kill and imprison people at random until crime stopped.
5958
I mean this is only my fourth mafia game ever, but I can go back to tryhard analytical mode if you want. If it were me two days ago, when it became apparent that it was going to probably come down to the final day, and the name and existance of the coin were public, I think I would have claimed to have a coin if I were scum. To fabricate exactly the forced hand you have right now.
Sigh. I'm in a worse situation than you. It's not that I'm really confused or anything, my situation is just hopeless because you both claim to be inmune to lynches. Guess I will lynch the one more likely to be lying about the coin.
#lynch Mr_SuNa
Sigh. I'm in a worse situation than you. It's not that I'm really confused or anything, my situation is just hopeless because you both claim to be inmune to lynches. Guess I will lynch the one more likely to be lying about the coin.
#lynch Mr_SuNa
Not lying about anything, I have been truthful.
I am Stable Boy, and LockeZ you are done
#lynch LockeZ
Nothing else to do if Gourd has a coin too
I am Stable Boy, and LockeZ you are done
#lynch LockeZ
Nothing else to do if Gourd has a coin too
Jeroen_Sol
Nothing reveals Humanity so well as the games it plays. A game of betrayal, where the most suspicious person is brutally murdered? How savage.
3885
"It really is a beautiful knife... The stars adorned on the black blade..."
"He gave it to me me right before he died."
"It certainly served its purpose... Tell me, why did you do it? You could have prevented all of this. You could have stopped Morgan."
"But that would not have brought my brother back from the dead, would it? What would I have done? Where would I have gone? The gods do not smile upon bastards, and bastard daughters less even than sons. When my father died, I lost everything. To Tellus, I was nothing more than a nameless outcast, ripe for a brothel, and I'm certain my father's wife would have sent me to one had she still been alive. Only George ever saw me as a person. As a sister...
And now..."
"But why go this far? To murder lords for a potential poisoning..."
"Did you not murder Amber, when you executed him for a murder he claimed not to have committed? Did you not send your knight to pierce Seebreeze in his sleep? You have murdered more lords than I have!"
"But why continue after Langdon's death? He confessed to me tha-"
"How could I trust someone like you? You, who saw George's death only as an opportunity to seize Tellus for yourself! How could I trust it was not you who poisoned him? Why would you, who has been so fortunate, deserve to live, while my brother, who already lost his father, brother and wife, died? You have never cared about your son, nor Morgan. All you care about is the power they give you!"
"This country needs stability, and a ruler. Only I can give it that now that the line of the Darkstars has ended, and the lords of the South, West and North lay slain."
"Then you must kill me. I may not carry the name of Darkstar, but with me, the line of the Darkstars lives. And one day, I will have a son, and I will ensure the Darkstars will sit the throne once more."
"I am saddened to hear that. I did not intend to end the noble house of Darkstar today. Please do not force my hand. I am prepared to let you stay at the black castle, much like Lady Goldstrike before you. You would not need to live a life of povert-"
"I have murdered a lord with that knife. I cannot be left alive, and you know it. The only thing I ask is that you do it yourself. And that I am buried with my brother and his knife."
"You are asking me to kill you?"
"I have nothing left in this world. And I will not let you sit the throne innocent of single-handedly ending the line of Darkstar..."
"...
If you insist, then it appears I have no choice..."
LockeZ, Rosa, scum-aligned, was lynched day 6!
Powers:
Gourd_Clae, Lord James Oakleaf, survived!
Powers:
Mr_SuNa, Clark Sanders, survived!
Powers:
Final Day 6 votecount:
LockeZ: 2 - Gourd_Clae, Mr_SuNa
Mr_SuNa: 1 - LockeZ
End of Game!
Gourd_Clae, Ebeth, wildwes, JJJ7, and Mr_SuNa win!
Council of Death - Dead Lounge
"He gave it to me me right before he died."
"It certainly served its purpose... Tell me, why did you do it? You could have prevented all of this. You could have stopped Morgan."
"But that would not have brought my brother back from the dead, would it? What would I have done? Where would I have gone? The gods do not smile upon bastards, and bastard daughters less even than sons. When my father died, I lost everything. To Tellus, I was nothing more than a nameless outcast, ripe for a brothel, and I'm certain my father's wife would have sent me to one had she still been alive. Only George ever saw me as a person. As a sister...
And now..."
"But why go this far? To murder lords for a potential poisoning..."
"Did you not murder Amber, when you executed him for a murder he claimed not to have committed? Did you not send your knight to pierce Seebreeze in his sleep? You have murdered more lords than I have!"
"But why continue after Langdon's death? He confessed to me tha-"
"How could I trust someone like you? You, who saw George's death only as an opportunity to seize Tellus for yourself! How could I trust it was not you who poisoned him? Why would you, who has been so fortunate, deserve to live, while my brother, who already lost his father, brother and wife, died? You have never cared about your son, nor Morgan. All you care about is the power they give you!"
"This country needs stability, and a ruler. Only I can give it that now that the line of the Darkstars has ended, and the lords of the South, West and North lay slain."
"Then you must kill me. I may not carry the name of Darkstar, but with me, the line of the Darkstars lives. And one day, I will have a son, and I will ensure the Darkstars will sit the throne once more."
"I am saddened to hear that. I did not intend to end the noble house of Darkstar today. Please do not force my hand. I am prepared to let you stay at the black castle, much like Lady Goldstrike before you. You would not need to live a life of povert-"
"I have murdered a lord with that knife. I cannot be left alive, and you know it. The only thing I ask is that you do it yourself. And that I am buried with my brother and his knife."
"You are asking me to kill you?"
"I have nothing left in this world. And I will not let you sit the throne innocent of single-handedly ending the line of Darkstar..."
"...
If you insist, then it appears I have no choice..."
LockeZ, Rosa, scum-aligned, was lynched day 6!
Powers:
-Roleblock: Every night, you may choose one person to prevent them from using any night actions that night. You cannot block items.
-Executer: You will execute all scum nightkills.
-Executer: You will execute all scum nightkills.
Gourd_Clae, Lord James Oakleaf, survived!
Powers:
-Bodyguard: If any action or item would kill you at night, your bodyguard will die instead. Does not apply to statuses.
-Lord's Justice: Every night, as long as your bodyguard lives, you may choose one person. Your bodyguard will kill this person, but not if they are neutral town or scum. If you use this action, you will sacrifice your Bodyguard power for that particular night.
-Lord's Justice: Every night, as long as your bodyguard lives, you may choose one person. Your bodyguard will kill this person, but not if they are neutral town or scum. If you use this action, you will sacrifice your Bodyguard power for that particular night.
Mr_SuNa, Clark Sanders, survived!
Powers:
-Watch: Check one player to see who targets that person with actions or items on that particular night.
Final Day 6 votecount:
LockeZ: 2 - Gourd_Clae, Mr_SuNa
Mr_SuNa: 1 - LockeZ
End of Game!
Gourd_Clae, Ebeth, wildwes, JJJ7, and Mr_SuNa win!
Council of Death - Dead Lounge
Okay, congratulations, but why do you keep taunting me? Are you CAVE_DOG in disguise?
LockeZ
I'd really like to get rid of LockeZ. His play style is way too unpredictable. He's always like this too. If he ran a country, he'd just kill and imprison people at random until crime stopped.
5958
JJJ7 seriously deserves an MVP award for being completely right about absolutely everything. He called all three scum, and even correctly explained why we were doing the things we were doing.
I'm pretty sure I had both of the last two survivors convinced I was town and would have won if Mr_SuNa hadn't had a coin. Also would have won a lot more easily if Ebeth hadn't had platemail, or if the poison had activated before the night actions instead of after (assuming he wasn't lying about poison). Really close game!
Ebeth, we knew you and Gourd switched, we just couldn't do anything about it. My insistence that the info should be hidden in case the scum had ways to kill you both was bluffing; we knew Gourd was your accomplice anyway. I had already used my poison earlier in the game though. Pianotm was the one who poisoned you.
Well, close for scum and green team. The two lords who died on the first night, not so close.
I'm pretty sure I had both of the last two survivors convinced I was town and would have won if Mr_SuNa hadn't had a coin. Also would have won a lot more easily if Ebeth hadn't had platemail, or if the poison had activated before the night actions instead of after (assuming he wasn't lying about poison). Really close game!
Ebeth, we knew you and Gourd switched, we just couldn't do anything about it. My insistence that the info should be hidden in case the scum had ways to kill you both was bluffing; we knew Gourd was your accomplice anyway. I had already used my poison earlier in the game though. Pianotm was the one who poisoned you.
Well, close for scum and green team. The two lords who died on the first night, not so close.
Thanks LockeZ!
You also did a good work as mafia, the only real mistake you made was
not killing Suna.
So I'm going to say: Good game.
Good game.
Edit: And hey, I'm generally useless in this mafia thingies, so this was a
nice change of pace.
You also did a good work as mafia, the only real mistake you made was
not killing Suna.
So I'm going to say: Good game.
Good game.
Edit: And hey, I'm generally useless in this mafia thingies, so this was a
nice change of pace.
LockeZ
I'd really like to get rid of LockeZ. His play style is way too unpredictable. He's always like this too. If he ran a country, he'd just kill and imprison people at random until crime stopped.
5958
If Ebeth was really poisoned, I should've killed Suna the final night. But the way I saw it there were three possibilities:
1) Ebeth was poisoned, and poison occurs before night actions.
2) Ebeth was poisoned, and poison occurs after night actions.
3) Ebeth was lying about being poisoned to try to keep the scum from targeting him.
I considered options 1 and 2 to be equally likely, so the weight of option 3 convinced me to nightkill him instead of Suna.
I don't think I should've killed Suna earlier. I was doing a good job at manipulating him, and we were able to completely nullify his power from day 3 onward. Day 3 Majora redirected his power to Ebeth, day 4 I roleblocked him, and day 5 I just targetted Gourd instead of Ebeth for the nightkill so he couldn't see it.
1) Ebeth was poisoned, and poison occurs before night actions.
2) Ebeth was poisoned, and poison occurs after night actions.
3) Ebeth was lying about being poisoned to try to keep the scum from targeting him.
I considered options 1 and 2 to be equally likely, so the weight of option 3 convinced me to nightkill him instead of Suna.
I don't think I should've killed Suna earlier. I was doing a good job at manipulating him, and we were able to completely nullify his power from day 3 onward. Day 3 Majora redirected his power to Ebeth, day 4 I roleblocked him, and day 5 I just targetted Gourd instead of Ebeth for the nightkill so he couldn't see it.
















