STRUCTURE MAFIA [NIGHT 3]

Posts

oddRABBIT
I feel bored. How odd.
1979
I'm surprised by the lack of things happening.
I'd rather believe that Gourd wouldn't screw around with weird stuff like insane cops. Instead, here's what we got:

These players are non-scum:
- pianotm
- cap_h
- frogge

These players have not yet been cleared:
- snowfox
- ozzy
- oddrabbit


My solution:

snowfox is scum
@Odd I'm interested what happened when Ivory got lynched. Did you vote against it? Did IF or Kloe propose to lynch her first? Was Ivory's cop claim definite ("I'M THE COP, IDIOTS") or indirect ("I've got the towniest role ever, don't kill me") ?
oddRABBIT
I feel bored. How odd.
1979
author=psy_wombats
I'd rather believe that Gourd wouldn't screw around with weird stuff like insane cops. Instead, here's what we got:

These players are non-scum:
- pianotm
- cap_h
- frogge

These players have not yet been cleared:
- snowfox
- ozzy
- oddrabbit


My solution:

snowfox is scum



This is definitely possible. Snowfox, so far, has been pretty inactive.
I have reasons of my own to believe that snowfox is town though, I'd really rather that delta's cop is screwy or something else interfered. But I really don't think it's likely.
oddRABBIT
I feel bored. How odd.
1979
author=psy_wombats
@Odd I'm interested what happened when Ivory got lynched. Did you vote against it? Did IF or Kloe propose to lynch her first? Was Ivory's cop claim definite ("I'M THE COP, IDIOTS") or indirect ("I've got the towniest role ever, don't kill me") ?



I didn't vote against it, as I wasn't there at the time, however, I definitely did not support it. While I was suspicious of Ivory, I did not plan on acting against her.

IF voted first.

Both.
Frogge
I wanna marry ALL the boys!! And Donna is a meanc
18995
I feel that there is a good chance that we'll find the final mafia tonight anyway, so I'll roleclaim. I am independent. It is also why I lynched Ratty on day 1 despite not actually having any suspicions of him beforehand. Because he roleclaimed as independent, while I was the one who was actually independent.

So that only leaves three suspects for me. Odd, psy or cap_h. I'll just go with my gut and say it's cap.

#lynch_CapH
oddRABBIT
I feel bored. How odd.
1979
author=Frogge
I feel that there is a good chance that we'll find the final mafia tonight anyway, so I'll roleclaim. I am independent. It is also why I lynched Ratty on day 1 despite not actually having any suspicions of him beforehand. Because he roleclaimed as independent, while I was the one who was actually independent.

So that only leaves three suspects for me. Odd, psy or cap_h. I'll just go with my gut and say it's cap.

#lynch_CapH


You forgot Snowfox14.
Frogge
I wanna marry ALL the boys!! And Donna is a meanc
18995
Oh wait, now I remember, Cap was confirmed town. Well, I'm dumb.

#cancel
#lynch_OzzytheOne


I don't really think snowfox is mafia. It's their first time playing, and I'm pretty sure anyone flipping scum on their first play would make being scum awfully obvious.
OzzyTheOne
Future Ruler of Gam Mak
4698
author=Frogge
Oh wait, now I remember, Cap was confirmed town. Well, I'm dumb.

#cancel
#lynch_OzzytheOne


I don't really think snowfox is mafia. It's their first time playing, and I'm pretty sure anyone flipping scum on their first play would make being scum awfully obvious.


Could you please elaborate on why you think I'm scum? By the logic you used for snow, I should also not be scum, seeing as it's my first time playing. Also, I voted for both Ratty and IF. Why would a newbie scum do that? Wouldn't that be extremely dumb?
pianotm
The TM is for Totally Magical.
32388
On the other hand, Frogge didn't vote for IF, and let me check to see if he voted for Ratty.
oddRABBIT
I feel bored. How odd.
1979
I just did something really stupid that I'm never going to regret.

I hope you like pointless announcements.
pianotm
The TM is for Totally Magical.
32388
And Frogge DID vote to lynch Ratty.
oddRABBIT
I feel bored. How odd.
1979
On the other hand, I don't think I voted for Ratty, but I definitely voted for IF.
pianotm
The TM is for Totally Magical.
32388
One thing I feel I need to point out is that Cap_H has been super aggressive, and he's been all over the place with his scum accusations.
pianotm
The TM is for Totally Magical.
32388
But Cap_H has been protecting me, and scum wouldn't protect someone who can jump into mason teams.
pianotm
The TM is for Totally Magical.
32388
By the way, the only message I got from scum chat was a good night message. Yeah, I missed jumping into Team Oso. I wish we could have used their night kill...
author=Frogge
I feel that there is a good chance that we'll find the final mafia tonight anyway, so I'll roleclaim. I am independent. It is also why I lynched Ratty on day 1 despite not actually having any suspicions of him beforehand. Because he roleclaimed as independent, while I was the one who was actually independent.

This sounds pretty solid to me. Your vote on Ratty seemed weird to me, I guess it was because you had hidden reasons. And the ability plays into this too (it could help scum, it could help town, and it's all indirect).
The players Cap_H and Frogge are non-scum and DELTA FORCE has not received erroneous results from its investigative ability
author=oddRABBIT
author=psy_wombats
@Odd I'm interested what happened when Ivory got lynched. Did you vote against it? Did IF or Kloe propose to lynch her first? Was Ivory's cop claim definite ("I'M THE COP, IDIOTS") or indirect ("I've got the towniest role ever, don't kill me") ?
I didn't vote against it, as I wasn't there at the time, however, I definitely did not support it. While I was suspicious of Ivory, I did not plan on acting against her.

IF voted first.

Both.

This is also decently convincing -- if you and IF were both scum you would've coordinated to actually do it while online at the same time to avoid Ivory reporting you in the main thread. Sounds like me IF thought he could get away with convincing at least one of you and just went for it.