CRYSTAL-MINT'S PROFILE
(adorable art of my character Lacie © steamed-bun.deviantart.com!)
Search
Filter
[Play Time] Bullet Ballot Mafia
author=Gourd_Clae
"Kloe - only applicable if the piano VS kloe tirade was a ploy to sacrifice piano for Kloe and someone else. "
A theory, but when I flip town I think we all know how that could become a serious allegation...
As I said earlier, that simply sounds like exploring different possibilities.
author=Gourd_Clae
"lol You missed where I threw that same shade at you last night? I wondered why you didn't say anything, since you were so eager to have fingers pointed at you."
Admitting she threw shade...
I'm not exactly sure when this was said, so I can't really comment on that haha
author=Gourd_Clae
"Kloe:
Right, well, If I were Mafia, I wouldn't do that, but most would and it's a good theory!
Maki:
But hey, look, it's that phrase again. "
Clearly throwing shade - in this case Maki was saying she saw this before with me and was essentially saying it was scummy of Kloe to say this.
Um...so you think Maki's suspicious in suspecting Kloe for saying "If I were Mafia", a phrase that you told us not to use?
[Play Time] Bullet Ballot Mafia
Found it!
author=Crystal-Mintauthor=Gourd_ClaeSure, if you think 2 votes means everyone...author=MakioKutaDidn't we already establish that everyone found piano obviously suspect...?
That doesn't back up me voting for him the first day at all. Very few people were suspicious of piano on the first day, or at least if they were very few people SAID they were. So why would I be voting for him on day one to keep suspicion off myself? No one could have predicted the self destruction piano went through on day 2.
[Play Time] Bullet Ballot Mafia
author=Kloe
He quoted you... Anyway, two votes on day 1 isn't surprising considering how many were alive + double vote + Jeroen had a hunch!
I was talking about the quotes he didn't include: a post where he quoted Maki, who was talking about Day 1 (confusing, right? I'll try to find the original post xD)
[Play Time] Bullet Ballot Mafia
author=Kloe
So... Much... Ninja-ing
I don't even understand what people are saying anymore, I need a tl:dr version!
So, are we agreed who it is? (Now that I think about it, no, crystal will never leave Makis side)
As I said before, I'm not supporting Maki, but there's just not enough strong evidence for me to vote for her either xD
Namely, the fact that I can counter every single one of your arguments despite myself having an inkling of suspicion against her says a lot haha
[Play Time] Bullet Ballot Mafia
author=Gourd_Claeauthor=Crystal-MintI wasn't referring to votes, but even still, only 2 votes? There were four votes on piano. Jeroen also said he knew it from the beginning. Kloe led the charge. Maki "had a hunch" People apparently found his outburst very incriminating and included this in arguments against me - namely YM although they voted for odd.
Didn't we already establish that everyone found piano obviously suspect...?Sure, if you think 2 votes means everyone...
I realize this isn't everyone but it is an overwhelming majority.
2 votes on day 1. That's what Maki was talking about in the post you quoted, right?
[Play Time] Bullet Ballot Mafia
author=Gourd_Clae
OH now I understand. Okay, now I agree with you.
author=Gourd_Clae
XD I didn't realize that was what you were getting at crystal, my bad!
Oops, seems like I was ninja'd again
[Play Time] Bullet Ballot Mafia
author=Gourd_Clae
I'm not sure you read that right. I said that Maki threw shade at Kloe at least one more time. I didn't even mention how many times Kloe said "If I was mafia" Maki was being a bit strange in using my logic against Kloe in the first place since she had already begun pointing a huge finger at me.
What I meant was, Maki didn't say that for no reason.
What does "my logic against Kloe" mean though?
Gourd_Clae
Maki has been leading town opinion all day.
You don't think Maki could have thrown shade at Kloe now to use on the next day while still leading town in voting on me today? Because I do. The difference is you suggesting it versus her suggesting it. If you suggest it you must provide an argument. If she puts it to rest for now, she can always use it later.
Where else did Maki suspect Kloe, aside from questioning why Kloe was intent on comparing herself to mafia?
Gourd_Clae
I concede that you would suspect a RP to have people acting differently - but why did Kloe not change?
Why does that even matter? Everyone roleplays differently. I feel like you're just grasping at straws here.
[Play Time] Bullet Ballot Mafia
author=Gourd_Claeauthor=Crystal-MintMy point was that the fact that you were playing a rp changed Maki drastically but not Kloe? It seems strange to me.author=Gourd_ClaeBy the way, why are we even talking about past experiences? That should definitely NOT be a reason to vote for someone, especially when the "past experience" was an RP
Also, crystal, the point was Kloe is not acting radically different - why should Maki?
Or MAYBE Kloe just played a character that's more similar to her real life personality ._. (I'm guessing you've never RPed before?)
My point was the fact that this type of meta argument really isn't something you can use, especially when it was an RP before.
author=Gourd_Claeauthor=MakioKutaDidn't we already establish that everyone found piano obviously suspect...?
That doesn't back up me voting for him the first day at all. Very few people were suspicious of piano on the first day, or at least if they were very few people SAID they were. So why would I be voting for him on day one to keep suspicion off myself? No one could have predicted the self destruction piano went through on day 2.
Sure, if you think 2 votes means everyone...
[Play Time] Bullet Ballot Mafia
Ok, Gourd's entire response just screams "suspicious" to me. (Either that or you just didn't read anything properly haha)
Maki was not suspecting Kloe for saying "If I was mafia" ONCE, but rather because I'm pretty sure Kloe's said that in over a dozen posts by now. I even spoke up about it, since it seems really unneccessary for Kloe to do that so often.
Doesn't that contradict what you said earlier? Why would Maki "throw shade" at Kloe in the first place if her intention was to get everyone to vote for you?
Yes, because it was roleplay. Of course she'd act a bit differently!
author=Gourd_Claeauthor=Crystal-MintActually she's mentioned Kloe one other time at least. Kloe said "If I was mafia" and Maki threw serious shade.
Actually, I don't think Maki has suspected Kloe or oddrabbit at all! The one time she mentioned them didn't actually accuse them, it was just exploring different possibilities.
Maki was not suspecting Kloe for saying "If I was mafia" ONCE, but rather because I'm pretty sure Kloe's said that in over a dozen posts by now. I even spoke up about it, since it seems really unneccessary for Kloe to do that so often.
Gourd_Claeauthor=Crystal-MintThink about it: Maki likely already voted. Maki needs you to vote for me specifically if they're going to get a townie lynched.
Plus, Maki was the one who responded to my (half-joking) post about voting for Kloe (because she's a distraction) and said NOT to vote for Kloe. How is that the behavior of a mafia?
Doesn't that contradict what you said earlier? Why would Maki "throw shade" at Kloe in the first place if her intention was to get everyone to vote for you?
Gourd_Clae
And Maki even admitted that they are acting very differently. Their excuse was RPing but Kloe is the same?
Yes, because it was roleplay. Of course she'd act a bit differently!














