REDMAN45'S PROFILE

I'm recently starting a new RPG project and can't decide if I would have a silent hero where players choose his actions or a hero with a predetermined personality.

I always liked the silent hero in games (Suikoden & Persona series) opposed to the ones where the hero voices his opinions because a lot of the time I'm turned off by a hero's emotional mood swings while I feel a silent hero lets me voice who the player wants to be. I preferred Dragon Age over Dragon Age 2 because I didn't like the hero talking all the time.

So what are you guy's opinion on silent heroes and those with personalities? Which do you relate to more?