E 3 - Too spontaneous. Hard to hear the melody.
E 10 - Too repetitive for me. Could have added more instruments at some points.
E 20 - Didn't think I would hear something like this. Creative, but doesn't sound like an airship theme.
E 19 - I naturally like electronic stuff, so this is one of my faves. The whole time I was thinking "what software is that?".
E 23 - Meh. Not exceptional, but not bad.
E 25 - Cool piece. Could have used more instruments for a less repetitive composition. Ending was just a fade out instead of conclusion. Software intrigues me.
E 15 - Has a grooving support, but lacks a real melody.
E 9 - Seems to nonchalant to be an airship ride. Unless your riding over a grave yard or something.
E 21 - Very ominous. When I think of an airship though, I think happy and adventurous.
E 16 - Gets boring for the first half. Way too repetitive!
E 24 - Rhythm is hard to follow, chords are annoying, and the continuous bass guitar sounds odd on it's own.
E 17 - In the first couple of seconds I was into it. The beat was very radiant. Really sounds like an airship! I like it most because it constantly changes. Still don't like fade out endings.
E 14 - Like it. Techno airship. Loses airship feel at some parts though.
E 6 - Rhythm keeps changing (cool). Kept my attention until the very end where it got a little annoying. Ride of wonder.
E 5 - Sounds RTP-ish. Errrgh! More fade out! Pretty good though.
E 22 - So peaceful. Like floating on clouds. I imagine it could be sped up for a different feel.
E 12 - Makes me think of the recovery after a sad time. Not really an airship, but awesome sounding. Software sounds much better than Mario Paint Composer!
E 26 - Cool piece. Definitely made in Mario Paint Composer.
E 8 - Love it! Very futuristic and entertaining! Cuttin' it close at 1:58 though!
E 18 - Reminds me of Earthbound for some reason. Rhythm is adaptive. Airship theme isn't present though.
E 1 - Beginning is great. Middle is great. Ending is great. What were you thinking Clyve?!
E 13 - Mysterious ride. Reminds me more of a boat than an airship.
E 7 - Sounds like funeral music to me.
E 2 - I Agree with Kentona. EPIC BATTLE. The only other thing that comes to mind is a volcanic area.
E 4 - Awesome airship using mostly piano. Thrives.
E 11 - Great mix of instruments for this airship. Like an on board orchestra!

My vote - E 17. Good mix that still sounds like an adventurous airship. 17 is an mp3 though Clyve.

So how sucky is mine
Kentona: Ow
Dudesoft: Sounds more like Bowsers Castle
Ivoryjones: Cringeworthy and he has noticed that faulty snap in the middle
Blobofgoo: Annoying and Odd

Final: Annoying, Odd and Cringeworthy Bowsers Castle music that no-one likes with a fault in the middle... I thought that might happen...
If anyone votes for it, I will watch Monty Python and the Holy Grail until I know it by heart

author=ivoryjones
Don't worry, mine got mixed reviews too! :D
My songs tend to give off weird/inappropriate/funny vibes to people so yeah. x)
Oh and I actually thought Kentona's review of your song was the least harsh of all. o.o

I guess I'm pretty good at evil dream temple songs instead of airship themes XD!
On a more realistic note, I have to say that right now what I'm about to say is more or less an excuse than anything else. I guess I didn't try hard enough, I need to do my ABSOLUTE best to beat at least some of the better people, or get to my small goal of at least 3rd place.
Really though, most of my songs give me a surrealistic vibe anyway, so if the next music contest deals with surrealism, give me 1st place at the start...
than again it deals on if it's good or not, but nonetheless it would be surrealistic beyond belief...

17, 8, and 11 are my top three. Tough choice!

I have to give the nod to 8!

I really enjoyed this contest. Will there be another one soon? Next time I plan to work on my song until the deadline and make it perfect, plus making music is really fun so if you can please make another contest soon.

I believe these are going to be frequent mini-event, yes.

11 win s thanks goodnight

Dagnabbit. I just realised I uploaded an old version of my entry instead of the final mix. I know it's too late to resubmit, but just in case anyone's interested, here's entry 15 with human drums (instead of a loop) and properly mastered: http://rpgmaker.net/users/Faenon/locker/AIRSHIP.mp3

They don't have to look at the reviews if they don't want to. Plus giving feedbacks after the competition kinda ruins the fun.

author=Faenon
Dagnabbit. I just realised I uploaded an old version of my entry instead of the final mix. I know it's too late to resubmit, but just in case anyone's interested, here's entry 15 with human drums (instead of a loop) and properly mastered: http://rpgmaker.net/users/Faenon/locker/AIRSHIP.mp3

I liked the first one better. The renewed one seemed too fast.

Voting should end in an hour! If you haven't voted, do so soon!