MAFIA OF THE DEATH NOTE - GAME THREAD
Posts
No, that last post wasn't the post I was referring to. Search again. Hint: the word "day 3" and "day 4" in it.
And MM, what does itrombe's death has to do with cave's innocence if he clearly protected me this night. Was that a scum-DB mess up just now or what.
And MM, what does itrombe's death has to do with cave's innocence if he clearly protected me this night. Was that a scum-DB mess up just now or what.
Oh, right, and I claimed explosion that time I was going off my head on sugar rush. Forgot about that.
Also, the reason I said I didn't mind dying on the third day was because if we kept lynching wrong (and to my mind at that point it looked like we would since I was so suspicious of Gourd) my second win condition would be bust and I'd only get a half-win.
As it is, unless we lynch an innocent today, I'm luckily not where I thought I'd be - half way to a half loss.
Also, the reason I said I didn't mind dying on the third day was because if we kept lynching wrong (and to my mind at that point it looked like we would since I was so suspicious of Gourd) my second win condition would be bust and I'd only get a half-win.
As it is, unless we lynch an innocent today, I'm luckily not where I thought I'd be - half way to a half loss.
Jeroen_Sol
Nothing reveals Humanity so well as the games it plays. A game of betrayal, where the most suspicious person is brutally murdered? How savage.
3885
People at high risk of being modkilled:
ldida1 (I only just found out it's Ldida rather than idida -_-)
People at risk of being modkilled:
Despite
People at low of being modkilled:
Everyone else
Day 2 votecount:
CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK: 3 - Adon237, ivoryjones, Liberty
Itrombe: 1 - MirrorMasq
With 11 alive it takes 6 to lynch.
Day 2 will end August 8th 1PM GMT, that is in about 45 hours.
ldida1 (I only just found out it's Ldida rather than idida -_-)
People at risk of being modkilled:
Despite
People at low of being modkilled:
Everyone else
Day 2 votecount:
CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK: 3 - Adon237, ivoryjones, Liberty
Itrombe: 1 - MirrorMasq
With 11 alive it takes 6 to lynch.
Day 2 will end August 8th 1PM GMT, that is in about 45 hours.
I am Mail Jeevas! Mello's best friend, and I am an independent, FYI. I am already acknowledging the fact that there is a good chance you mafia will kill me tonight anyways.
author=ivoryjones
People who had claimed:
ivory: Mason townie
Itrombe: Weak doctor (never mentioned alignment?)
MM: Double voter (?)
Adon: Cop, indi: Mail
Liberty: loved, cop: Matsuda
- TBG
-YM
-Cave
-Chana
-Rabitz
-Idida1
-Despite
Wow!!!!
That post you've made, I believe was after your "sugar rush". And why would you assume that TBG isn't 'missing' but dead and you've just lost your other condition?
So, four Mafia, two indies and six townies left.
Myself and ivory have claimed townies.
adon has claimed indie.
That leaves four town, four mafia and one indie.
Now, itrombe claimed weak doctor. That means that either he and cave are both town, he is mafia and cave is town, or both are mafia and itrombe is fake claiming. If his claim was true and cave was mafia he'd be dead... however, Gourd was pretty sure that cave was mafia (and I have my own gut feeling but I won't discount being wrong) so... it's more likely that either both are lying or both are town, right?
Myself and ivory have claimed townies.
adon has claimed indie.
That leaves four town, four mafia and one indie.
Now, itrombe claimed weak doctor. That means that either he and cave are both town, he is mafia and cave is town, or both are mafia and itrombe is fake claiming. If his claim was true and cave was mafia he'd be dead... however, Gourd was pretty sure that cave was mafia (and I have my own gut feeling but I won't discount being wrong) so... it's more likely that either both are lying or both are town, right?
WHY ARE PEOPLE ALWAYS BRINGING UP IF TROMBE'S CLAIM IS TRUE IF CAVE IS MAFIA WHEN HE CLEARLY PROTECTED ME A THOUSAND FACEPALMS
B
1 - I'm pretty sure I was still a bit silly at the time. I was coming down from the high, trying to be serious. I actually think my brother might have slipped something in the cookies. I wouldn't put it past him... >.<;
2 - I counted in my head the blue names that were on the night list. Usually people whose names turn up on it are those killed. Hence a miscount.
author=ivoryjones
That post you've made, I believe was after your "sugar rush". And why would you assume that TBG isn't 'missing' but dead and you've just lost your other condition?
1 - I'm pretty sure I was still a bit silly at the time. I was coming down from the high, trying to be serious. I actually think my brother might have slipped something in the cookies. I wouldn't put it past him... >.<;
2 - I counted in my head the blue names that were on the night list. Usually people whose names turn up on it are those killed. Hence a miscount.
author=Liberty
...ivory... itrombe... short names, start with 'i'
sorry?
i dont know what youre talking about
Also, because for some reason that's what Gourd said in his letter: if itrombe is dead then Cave must be mafia.
Also, I believe today Cave AND itrombe are mafia. Cave is going to try to get you to kill itrombe. You'll see itrombe was mafia and trust Cave. Kill itrombe, but also Cave. M'kay? Also, I had other things I was going to say but realized SOME of them were dumb, realize that not all of them are. Chearlie is obviously innocent for one. Also, the Cave and itrombe arguement following is still legitimate as well.
Hey. Hey, liberty. I'm not mafia. I'm Near. My goal is to kill Mello and eliminate all Kira supporters. Stop with your meta-bullshit now please.
That out of the way, let's get down to business. For some reason itrombe didn't die which means he's mafia. Also, Liberty was sooooo scummy she's toatlly mafia. MM defended her so he's mafia.
But, wait! That's using cave logic. Town, I have some instructions for you and it's :
Lynch Cave Dog. Do it. There is no reason for itrombe to be alive, but that would make it perfect for him, an innocent townie to be lynched. However, I was killed by mafia: This is something that is also a part of my role that isn't released when I die. When I die, I'm informed if it was mafia that killed me. Mafia killed me. If itrombe is dead, then CAVE IS MAFIA. Do NOT let him duck out of this. The other person I suspect is Marrend. Marrend has been sooooo cryptic with his posts and generally lurky like he has been when previously mafia. He has also done nothing for town. Nothing. Liberty was hounded by Cave so much she's innocent. rabitZ is a nulltell. Just because he was acting completely innocent does not mean anything.
Who I think is scumteam:
CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
Marrend (Wrong?)
MirrorMasq
MrChearlie (Wrong)
In that order. MM is low on my suspect list but still there, because Cave did not directly attack MM after he said Lib wasn't at fault (though she obviously was). And MrChearlie because he was the very first on the Liberty bandwagon. Now, if a bandwagon is started by mafia another mafia is usually going to help the badwagon look like a good idea because people are more likely to join the more people there are and vice versa. The most likely person to join is another of his group, that being mafia theoretically.
IF ITROMBE IS ALIVE:
Ask him who he protected first. If he protected cave: Then Cave and itrombe are clear. The only person cunning enough to fake being weak doctor with someone as inexperienced as itrombe is cave. However, Cave would never allow itrombe to protect himself (Cave) because he knows that if town kills off itrombe, he'd be fucked. Therefore: If either are mafia it's one or the other. If itrombe lives and says he protected Cave they are both clear.
Um, I think I read that wrong. >.<;
Okay, so let me get this straight.
First, Marrend is ???, according to Gourd's letter.
Then, last night, itrombe protected you, ivory, yes?
Okay, so let me get this straight.
First, Marrend is ???, according to Gourd's letter.
Then, last night, itrombe protected you, ivory, yes?
I'm sorry. It's late/early and I've been looking after my sister's colicky baby, so I haven't had much sleep. I've not been 'absorbing' the information. I'll come back to it tomorrow and see if it makes better sense then. >.<;
...did you not read about my suicide condition. If me or Chearlie got killed, the other dies. Since Chearlie was dead, that means I was proteced. D'oh.
author=ivoryjones
No, that last post wasn't the post I was referring to. Search again. Hint: the word "day 3" and "day 4" in it.
And MM, what does itrombe's death has to do with cave's innocence if he clearly protected me this night. Was that a scum-DB mess up just now or what.
How is it clearly? oO
He said he's gonna protect Cave.
Jeroen_Sol
Nothing reveals Humanity so well as the games it plays. A game of betrayal, where the most suspicious person is brutally murdered? How savage.
3885
author=ivoryjones
Why did Jeroen said 11 alive. I thought only 2 (3?) were killed.
When I say alive I mean playing the game.
Gourd died
Chearlie died
Marrend died
thatbennyguy went missing
Therefore 11 people are currently playing the game.
















