Full Games List
Featured Games
New Games
Reviews
Media
Images
Blogs
Game Updates
Images Feedback Summary
Game Design Highlights
Tutorials
Articles
Scripts
Utilities / Plugins
Resources
Engines
Engine Bulletins
What is Makerscore?
Past Events
Achievements
Misaos
Forums
Post History
Chat
New to RMN?
Full Store List
RMN Music Pack (free)
DOCTER MAFIA: STOP THOSE SNATCHER SCUM!
Posts
thatbennyguy
1612
thatbennyguy
View playlists
CloseOK so I protected MirrorMasq this round, but he still dies. Which means I'm not binary odd, paranoid, sane, or bodyguard. I am either Binary Even, Insane, or Naive doc. Liberty is confirmed CPR, and I'm guessing that she killed this night, so she killed either Mirror or LWG. I'd assume that she killed LWG because he was lurking, but she can talk on that front.
So we've got 5 innocents, and 1 mafia. If we can weed out all our reports, and logically sift through them all, I reckon we can come to an almost 100% certainty of who is mafia.
My guesses are:
Liberty - CPR (100%)
Benny - Insane (since I missed a day, and nobody died that day)
MrChearlie -
Dudesoft -
RabitZ -
ivoryjones -
If anyone can fill in any blanks by roleclaiming, that'd be great.
So we've got 5 innocents, and 1 mafia. If we can weed out all our reports, and logically sift through them all, I reckon we can come to an almost 100% certainty of who is mafia.
My guesses are:
Liberty - CPR (100%)
Benny - Insane (since I missed a day, and nobody died that day)
MrChearlie -
Dudesoft -
RabitZ -
ivoryjones -
If anyone can fill in any blanks by roleclaiming, that'd be great.
I seem to be a safe doctor for protecting. I protected myself, and am fine. I protected Liberty and she is fine. So, my protecting either does nothing or is safe. However from the flavour in my pm's I don't think I'm normal. I'm probably not insane nor paranoid.
My hand seems to be an issue. I dunno. If there's such a thing as normal town, nothing special, that's probably me. I'm also in a wheelchair if that matters?
My hand seems to be an issue. I dunno. If there's such a thing as normal town, nothing special, that's probably me. I'm also in a wheelchair if that matters?
I have an issue with you, Chearlie.
You claimed to be Paranoid, but I decided to prove it by protecting Dudes, who I felt was acting oddly. I was free to roam the hospital, doing so, however, a few things happened:
1) he wasn't in his office when I checked it.
2) ran into an Estonian doctor who made me feel sleepy. (hypnosis?)
3) we both looked for Dudes but never found him.
Firstly, how was I out and about when Chearlie was supposed to be locking me up in my office? Secondly, where was Dudes?
You claimed to be Paranoid, but I decided to prove it by protecting Dudes, who I felt was acting oddly. I was free to roam the hospital, doing so, however, a few things happened:
1) he wasn't in his office when I checked it.
2) ran into an Estonian doctor who made me feel sleepy. (hypnosis?)
3) we both looked for Dudes but never found him.
Firstly, how was I out and about when Chearlie was supposed to be locking me up in my office? Secondly, where was Dudes?
Dudes, you might be Naive: neither you or I were targeted those nights so there might not be any reactions to prove or disprove your protective abilities.
Also, as I targeted Dudes, I was shocked to find two doctors dead. Seems the Insane struck last night. If so, that lends credence to Benny, but, uh, the second strike would be mafia, not me. Two in one night - one for mafia, one for Insane.
Also, as I targeted Dudes, I was shocked to find two doctors dead. Seems the Insane struck last night. If so, that lends credence to Benny, but, uh, the second strike would be mafia, not me. Two in one night - one for mafia, one for Insane.
Liberty: CPR (100%)
TBG: Insane - Even - Naive -Odd - Paranoid - Sane - Bodyguard - Mafia
Chearlie: Insane - Even - Naive - Odd -Paranoid - Sane - Bodyguard - Mafia
Dudes: Insane - Even - Naive - Odd - Paranoid - Sane - Bodyguard - Mafia
RabitZ: Insane - Even - Naive - Odd - Paranoid - Sane - Bodyguard - Mafia
ivory: Insane - Even - Naive - Odd - Paranoid - Sane - Bodyguard - Mafia
That's what I figure so far. Just remember, just because Mirror died doesn't mean that Benny is confirmed anything. With two deaths come two possibilities: Benny might be Insane, but he might also be mafia pretending to be insane and the real Insane might be whoever protected LWG. Just, keep it in mind.
TBG: Insane - Even - Naive -
Chearlie: Insane - Even - Naive - Odd -
Dudes: Insane - Even - Naive - Odd - Paranoid - Sane - Bodyguard - Mafia
RabitZ: Insane - Even - Naive - Odd - Paranoid - Sane - Bodyguard - Mafia
ivory: Insane - Even - Naive - Odd - Paranoid - Sane - Bodyguard - Mafia
That's what I figure so far. Just remember, just because Mirror died doesn't mean that Benny is confirmed anything. With two deaths come two possibilities: Benny might be Insane, but he might also be mafia pretending to be insane and the real Insane might be whoever protected LWG. Just, keep it in mind.
ivoryjones
75
Wait, if you are CPR and you protected dudes, shouldn't he be dead? Unless he's the odd doctor.
When I was protecting rabitz, the lights suddenly turned off and he was searching for a flashlight. After the lights came back, he was still searching for a flashlight.
I don't think Chearlie is mafia because he was one of the first (I think?) who voted for Jeroen.
When I was protecting rabitz, the lights suddenly turned off and he was searching for a flashlight. After the lights came back, he was still searching for a flashlight.
I don't think Chearlie is mafia because he was one of the first (I think?) who voted for Jeroen.
Or, alternatively, LWG could have been mod-killed. If so, that means only Mirror was actively killed. If that is true, then Benny could be either Evens or Naive or Mafia or neither. If Mirror was Bodyguard he could have taken the kill for Benny.
Damn, this is leading us nowhere productive. Right, let's all - write out (without quoting) the general information given to us via our PMs,
AND
Write out a list of who we're most suspicious of at the moment.
Also, a plan for tonight might be a good idea. Ivory, any ideas?
Damn, this is leading us nowhere productive. Right, let's all - write out (without quoting) the general information given to us via our PMs,
AND
Write out a list of who we're most suspicious of at the moment.
Also, a plan for tonight might be a good idea. Ivory, any ideas?
ivoryjones
75
Cave didn't state if he was gonna be modkilled or not. If he's willing to tell us, great, if not, then there's a high chance he was killed.
TBG and dudesoft are top on my list for now, Chearlie I'm leaning more on town. Did he ever said he protected you that night?
TBG and dudesoft are top on my list for now, Chearlie I'm leaning more on town. Did he ever said he protected you that night?
Well, the night I protect mirror Mask someone tried to breakt into the office, the next day, you killed gourd, TBG didn't did anything and now it seems he is the insane one, so I give in fact that mafia tried to kill mirror and I protect him (at the beggining I though it was backwards), due that it says that they couldn't open it, I assume that I was the paranoic, although I don't get the point in my last PM.
Although it don't said that is dudes, it refers as him, as "someone". I don't how relevant are the PM, since TBG, and gourd also said they were chances of being paranoics. So maybe lock in the office isn't as relevant as I though. But I am sure I can protect someone, maybe even doctor.
author=Liberty
3) we both looked for Dudes but never found him.
Although it don't said that is dudes, it refers as him, as "someone". I don't how relevant are the PM, since TBG, and gourd also said they were chances of being paranoics. So maybe lock in the office isn't as relevant as I though. But I am sure I can protect someone, maybe even doctor.
Maybe, but just because you vote on someone doesn't mean you're not mafia. It's a well-used tactic to make you seem less guilty by casting a vote on your mafia partner. Even better if you do it first.
Dudes might be the Odd doctor, or his partner might have intervened. Who should have been LWG. He should have been protecting LWG. Why wasn't he? This is the second time he's broken from the plan. Dudes, not on, man. Though I guess it saved your bacon this time.
We can't do a protect ourselves tonight plan. We need to lynch someone today and maybe a chain would be a good idea?
Dudes might be the Odd doctor, or his partner might have intervened. Who should have been LWG. He should have been protecting LWG. Why wasn't he? This is the second time he's broken from the plan. Dudes, not on, man. Though I guess it saved your bacon this time.
Ivory<>rabitZMirror<>BennyLWG>Dudes>Jeroen>LWG
Chearlie<>Me
We can't do a protect ourselves tonight plan. We need to lynch someone today and maybe a chain would be a good idea?
ivoryjones
75
Ok, plan. We are deadmeat if we lynch wrong today since the insane might not get lucky tonight, if we go for partners, the insane might just accidentally kill his partner. A protect-chain is probably worse than partners for obvious reasons. We could opt for protecting ourselves again, just to make sure what one of us are if mafia targets us and not you liberty, is that good?
ivoryjones
75
Ok, well plan B:
We could choose to lynch either tbg or dude, or maybe even chearlie (but I'll lean more on the former 2). If we lynch wrong, we can protect ourselves and you can kill either dude or chearlie, liberty. Is that good?
We could choose to lynch either tbg or dude, or maybe even chearlie (but I'll lean more on the former 2). If we lynch wrong, we can protect ourselves and you can kill either dude or chearlie, liberty. Is that good?
thatbennyguy
1612
OK so we got a cross on Liberty and Chearlie. Liberty and Chearlie share the same message, therefore they are both clear. WOOHOO!
Plus, if I was mafia, why would I get my own partner Jeroen_Sol lynched? I mean, if my life was on the line, why would I make my partner be lynched. Isn't that kind of a scumbag move?
The fact that Liberty's & Chearlie's protection of Dudesoft failed is perhaps due to the fact that he is Estonian doctor and does not get affected by any night actions. This would solve the problem of Liberty not protecting Gourd from death night 2. Anyone catching my drift? Or do I stand alone on this?
Plus, if I was mafia, why would I get my own partner Jeroen_Sol lynched? I mean, if my life was on the line, why would I make my partner be lynched. Isn't that kind of a scumbag move?
The fact that Liberty's & Chearlie's protection of Dudesoft failed is perhaps due to the fact that he is Estonian doctor and does not get affected by any night actions. This would solve the problem of Liberty not protecting Gourd from death night 2. Anyone catching my drift? Or do I stand alone on this?
Chearlie, you and me again tonight. And a chain with the rest (just take out whoever we lynch).
Also, we should all be very happy that we got Jeroen. ^.^
So, random plan:
Ivory>Dudes>Benny>rabitZ>Ivory
Chearlie<>Me
Sound good?
Personally I'm suspicious of rabitZ (for never saying much and lying low a lot - I can't get a read on him), Dudes (PM - if he was protecting himself, he should have been in his office) and Chearlie (you locked Mirror in, or claimed to, but I wasn't. Who's your character?)
Also, we should all be very happy that we got Jeroen. ^.^
So, random plan:
Ivory>Dudes>Benny>rabitZ>Ivory
Chearlie<>Me
Sound good?
Personally I'm suspicious of rabitZ (for never saying much and lying low a lot - I can't get a read on him), Dudes (PM - if he was protecting himself, he should have been in his office) and Chearlie (you locked Mirror in, or claimed to, but I wasn't. Who's your character?)
ivoryjones
75
Who the hell cares why you'd do it. You've "missed out" a lot, so you "couldn't" have done anything to "prevent your partner from being lynched".
thatbennyguy
1612
Hmmm after re-reading that it seems like I'm rambling a bit. Let me rephrase:
- MrChearlie and Liberty both claim to share the same flavour text. Since there is only one mafia, and Liberty is confirmed clear, it is almost certain that these two are DOCTER-aligned, from my point of view.
- The fact that their night actions did not work on Dudesoft makes it seem as though Dudesoft was able to override their actions, which we saw some of in night 2. in night 2, Liberty tried to protect Gourd_Clae, but caught a glimpse of an estonian doctor in the distance. Mind you, dudesoft saw 2 estonian doctors playing chess, so whatever.
- MrChearlie and Liberty both claim to share the same flavour text. Since there is only one mafia, and Liberty is confirmed clear, it is almost certain that these two are DOCTER-aligned, from my point of view.
- The fact that their night actions did not work on Dudesoft makes it seem as though Dudesoft was able to override their actions, which we saw some of in night 2. in night 2, Liberty tried to protect Gourd_Clae, but caught a glimpse of an estonian doctor in the distance. Mind you, dudesoft saw 2 estonian doctors playing chess, so whatever.
