DOCTER MAFIA: STOP THOSE SNATCHER SCUM!

Posts

Nice to see you still thinking on your feet! :D
I make the plan, you refine it and point out what I missed. Okay, so let's see.
As long as both myself and Chearlie are protected securely...

Chearlie protects self.
Two people protect me (just in case one is mafia.) NOT TBG, since he's believed to be Insane. So... TBG can protect himself, if he's still alive.
That leaves rabitZ, ivory and Dudes. The left over can protect themselves.

Chearlie < Chearlie
Liberty < Dudes, RabitZ, Ivory
TBG < TBG

If TBG is lynched, then one of you can protect yourself. If Ivory, rabitZ or Dudes is lynched, then the living two protect me.

Fine?
This is a really nice plan. Now here are the possibilities if we nolynch.

Chearlie < Chearlie <-- I'm pretty sure he's paranoid, therefore he won't get killed.
Liberty < Dudes, RabitZ, Ivory <-- one of these guys is mafia, so I suspect that at least one of the other two will protect Liberty here. If mafia decides to kill one of the guys protecting, then they will surely die. That will leave 2 people to choose from.
TBG < TBG <-- well I'm insane most probably, so I'll probably kill myself. If CAVE accepts option of protecting nobody, I will.

Seems legit, but I feel a bit vulnerable by my lonesome. Ah well, I guess no-one needs a crazy doctor anyway.
You told us earlier that both of us should protect Chearlie, who is probably paranoid, yet you still want us to protect him. WTF? "Thinking on your feet" my ass. -inhales-

Either TBG or dudesoft is probably lynched today, so I'm fine with that plan.
Um, what? No, you're protecting me. Chearlie is protecting himself. The plan is just making sure he and I get through to the end.
We lynch today. If that's a miss, I kill someone tonight. Mafia will make their kill. That takes us down to three, unless I hit the mafia. Then there's just me, Chearlie and mafia Joe. We lynch him, game won.

What. Wasn't it supposed to be either rabitz or me protect you? Why do -both- of us need to protect you?
author=ivoryjones
You told us earlier that both of us should protect Chearlie, who is probably paranoid, yet you still want us to protect him. WTF? "Thinking on your feet" my ass. -inhales-


>.<;
The Chearlie protects self was a last second addition, hence why I hadn't given thought to the repercussions of that point. That said, I'm happy you caught it.
Now, let's get one of these guys out the way. But first we need to make sure everyone is on board with the plan.
Because if one of you is mafia, there's the issue of me being unprotected and open for mafia kill.
With two protecting me, there's extra safety - making sure I make it to tomorrow. In fact, if three protect (say we got rid of TBG) then I could kill off one and still be sure of being protected. But the current plan works. Unless you can see something else wrong with it, in which case, please point out!
Dudesoft
always a dudesoft, never a soft dude.
6309
I have nothing to add to this so far.
If I'm dead tomorrow, fellow doctors, enjoy losing.

#lynch thatbennyguy
Wait, Chearlie protected you the night before right liberty? If you could "roam freely", then doesn't that make him not paranoid?
Sorry for being a little late, water temple are always a pain in the ass u.u

...I also don't get why would people protect me if I am protecting my self o.O

I really think that is dudes, so just lets plan tonigh in case we haven't find the last mafia and contiue with our votes. so, first I read
I protect myself, and liberty protects me.
and the others do a bunch of things?

Okay what about this:
I protect myself, Liberty protects me, and everyone protects Liberty, and just in case TBG protects himself.
Sorry about my last post, it is very similiar to what have you been saying, I didn't see there was 39 pages, so that is an answer for 38 page :/
I won't protect you, Chearlie, since it's my job to cut down the number and try to strike the mafia in our midst if we miss him today. We literally have only today, tonight and tomorrow to win.
One lynch today, one kill by us(me) tonight and a last lynch tomorrow. If we don't get mafia by then, we're done. Mafia wins. By striking as much as possible, with two confirmed town, we can take the fight to the mafia. They might try to strike us down, but they won't be able to win.

Ivory, the reason why is a combination of Chearlie protecting Mirror (who was innocent and attacked. If he hadn't been town, he wouldn't have been able to protect Mirror from the attack) and that I was halted from 'protecting' Dudes last night.
Personally, I don't think Chearlie is confirmed paranoid, but I do believe that he's a doctor. Most likely either sane, paranoid or Odds. He can't be naive, mafia or Bodyguard since he successfully protected Mirror from attack. He might be Insane, but there's no surety of that. If he's sane, paranoid or odds, he'll protect himself successfully tonight. That's all we want.
Okey Dokey, then liberty's plan it is
#Lynch Dudesoft
Players alive
rabitZ
TBG
MrChearlie
Dudesoft
Liberty
Ivory

Unofficial count
Dudes: TBG, Chearlie
TBG: Dudes, Ivory

Awaiting confirmation for plan
rabitZ, Ivory, Dudesoft

Current Plan
Day 4
Lynch someone - TBG or Dudes.

Night 5
Chearlie - protects self
TBG - protects self
rabitZ, Ivory, Dudes - protects Liberty

Liberty kills off suspect mafia.

Day 5
If mafia still alive: Chearlie, Liberty lynch surviving mafia.
Well, are you going to put up a vote liberty? I'm fine with either.
I want to wait for rabitZ to say he'll join in the plan first. Otherwise it might mess up.
I'll probably be voting for Dudes - not only because I feel suspicious of him, but also because he's proven he can't be trusted to stick to plans even when he says he well. This is twice he's gone against plan. (Yeah, I know I can't talk since I also went against plan last night, but I was sure that Chearlie would stop my ability and since I didn't end up accidentally killing Dudes, it seems I was right.)
Yellow Magic
Could I BE any more Chandler Bing from Friends (TM)?
3229
author=flavortext
Mirrormasq, who was Dr. Who, DOCTER-aligned Doctor, has been killed Night 3.

Erm there's no such thing as a Doctor Who >:(