RMN'S FANTASY VANILLA MAFIA (GAME THREAD)

Hi guys. I don't know where CAVE is getting this theory I visited Chearlie. I didn't. Either he really is a tracker and we've got a bus driver, or he's lying.

or, alternately, it was the right answer. ##unvote

Let us all join hands and reread the game

Oh okay. Rereading it is.

Um, okay, let's see. Firstly, let me do some quotes:

author=Liberty
And I'm back. I'll read up more in a mo, but I'll answer this one right off the bat.

author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
I have a question for Liberty first though. You keep saying that you think I am probably not mafia, but independent.

Why is that? What is working in your brain that leads you to believe that I am independent over scum? Why is the possibility of me being scum too remote for you to consider?

Most of the games I've played with you in them, I tend to get a feeling when you're mafia. I'm not getting that feeling at the moment (I could be wrong, but I've learned to trust my gut when it comes to you. It's not been wrong on a Cave-read before) but I'm not wholly convinced you're town, either. I dunno, it's a combination of your tone, reaction to things people have said and gut feeling. It's hard to pinpoint just one thing that leads to my conclusion, but yeah. I just don't get the mafia vibe from you like I do when you are mafia.

Oh hi there, answer to your previous question which you seemed to just skip over.

author=Liberty
Gourd, as to your first post after night - sure it could have been worse, but we've lost another townie as well as a useful power. That's not as good as it could have gone, either.

Cave: so you have some sort of investigative ability. I'll believe you for now, but I too would like to hear back from Jeroen about his night visit. It could be for a number of reasons, but it is rather suspicious - namely because if he was a Doctor, he'd have protected Chearlie, which leads to him being something suspicious... if what you claim is true.

Oh hello there, piece of information that you skipped over or didn't bother to read at all.

Yeah, you're acting like scum, jumping at everyone. Who has the most votes in this game so far, Cave? You do.

Do I think you're mafia? I'm starting to question my gut feeling that you aren't because of the way you're acting and screwing words and meanings.

I'm most suspicious of Gourd again, tbh.

Also, both Mirror and I need to level up on being town.
I need to enhance my scumreading
He needs to enhance being... Helpful and not antitown all the way cross the sky.

So we have a hammerer. This hammerer is either a doublevoter In which case it's probably someone who voted for Mirror, or someone who sends his votes anonymously. Is there anyone who didn't vote whatsoever yesterday?

Well... No there isn't enough evidence for that.

Actually, I just realized something. Bus driver switches two targets around, not actors. I can't have targeted anyone, seeing I didn't do anything. CAVE, what's that even all about?

The answer works because frankly, it's the truth. I'm leaning towards not being mafia because I just don't feel like you're mafia. I may be wrong, but I can't help how I feel. You can't just turn your gut on and off, you know.

As I was trying to point out that there could have been other reasons than just mafia for the night visit, I just pointed out the first that came to mind which just happened to be Doctor. (Probably because of the last game) But I also pointed out that it wasn't a viable option because of Chearlie's death.

Cave: so you have some sort of investigative ability. I'll believe you for now, but I too would like to hear back from Jeroen about his night visit. It could be for a number of reasons, but it is rather suspicious - namely because if he was a Doctor, he'd have protected Chearlie, which leads to him being something suspicious... if what you claim is true.

>.<;
It's in the wording. Allow me to break it down for you.
First I put "I too would like to hear back from Jeroen about his night visit." You can see that I would also like to see that he has to say about this.
"It could be for a number of reasons," - I point out that it may not just be the most suspicious reason - basically, let's not get ahead of ourselves and jump on the guy because there could be multiple reasons for said visit - if it even occurred.
"but it is rather suspicious " - well, a night visit is suspicious.
"if he was a Doctor," - first night action that involves interaction besides mafia to jump in my head. I would have said Cop or Investigative role if it had occurred to me first. But this also points out a role that he cannot use to explain away the visit if he tries to explain, especially when coupled with the next line - "he'd have protected Chearlie," which we know isn't true because Chearlie died. Hence by pointing it out in such a manner it is struck from the possibility list.
"which leads to him being something suspicious..." - again, true.

Do you now understand? Must I dissect some more?

It's not so much the voting for multiple people as it is the jumping from one person to the next to the next. Usually town sticks to just a handful of people they are suspicious of - and I've noticed that you do this a lot. You might point out that people seem suspicious and why but your votes tend to rotate around the group you're most suspicious of and you tend to latch onto a couple of people and don't let go. It's odd behaviour for you.

good answer. a post with that many words can't possibly be wrong.

as for jumping between people, you have to look at the context of the votes. my first vote on adon was legitimate. my second vote on him was because I got confused and thought he had only made two posts this game. my vote on shinan was a joke because he claimed mafia and i unvoted immediately. vote on ym was real. vote on mirrormasq was real. vote on jeroen was to get him to try and admit something and the vote on you was also because i thought you were mafia, although I am leaning the other way now.

##unvote

I'm torn now. Want to lynch Yellow Magic again because I feel like he should be been lynchable yesterday, but wasn't. Getting the feeling now that the scumteam is primarily composed of lurkers coasting along. marrend, despite, chana, adon. thatbennyguy has seemed more quiet and less wild than he usually is.

Good morning guys nice to see I'm alive *sees lynchvote* ffs.

Can I see concrete reasons, CAVE_DOG?

You've only got one way to stop this murder, Yellow Magic. You've gotta vote for Adon to be killed. I've just about figured this whole game out and this will break it wide open.