RMN'S FANTASY VANILLA MAFIA (GAME THREAD)

Wait, is it only -5 GMT?

Aspirin, ivory, aspirin.

*puts hands up in despair*

I was just preparing the ultimate bluff too.

...not that it'll do us any good now...

I have school from 7-2:40 and then soccer at around 3:30-5:00 and then homework and stuff and science Olympiad on Tuesdays and geeze I do not have a lot of RM time anymore ;_;

So anyway, Cave, lynching people all over the place the whole game doesn't really make anybody side with you, and you look very scummy. Of course there is the possibility that you are so used to being scum that being a townie isn't really your thing. Regardless, I have not been convinced of anybody being mafia, but there are still mafia among us!

author=Adon237
I

So anyway, Cave, lynching people all over the place the whole game doesn't really make anybody side with you, and you look very scummy. Of course there is the possibility that you are so used to being scum that being a townie isn't really your thing. Regardless, I have not been convinced of anybody being mafia, but there are still mafia among us!

I've gone over this before but voting for multiple people is not a scumtell and you are, how do I say this, bad at mafia if you think that is the case. Like, seriously. Does someone want to explain to me the logical connection between voting for multiple people and being scum?

Hi, I'm not lurking, my online hours just do not correespond to most people's and it's that way game after gamen. This settled, I am still flabbergasted at how MM, BEING A COP, did almoqst everything he could to get lynched on day1.......????
Second point : CAVE started the bandwagon on MM, who, in his eyes, passed in the lapse of a few post from "most scummy" to fairly scummy" to.... "town", no more no less!! with no serious explanation whatsoever from one point of view to the other; AND when it was quasi certain MM was going to be lynched CAVE backed out, I would sy CAVE is almost(?) undoubtedly mafia.
YM insisted on lynching MM, but a lot of people did (frankly who wouldn't have), and it does not, imo, prove a thing, for all we know he could be the doctor, which would explain a certain reserve.
As for Liberty, the wishy washyness seems to be the rule (sorry Liberty!) and I haven't detected any scumminess for now but I will reread her posts.
I agree that Gourd's quasi affirmation of Adon's innocence after 1(?) post of the latter is suspect, in the same way that CAVE seemed at least imo, to KNOW MM was town.
Lastly, I don't understand why the overtalkative Ivory has been SO silent, school?
To say that, at this point, I would vote CAVE with quasi no hesitation, which I will most probably do later on, but the day is still very young.

This is a very dishonest post. You asked me before what I thought made Mirrormasq less scummy and I gave you a direct answer.

Nothing. It's what Yellow Magic and Liberty have said.

I was not saying he was less scummy. I was saying that he was not the best lynch for that day. If I wanted him lynched, I could have just stayed on, gotten him lynched sooner, and done damage control later. I voted for Yellow Magic because I wanted him dead.

And this:

Well, for example, before she "became" town for you, she had "become" fairly scum, the two without any explanations in between.(To me it definitely had something to do with the preceding post as I didn't know your nolynch theory went to the point of preferring to lynch a townie rather than no lynch.)

is not true, because I did give you an explanation. There were better lynch targets available. In my big list where I guessed the alignments of posters, which immediately preceded this post, I didn't even say that Mirrormasq was town. I said he was mirrormasq AKA awful.

You also made this post.

ok, I've been reading Ym's posts and am not convinced, as for MM, there's that chickening out of the bet and right off attack of CAVE without any reason (yes, Jeroen), which seems substantial enough, so :
#Cancel
#Lynch MirrorMasq
and, yes, CAVE, his alignment should shed some light on yours considering you practically (momentarily) saved him from the lynch by cancelling.

This post looks very bad now that you are going for me. It looks to me an awful lot like you were hedging your bets here with that last line. In the scenario that Mirrormasq was scum, you probably would have said that I tried to stop the lynch because he was my scumbuddy. Since he was town, you are saying that I tried to stop the lynch because I knew he was town.

##unvote
##Lynch Chana

I guess it's unlikely, but we should be careful nonetheless. I currently have no idea who the scumteam is, as I quite often find myself agreeing with CAVE over and over when reading his posts, but have yet to actually figure anything out by myself. I'll check back on some people's posts when I have the time.

I'll go catch some Zs now, see y'all later.

You said : "actually to be honest with my opinion of mirrormasq being town" after arriving at the conclusion that he was only "fairly scum" from "the scummiest" (this last shift of opinion, yes, you did somewhat explain, but not the first, and without MM saying anything particularly significant in between) : which was for the least weird! (backing out of voting for him was only the logical (prepared?) move to make after that).

because I was playing off the assumption that, if yellow magic and/or liberty were scum, which I believed, then mirrormasq would not fit in with their scumteam. i was not stating that he was town, but that i was going to assume that he was as it would fit in with my worldview where one of liberty or yellow magic was scum. i may have not worded it the best, but I have explained it multiple times so I'm not sure why you are still going after this.

also, i don't see why mirrormasq has to say anything at all for my opinion of him to change. I reread the thread and develop new viewpoints on people as I gain new information. Something person x says can convince me that person y is probably not scum if person x has been trying to lynch person y all day.

your insistence that not unvoting mirrormasq was "the logical move" rather than "the town move" is very bad because you framed this earlier in a way that would make it so there was no way I could not be scum. I unvoted Mirrormasq and told people in very large letters to vote for Yellow Magic. Why did I tell people to vote for Yellow Magic? Because I did not want Mirrormasq lynched. Are you honestly going to tell me that, not only did I know that people would follow my lynch on Mirrormasq, that I also knew that people would stubbornly refuse to NOT vote for Yellow Magic when I called for it repeatedly? Where in this master plan does the scenario where people actually voted for Yellow Magic fit in?

This post looks very bad now that you are going for me. It looks to me an awful lot like you were hedging your bets here with that last line. In the scenario that Mirrormasq was scum, you probably would have said that I tried to stop the lynch because he was my scumbuddy. Since he was town, you are saying that I tried to stop the lynch because I knew he was town.

we have ~30 hours or something. I want to lynch either Gourd or Chana today. Preferably Chana for this series of posts. Vigilante, if you are alive, shoot Gourd.

##unvote
##Lynch Gourd_Clae

We can't nolynch. Without a cop, you are essentially giving the scumteam a free kill and putting us at 12 players, and it is mathematically advantageous to stay at an odd number, so stop spreading your votes out.