RMN'S FANTASY VANILLA MAFIA (GAME THREAD)
Posts
I'm on board for lynching mirrormasq if everyone else is. We can afford to lynch wrongly at this early stage.
Jeroen_Sol
Nothing reveals Humanity so well as the games it plays. A game of betrayal, where the most suspicious person is brutally murdered? How savage.
3885
Right now my eye's on Gourd and Mirror. I'm not quite sure about you, Adon, but you're most definitely not in the clear. Shinan is either being a genius mafia with a brilliant sense of reverse psychology or just a Village Idiot.
I'll be gone for a while guys, catch y'all later.
I'll be gone for a while guys, catch y'all later.
I was not asking whether I was in the 'clear' or not, I was seeing what you thought about Cave and the other accused scum, but my bad.
I think Shinan is mafia, moreso than TBG right now, plus he is lurking.
I think Shinan is mafia, moreso than TBG right now, plus he is lurking.
Well of course I am mafia. I've said so much. YM and MM are also mafia and then the fourth one is...
Well to be honest we're keeping the fourth one hidden for now because you know. If people start believing us and killing us off (like what seems to be happening with MM now) it's good to at least have one we didn't openly out.(but it's ivoryjones)
Well to be honest we're keeping the fourth one hidden for now because you know. If people start believing us and killing us off (like what seems to be happening with MM now) it's good to at least have one we didn't openly out.(but it's ivoryjones)
Now that I have a slightly clearer head, let's see if I can't post something more productive.
For one thing, I'm not reading the initial votes in this thread as "joke-votes". Everyone seemed to come off as rather serious to me. Next, there's Shinan, and his shenanigans. I have no clue what to make of that. Thirdly, there's the argument between CAVE_DOG and MirrorMasq. It's giving me bad vibes all over the place.
For one thing, I'm not reading the initial votes in this thread as "joke-votes". Everyone seemed to come off as rather serious to me. Next, there's Shinan, and his shenanigans. I have no clue what to make of that. Thirdly, there's the argument between CAVE_DOG and MirrorMasq. It's giving me bad vibes all over the place.
Hi, all, and I step in as half the players are gone to bed as usual... so I've read those 8 pages :
Shinan is his wild self as usual, it would be improbable but funny if he was really mafia, though if it was revealed true at his death, it also could be a clever way to denounce townies as mafia as people would hesitate to beleive him, so : joke or clever sacrifice?
CAVE is lying, imo, every other line (or does it hide some meaning), so suspicious but no certainty.
TBG is town, imo.
Gourd seems passably suspicious? as for MM I haven't seen any sign of him being mafia for the time.
Lastly, Adon seems rather quiet.
So much for what I've read, of course they're first impressions.
Shinan is his wild self as usual, it would be improbable but funny if he was really mafia, though if it was revealed true at his death, it also could be a clever way to denounce townies as mafia as people would hesitate to beleive him, so : joke or clever sacrifice?
CAVE is lying, imo, every other line (or does it hide some meaning), so suspicious but no certainty.
TBG is town, imo.
Gourd seems passably suspicious? as for MM I haven't seen any sign of him being mafia for the time.
Lastly, Adon seems rather quiet.
So much for what I've read, of course they're first impressions.
author=Shinan
Well of course I am mafia. I've said so much. YM and MM are also mafia
Well, what can I say? It's true...
Shinan, why did you what are you even what
ok forget that
Yeah this is really all over the place!!
ok, YM supporting Shinan means the former is not mafia, as for YM? or do they both think we can only take it as a joke, especially if they are two denouncing themselves? The most probable being that all this is a joke of course.
yeah i am going to say it is a joke because nobody would ever announce themselves as mafia, unless they are scewing with us and actually are mafia but ohh god
Yes, it's quite a predicament for you guys, isn't it...
Ok, I remember, Shinan would say (in some other game) :"Of course I'm town", now he's saying "Of course I'mafia" (i.e. :we're all suspicious?), so I beleive he's innocent. As for YM it's quite another story, I haven't found any interesting information in any of his posts but a lot of pictures, I'd say very suspicious.
Jeroen_Sol
Nothing reveals Humanity so well as the games it plays. A game of betrayal, where the most suspicious person is brutally murdered? How savage.
3885
Hmmm... Reverse psychology to the max here...
I think the most probable situation is both of them are town, but maybe one really is scum. It seems that way, they're trying to give off a vibe of not being on the same alignment. If they are truly masters of reverse psychology, this all might be an eleborate plan by mafia to make their members seem disconnected.
So basically I have no clue. Probably it's just a joke, but it's very plausible either is scum. If that's the case, the other isn't in the clear.
Dammit this is so ridiculous.
I think the most probable situation is both of them are town, but maybe one really is scum. It seems that way, they're trying to give off a vibe of not being on the same alignment. If they are truly masters of reverse psychology, this all might be an eleborate plan by mafia to make their members seem disconnected.
So basically I have no clue. Probably it's just a joke, but it's very plausible either is scum. If that's the case, the other isn't in the clear.
Dammit this is so ridiculous.
Adon, turn the PC off right now!

















