RMN'S FANTASY VANILLA MAFIA (GAME THREAD)
Posts
Day 4 Current Vote Count:
GameOverGames(1) --- ivoryjones
With 7 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.
About 48 hours until the Day 4 deadline (Monday at 11:59PM GMT-4).
If no hammer vote is reached, a NoLynch will occur.
Ok, I'm going to sleep guys, see you tomorrow.
GameOverGames(1) --- ivoryjones
With 7 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.
About 48 hours until the Day 4 deadline (Monday at 11:59PM GMT-4).
If no hammer vote is reached, a NoLynch will occur.
Ok, I'm going to sleep guys, see you tomorrow.
Jeroen_Sol
Nothing reveals Humanity so well as the games it plays. A game of betrayal, where the most suspicious person is brutally murdered? How savage.
3885
Okay, two scum down, two to go.
What does a watcher do? Is it like a tracker or something?
I find game's sudden rise in post frequency when gunned for very suspicious, not to mention the post where he says post frequency in scumchat might not make rabitZ as likely to kill lurky scum.
#lynch GamesoverGames Productions
Did I get the capitalization right?
What does a watcher do? Is it like a tracker or something?
I find game's sudden rise in post frequency when gunned for very suspicious, not to mention the post where he says post frequency in scumchat might not make rabitZ as likely to kill lurky scum.
#lynch GamesoverGames Productions
Did I get the capitalization right?
It's the weekend, so I have more time to post. Your reasoning is also horrible, of course I'm responding to someone trying to kill the wrong person when the Town only has 2 lynchs that it has to get a lynch right in before the Mafia wins. The modkill reasoning is good evidence, if you actually think about it. Lack of evidence is not completely sure reasoning; we're all better of if we wait a bit and examine the whole game so far.
Note that there are two mafia, so they could hammer after only two town votes though they might not, and could be at any position in the voting just to play it safe.
If I do get lynched, I implore the four remaining town members to look over Cave's recent posts for evidence of who he might have watched, and read over Gourd's QT messages carefully. I don't think YellowMagic is mafia, but he's been silent on the past days while two Mafia members were lynched (again, not guilt for sure, but something to keep in mind).
Also calling ivoryjones suspect.
Note that there are two mafia, so they could hammer after only two town votes though they might not, and could be at any position in the voting just to play it safe.
If I do get lynched, I implore the four remaining town members to look over Cave's recent posts for evidence of who he might have watched, and read over Gourd's QT messages carefully. I don't think YellowMagic is mafia, but he's been silent on the past days while two Mafia members were lynched (again, not guilt for sure, but something to keep in mind).
Also calling ivoryjones suspect.
Jeroen_Sol
Nothing reveals Humanity so well as the games it plays. A game of betrayal, where the most suspicious person is brutally murdered? How savage.
3885
I'm not sayig relying to some trying to lynch us suspicious in itself, just that not playing very much and suddenly being active when gunned for is. Although, I guess you're right it's the weekend.
I don't think scum would throw in two votes to hammer someone since that is very, very risky. Also, I don't think they'd hammer someone for the same reason.
Still unsure whether watcher is a tracker or a completely different role.
I don't think scum would throw in two votes to hammer someone since that is very, very risky. Also, I don't think they'd hammer someone for the same reason.
Still unsure whether watcher is a tracker or a completely different role.
Jeroen_Sol
Nothing reveals Humanity so well as the games it plays. A game of betrayal, where the most suspicious person is brutally murdered? How savage.
3885
Ok, now with fixed grammar:
I'm not saying replying to someone trying to lynch you...
Wtf iPod, be easier to type on.
I'm not saying replying to someone trying to lynch you...
Wtf iPod, be easier to type on.
CAVE_DOG was Indie after all. How am I not surprised...
author=ivory
Also, since he claimed to be a 'neighbourizer' (which I still think is an unusual role in this game), I am leaning towards ym because for some reason he thinks it's cool to pull me down with him. But IF ym DOES turn out town, then it's likely gourd is mafia. But right now, I've got my eye on someone, namely games, for the posts he made:
I can vouch for Gourd being a neighbourizer. As to whether he is a Townie or Mafia, I can't really say for certain, but his general posting style in the QT has been rather Townie-like.
p.s. GameOverGames isn't new to Mafia IIRC
author=GameOverGames Productions
It's the weekend, so I have more time to post. Your reasoning is also horrible, of course I'm responding to someone trying to kill the wrong person when the Town only has 2 lynchs that it has to get a lynch right in before the Mafia wins. The modkill reasoning is good evidence, if you actually think about it. Lack of evidence is not completely sure reasoning; we're all better of if we wait a bit and examine the whole game so far.
2 lynches isn't so bad, really. Better than LyLo, anyway, so we can almost afford to get this one wrong..once.
About this modkill issue;
somebody active in scumchat would be noticed by Rabitz and get away with posting less in the topic, i.e. not getting these threats of getting mod killed.
I don't know. You might have a point there, but at the same time that's kind of..unfair?
I don't think YellowMagic is mafia, but he's been silent on the past days while two Mafia members were lynched (again, not guilt for sure, but something to keep in mind).
Also calling ivoryjones suspect.
I wasn't able to speak on the last day because y'all voted while I was asleep. Gourd summarised everything I said in the QT pretty well, though, so I like to think I was there in spirit.
ivoryjones a suspect? You betcha.
Jeroen_Sol
Nothing reveals Humanity so well as the games it plays. A game of betrayal, where the most suspicious person is brutally murdered? How savage.
3885
Yellow Magic, who do you think is most suspicious right now?
My vote's still on Game, but we mustn't forget about chana and Marrend. Adon's jokevote was on chana, maybe he was saying 'just a starter lynch' because of it being a vote on scum? Just grasping there, but the more theories the merrier, I guess -.-
Anyway, Game is most suspicious.
My vote's still on Game, but we mustn't forget about chana and Marrend. Adon's jokevote was on chana, maybe he was saying 'just a starter lynch' because of it being a vote on scum? Just grasping there, but the more theories the merrier, I guess -.-
Anyway, Game is most suspicious.
Okay, I'm bored. Here's an analysis.
Chana: Participated in Mafia-lynching bandwagons twice. That's overly reckless, even by my standards.
Gourd_Clae: See above. Also a Neighbourizer, which is a role more useful of Townies (of course, we shouldn't read TOO much into that)
Jeroen: Same thing.
ivory: Helped lynch TBG, who was a Mafioso (that's the singular of 'Mafia', right?). Not Adon though. However it doesn't make a whole lot of sense to lynch the second Mafia member to go down, so idk.
Marrend: I don't think he's done much in this game, apart from a mostly-baseless vote on me. Probably Mafia #3.
GameOverGames: Has also barely posted. Voted for Adon tho.
Yellow Magic: Scum Magic (dohoho)
Right now, I'm thinking two of ivoryjones, Marrend and GameOverGamesProductions are Mafia members. Pretty clear cut from here on in, IMO, so I'm willing to lynch any of those three. Seeing as there are already two votes on GoG, though:
#lynch GameOverGames Productions
If this fails, we vote for Marrend, and then ivory, I think.
Chana: Participated in Mafia-lynching bandwagons twice. That's overly reckless, even by my standards.
Gourd_Clae: See above. Also a Neighbourizer, which is a role more useful of Townies (of course, we shouldn't read TOO much into that)
Jeroen: Same thing.
ivory: Helped lynch TBG, who was a Mafioso (that's the singular of 'Mafia', right?). Not Adon though. However it doesn't make a whole lot of sense to lynch the second Mafia member to go down, so idk.
Marrend: I don't think he's done much in this game, apart from a mostly-baseless vote on me. Probably Mafia #3.
GameOverGames: Has also barely posted. Voted for Adon tho.
Yellow Magic: Scum Magic (dohoho)
Right now, I'm thinking two of ivoryjones, Marrend and GameOverGamesProductions are Mafia members. Pretty clear cut from here on in, IMO, so I'm willing to lynch any of those three. Seeing as there are already two votes on GoG, though:
#lynch GameOverGames Productions
If this fails, we vote for Marrend, and then ivory, I think.
Jeroen_Sol
Nothing reveals Humanity so well as the games it plays. A game of betrayal, where the most suspicious person is brutally murdered? How savage.
3885
XD coincidences :P
author=Marrend
What about my "graph"? Not helpful enough?
Anyway, benny, are you going to place a vote on me? If you think I'm scum, and have a reason for such a suspicion, shouldn't you have voted on me? That's usually what one does. Isn't it?
I can't be the only one that finds this post seriously scummy?
Actually, I don't know! That second part is...idk.
Jeroen_Sol
Nothing reveals Humanity so well as the games it plays. A game of betrayal, where the most suspicious person is brutally murdered? How savage.
3885
Well, suppose he is scum. He'd be asking his buddy to vote for him, and calling him out... I dunno, but I think CAVE is one of the few who calls his buddies out. It's a nulltell, I guess...
YOUR recent post, games, is the horrible one. You're basically saying you're just actively lurking and would post only when it's almost at the games' end or you being threatened. And it doesn't even make sense that you're only posting since it's 'weekend' because I've seen you online several times already.
And no ym, I meant games being new to mafia as in never participated in a game with cave.
Also I don't think I need to remind everyone on the people who's had in with the awful MM bandwagon, yes? I am quite certain that one or even both of them are in there.
And no ym, I meant games being new to mafia as in never participated in a game with cave.
Also I don't think I need to remind everyone on the people who's had in with the awful MM bandwagon, yes? I am quite certain that one or even both of them are in there.
Jeroen_Sol
Nothing reveals Humanity so well as the games it plays. A game of betrayal, where the most suspicious person is brutally murdered? How savage.
3885
You´re probably right. 4 of us (me, YM, Game and chana) are still here, so there´s a high chance one of us is scum.
Since I'm gonna be busy with homework later, I'll just put this up first.
If you mafias try to do some shit with me or something this night, something horrible will happen to one of you. Put a sock on it. =)
If you mafias try to do some shit with me or something this night, something horrible will happen to one of you. Put a sock on it. =)
Let me think about this. We're either at 5/2/0 or 4/2/1 today. Mys-lynching today would probably bring us to 3/2/0, or 2/2/1 tomorrow. If we lynch correctly, though, we're looking at 5/1/0 or 4/1/1. Though, if there really are three independents in this game, then I have to take into consideration that we can lynch one. At which point, we would probably be at 3/2/0 tomorrow.

















