[PLAY TIME] BULLET BALLOT MAFIA

Piano(3): Kloe, Jeroen_Sol, Makiokuta, oddRABBIT
oddRABBIT (3): pianotm, Crystal_Mint, Yellow, Isrieri (likely)
Yellow Magic (2): Gourd_Clae, Crystal_Mint
Isrieri (1): ?

That's a little better actually. Who voted for Isrieri...?

Isrieri could have gone to piano OR odd. That means the liar is in one of those two lists.

I do not believe Kloe, Crystal or Jeroen lied. I know I didn't lie and the vote count is backing me up.

The liar (and most likely mafia) is YM or Maki and one of the two has a history of lying...

author=Crystal-Mint
I passed the null vote to LockeZ, but since he died that same night I'm assuming Libby just gave the null ballot to another random person.

I asked Libby about what would happen if a special ballot was sent to someone who was then killed by mafia, and she told me that she would send it to someone random. So that is indeed what probably happened there.

author=Kloe
I am a bit confused that no-one has been like "IT WAS YOU, KLOE!" yet, but tbf it isn't me, so I guess thats okay.

Kloe, you really want shade thrown at you that bad? The ONLY thing I could come up with for you is that you and piano orchestrated that overdramatic tirade to throw one of you under the bus to protect the other. But that is SO farfetched, I abandoned the idea quickly. That's all I got really.

Anyway, to clarify since people seemed confused by a few things in the middle of the day (though I THINK you all got it straight in the end)

oddRABBIT's vote was nulled by breaking a rule, not by a special vote.

I voted for pianotm, and nulled pianotm's vote which was most likely for oddRABBIT.

--

Back to the topic of votes.

Where did Yellow Magic say they voted for oddRABBIT? Isn't it possible that YM voted for Isrieri? All I see is a post with YM admitting they didn't vote for piano, and saying that they suspected oddRABBIT.

Also isn't it possible that Isrieri forgot to vote in time and voted for themselves that way? The Isrieri votes is so random!

It was obvious that piano was trying to get oddRABBIT to take the fall yesterday. So you would think that fellow mafia would vote along with him to strengthen the chance of oddRABBIT hanging. Unless piano knew his bacon was cooked and was leading that charge while all along telling the other mafia's to NOT follow him in the vote so there wouldn't be that connection.

author=MakioKuta
Kloe, you really want shade thrown at you that bad? The ONLY thing I could come up with for you is that you and piano orchestrated that overdramatic tirade to throw one of you under the bus to protect the other. But that is SO farfetched, I abandoned the idea quickly. That's all I got really.

Yeah I agree, especially since Kloe kind of just started attacking piano for no reason (there wasn't much suspicion against him at that point)

MakioKuta
Also isn't it possible that Isrieri forgot to vote in time and voted for themselves that way? The Isrieri votes is so random!

I was thinking this too, but isn't Isrieri an experienced player? I would assume that they wouldn't make such a mistake...(it's still possible though)

author=Crystal-Mint
Can mafia even communicate privately though? I assumed they could only talk to each other at night when they were deciding who to kill.

I have no idea o.o I just sorta assumed that they are able to make plans together??

As for Isieri, yeah-- others mentioned that they are an experienced player. But it's possible some sort of irl thing came up and they weren't able to vote. That vote has so little strategic gain that it feels more like a fluke than anything purposeful.

author=Crystal-Mint

author=Gourd_Clae

author=Crystal-Mint
Well, I think we can safely say that Yellow Magic is most likely not mafia xD

Why is that? Mafia make mistakes.

How likely is it that mafia would forget who they killed at night?
I mean, unless YM did that on purpose to throw us off, but it seems pretty unlikely.

It is strange that he seemed not to know at all since it was announced, but that is a good point.

You have a point though - Isrieri may not have voted in time and voted for themselves. In that way, everyone can be telling the truth.

So we think it went down like this:

Piano(3): Kloe, Jeroen_Sol, Makiokuta, oddRABBIT
oddRABBIT (2): pianotm, Crystal_Mint, Yellow
Yellow Magic (2): Gourd_Clae, Crystal_Mint
Isrieri (1): :Isrieri

Ah, thanks. I missed that. Still, it's YM we're talking about. Not the most trustworthy one.

But, it does all add up if Isrieri somehow managed to vote for themself.

Which makes YM rather suspicious for going along with the vote for oddRABBIT along with piano.

It's usually whenever they feel like talking.

In other news, I'm incredibly disturbed by crystal's point because it's very unlikely that mafia would forget who they killed.

It was just a fluke, right...? If YM and I are just two townies accusing each other than this town is being played by mafia...