[FINISHED] KLOE THE MURDERER MAFIA

I will begin looking around in the town hall. If this is a larger place, another map would help a lot.

author=NeverSilent

author=Crystal-Mint
Oh ok, I see! Sorry if that comes across as scummy, but I'm really just a super indecisive person ;-;
Especially when there are 2 or more people who could be scum - I'm always unsure if I'm voting for the right person!

I hope this doesn't come across as me trying to divert attention away from myself, but I'm not really convinced that what you're saying here is completely true. After all, if I recall correctly, you were one of the first people to vote against Shinan last day, and you never changed your vote the whole time.

Why are people suddenly accusing me ;-;
I do find it kind of funny though; piano accused me for being indecisive and now NS is accusing me of the opposite haha

If I remember correctly, I voted for Shinan before that whole thing with piano vs LockeZ? I just didn't change my vote because even after a lot of the votes changed, most people still suspected Shinan. Honestly I did find piano suspicious, but now I'm not sure after him threatening to reveal his PM. It seems too risky for mafia, but maybe that's the entire point?

For what it's worth, CM has not seemed any more suspicious than ratty in that they both have scumtells as part of their natural behavior, and they both have been acting normally.

@Gourd, yes, but maybe it's time to start looking through the posts and reevaluating everyone's natural scumtells. We all have them. My biggest suspicion is now on LockeZ, because he's as aggressive as I am. I could be completely wrong. A lot of things factored into my not suspecting him, how much sense he made, the fact that he was scum last game (though, I'll admit, RNG can sometimes hit the same person twice in a row), the fact that he always plays like this. LockeZ is virtually unreadable because as scum and as town, his play styles are virtually identical.

As a point of fact, if LockeZ isn't scum, we stand a good chance of losing, because nobody else sending off real scum signals. We'll have to luck into a legit scum lynch. We have to get one to shake the other loose. Preferably, we have to get the scum leader, because even if we have two experienced scum, they're generally this unreadable because of how well they're coordinating. In that case, if we get one, we might be able break the other one's poker face.

Evidence:

-The first one to die was Ziggy. He was found dressed like Harold and died in the town hall.
-Crystal has been accusing people and trying to make them look suspicious a few times, like she did with ratty earlier on.
-Afterwards, we found the body of the farmer who was tied to a tree. But the tree was too high to get up to. Implying that the culprit definetly used an item to get up there.
-RabitZ was mod-killed afterwards. He was missing and arm and was strangled. (Possible connection to Shinan's suicide?). He also had toast and pink socks in his pocket, though it does get mentioned that these are useless.
-Right afterwards I died when you guys killed me. I was stabbed to death.
-The next morning the body of YM was found. He had nothing on him. His death seems to be the most mysterious with the complete lack of evidence.
-We found the real Kloe right afterwards. She was locked up in the cellar of the barn. However, the farmer's body was found in the forest and he was still dripping blood, meaning he died recently. There would be no way that the farmer wouldn't notice a girl locked up in his cellar, so he probably had something to do in all this. The farmer also had inapproperiate books under his bed, which means, could he have possibly been ''perverted'' over Kloe? And since we have a fake Kloe, maybe the farmer corpse is also fake? I feel that at this point it is a MUST to get the farmer down.
-The next to die was Shinan. He hung himself with a fake noose and then hung himself with a real noose. The noose might become useful later on.
-Fearful has been acting REALLY vague, to a point where he didn't even contribute anything to the game so far. Not sure if he's just not paying attention or trying to hide something.
-Infection Files was hung at the gallows(possible connection to crystal getting stuck in the stocks earlier? Yeah no way)

So yes, please get the Farmer's body down as soon as possible. Chou, guys.

Also, the meta reasoning doesn't seem useful here. Kloe wouldn't make it THAT obvious, would she? Still, I have other reasons for suspecting LockeZ. There's more than enough reason to lynch him without going meta.

At this point, I'm really reluctant to make a move because if LockeZ ISN'T scum, then whoever is scum is going to be really frickin' hard to get a bead on. And if LockeZ isn't scum, we'd be getting rid of a player who's really good at scum-hunting. I'm sitting here hoping someone slips up, and really, nobody has. So, I'm going through previous posts hoping to find any contradictions.

author=pianotm

Ratty524
Also @pianotm: Keep in mind that Crystal-Mint has participated in an RP mafia outside of this forum. She's not THAT inexperienced.

Didn't she say she had only participated in one, though? That was the werewolf one that Libby hosted on another site. She wasn't in Spy vs. Mafia. So this is the third one, ostensibly that she's been in, unless she was in others off site. I mean, she could have been in others we don't know about.

Yep, this is only my second RP Mafia!

author=pianotm

Ratty524

pianotm
Also, the meta reasoning doesn't seem useful here. Kloe wouldn't make it THAT obvious, would she?

This is the same person who kind of outed Shinan and Neversilent in a way, but again, I actually hope I'm wrong because it would demonstrate a MAJOR flaw with how this game is constructed, on top of the ones it already has.

Ratty, Shinan didn't flip scum. That also means we can't use the meta to accuse NeverSilent. There's the clue that NS' hair was found on IF, but that seems like a really obvious misdirection.

Valid point. I'll rest my case then.

Still, though, why would Frogge recommend lynching LockeZ among others if he wasn't scum? Again, there is a possibility, by the virtue of being in dead chat, that he does know who is playing mafia in this game, unless Kloe is being wise enough to make sure that secret is never made widespread.

Oh thank god frogge i'm glad your immortal somehow!!!

okay so

I killed Kloe!!!! I feel bad for her but we must be honest. Or I was told Harold is dead. So. Harold is dead, and I had to tell her. anyways

I being looking around town hall. Frogge says there's things to be found and I am looking for them.