DANGANRONPA 3 FORBIDDEN ACTION MAFIA! [GAME OVER]

author=pianotm
Also, you can call my FA scummy, Liberty, but at least I even have an FA. Which is more scummy: an FA that makes me argue against lynches, or being the only player without an active FA?

The one which argues against lynches, actually.

I'm more likely not to be mafia of the both of us because if I was, do you think for a second, with how "awesome and amazing" a player I am (citation needed), that I would put forward a FA that would make me so suspicious to everyone? The answer is no. The fact that you brought that up, though, pretty much makes me feel good about leaving my lynch vote on you until a better one comes along.

So, we know YM isn't mafia. I know I'm not mafia. That's 2 of 3 in my book, meaning piano, nessy or oddly are mafia.



If we look at Nessy's list, with she and YM having been dead, then there's either a game over OR only one mafia left alive. I'm betting game over since this was a big game, having three mafia would be more likely, though we can't discount there only being one mafia left.

Meaning that piano and oddly must be mafia in that scenario (thus killing off myself and Hikitsune). Of course, there's the chance that Nessy is lying through her teeth and deliberately didn't let YM get killed just so she could use this argument to cement her position as town as 'safe', because if she were mafia it would not have benefited her to have YM killed off, thus the game would have still been elongated an extra day without mafia win since there'd only be one mafia to three town. Better numbers for mafia are five to three, since it would further elongate their chance of winning since there are more bodies to hit a false lynch with, and they can still get another chance if they lose one member.

That is, 1/3 on one day vs 2/5 and 1/3 for the next day - more chance for them to win.


So I'm pretty sure Nessy is mafia. I'm pretty sure piano is mafia.

Liberty, your post hurt my brain.

So, having to defend myself from lynches is scummy? Seriously, do you read the stuff you write? Everyone defends themselves from lynches. Even claiming that you're okay with being lynched is a method of defending yourself from lynches. Because I can't defend myself the way I usually choose to, I'm scummy because of that. Of all of your arguments against me, this is the worst one. Meanwhile, you still don't have a working FA that we know of.

Of course, being the only player without an FA is, as YM said, ridiculously hard to believe. A) You're lying about your FA, which would, as far as I can tell, make you the only one, or B) you never expected the lack of an FA to come back to bite you; after all, you told us at the beginning of the game. I think these two are the most likely scenarios.

author=pianotm
Of course, being the only player without an FA is, as YM said, ridiculously hard to believe. A) You're lying about your FA, which would, as far as I can tell, make you the only one, or B) you never expected the lack of an FA to come back to bite you; after all, you told us at the beginning of the game. I think these two are the most likely scenarios.

Or C) I'm telling the truth and Frogge gave me a silly, personality-based FA without considering how scummy it would make me look.

If you wanna pass the test, the answer is C, btw.


I had forgotten that there were Indies in the game, but Cave was one wasn't he? If there is another Indie in the game, that would mean there could only be one mafia left, since if there were two mafia/one indie/two town then mafia would have won already.

So we're dealing with either:
- 1 indie/1 mafia/3 town
- 2 mafia/3 town
- 1 mafia/4 town

I'm leaning more towards the first two options instead of the last one, due to the numbers we started the game with. 3 mafia vs 10 town/1 indie or 9 town/2 indie sounds like a fair match up.

One thing I don't understand is why there were any indies involved in the game at all. It would make sense in a game that had powers, but it doesn't really make sense in an almost-vanilla game.

Then it would seem we are in agreement that Nessy/Piano is the most likely combination for scum (of course, you'd think I would also count, which is understandable).

I'm fine with moving my vote to Nessy and then going after piano tomorrow. What do you think of that idea, piano? Oddly? Do you think that considering YM still being alive, Nessy is a likely candidate for being scum?

If you're mafia (and it seems more likely to be that you are than not, considering it would have benefitted mafia to kill YM last night to also get rid of you if you were really town, thus plummeting our numbers more and making winning more likely) then killing you skews the numbers in towns favour instead.

That is, if last night they killed off YM then that would have killed off you as well (if you were both town, this means that it would be 2 mafia vs 2 town, leaving them to have won). The only reason not to have killed off YM would be to keep you alive, and that only benefits mafia if you are also mafia - so that they wouldn't be 1 vs 2).

So last night it was 6 (2 mafia/4 town). Killing off YM would have netted the win if your FA is true and you are town (leaving 2 mafia/2 town = mafia win). If, however, you are mafia then that would have left the numbers like so = 1 mafia/3 town.

author=Archeia_Nessiah
Well I know for a fact I'm town. And again let's look at it this way.
Assuming after night kill and YM got killed. Then the list goes like this:

- Odd
- Libby
- Piano

If indeed the Libby/Piano, Odd/Piano, Odd/Libby is one of the scum combos then town would go down instantly. I do not see how lynching against me would win here.

And again, if I really was scum, why would I reveal this FA? This makes me extremely suspicious if I were mafia and let YM live. I have to say bravo to mafia team though since they really got me into this position :P

If they'd killed you off last night they would have won already. The only reason not to is if you are mafia as that would have taken out the 'winning number' for them.

If you are not mafia, they would have already won the game. If you are mafia they couldn't kill YM off and won today - it buys town more time to play and find mafia.

If we hit wrong today then yes, mafia will win. If we hit right, we've bought ourselves another day to try and hit the nail.

Yeah libby, your behavior is very town and it's hard to think of you as not the mafia. But I would be lying if I said you're not the one person I suspected the most if anything, because you have the most freedom out of everyone and you're sadistic enough to plan this.

I would say though if I was Mafia, I would've killed you first. Not Hikitsune because he's speaking in haiku. Town could've killed him just on purely haiku hahahah.