DANGANRONPA 3 FORBIDDEN ACTION MAFIA! [GAME OVER]

Posts

Frogge
I wanna marry ALL the boys!! And Donna is a meanc
18995
Around 20 hours 45 minutes remain
Oh, another easy way to find vote tags - search through a person's posts on their profile page for #lynch. It's a bit faster, unless they're like Oddly and haven't voted in the whole game.

>.>

Maybe you should have given him the "Must vote on x day" FA.
Okay, can sleep then. Woo~

I'll be back later!
author=Liberty
How much time do we have left, btw?

Also, it's majority rules vote, right? It says there's hammering. In this case, then, 3 votes would mean a hammer, correct?

If there were two mafia, would they not have already voted hammer on piano and Nessy, were they not mafia? A thought to consider. Why are the two of them still alive? The only reason would be that either both are mafia, or there's only one mafia left.

Considering the numbers of the game, I'm leaning towards both being mafia.



author=Liberty
To clarify (I do this a lot because I like to dumb things down since I know I can be a bit obscure in my reasonings):

If piano was town and there were two mafia, he'd already have been hammer voted dead.
If Nessy was town and there were two mafia, she'd already be hammer voted dead.

This means either there's not enough numbers for mafia to do a hammer vote (only one), OR that both of them are mafia (because they would vote on the one who wasn't, hammer voting and thus securing the win for their team).




author=Liberty
Of course, this is supposing I'm not misreading the rules where it says hammer votes are a thing.



Just quoting these for the new page.
Yellow Magic
Could I BE any more Chandler Bing from Friends (TM)?
3229
You wouldn't have had to quote those for a new page if you had just done the right thing and placed a vote on Nessy.

By the way I disagree with all gajillion of your posts
I still want to hear from Oddly and don't want to chance that a hammer occurs beforehand.


Also, why am I still awake? >.<;

GO TO SLEEP LIBERTY
oddRABBIT
I feel bored. How odd.
1979
Once again, if everyone agrees, I can commit suicide to narrow down the options.

I'm still suspicious of Archeia_Nessiah, though, for the previously mentioned FA.
Yellow Magic
Could I BE any more Chandler Bing from Friends (TM)?
3229
If you're suspicious of Nessy, why don't you vote for her?

Fun-fact: I disagree with Liberty's latest post
pianotm
The TM is for Totally Magical.
32388
If you're suspicious of Nessy, why don't you vote for her?


I was just thinking that. Right now, YM, you're the only vote on Libby.

Libby, I'll vote Nessy if you do.
No... it feels weird, like a trap. Perhaps the scum team is piano/odd and they're waiting for a vote to appear on someone else to hammer. Then again, if that's the case, I am surprised that there hasn't already been a hammer on me.

Piano: 1(Libert)
Libert: 1(Piano)
Archy: 1(YM)

I know I and YM aren't scum. If there isn't a hammer vote on me already, with an assumed 2-person mafia, that means that Piano must be scum (or that there's only one mafia left - a bit unlikely).

Yeah... I'm 100% sure of that. Which means that Oddly isn't likely to be mafia else they'd have already hammered Nessy - leaving us with Nessy/Piano. Urgh, it's right, logically, but piano's last post feels so fucking trap-worthy. I don't trust at all.

Piano, put your money where your mouth is - put your vote on Nessy. If I am mafia then I'd have to be paired with Nessy or Oddly, by your reasoning, and there's nothing we could do by ourselves numberwise. I want to see you change your vote first.
pianotm
The TM is for Totally Magical.
32388
Okay.

#Lynch Archeia_Nessiah
pianotm
The TM is for Totally Magical.
32388
#cancel
#Lynch Archeia_Nessiah


I keep forgetting to cancel...
author=pianotm
If you're suspicious of Nessy, why don't you vote for her?


I was just thinking that. Right now, YM, you're the only vote on Libby.

Libby, I'll vote Nessy if you do.
What? No, that's you Piano. And that's why there's this stalemate and high suspicion on you. Because you're vote is already used up, if nessy wasn't mafia, you and oddly would have already hammered her ass. But Nessy must be mafia, as must you (assuming two mafia left) else she'd be dead already. The moment someone changes their vote to someone other than her, they're dead.


Uh to make that a bit easier to understand:
The fact that I haven't been hammered means that either piano/another are mafia and he's already got his vote on me, making the numbers impossible for a hammer (3 required).

If I were mafia, and Nessy wasn't my partner, then I'd have pushed to hammer her. If she was, I'd have still pushed to hammer her since her FA is sus as fuck as to why she's still alive and sacrifice play is something I do at times like this as mafia, but even if I wasn't, I'd be aiming for oddly under the pretense of not being useful to town due to him not actually contributing anything to the game. (No offence Oddly, but I'm not even sure why you sign up for the game if you're not gonna play it?)


If there are a two-person mafia left, both members either have to have voted to lynch someone already or be someone that is being voted on - or else there would have been a hammer vote already. Three have voted, three are voted on.

YM is safe. Sure, his vote could be bad, but he's safe. The fact that his vote is on someone who could be hammered if they were town means that it's likely she's not.

Piano's vote is on me. This causes a stalemate - currently his vote is wasted but I get the feeling it's just sitting there until someone else gets voted on, and it will then suddenly jump to that someone else, along with his partners' vote.

Oddly has not voted this entire game. Geez dude.

Nessy has no vote as yet but she's not sufficient numbers to vote anyone. There's more than a few reasons as to why she's suspicious and likely to be mafia.

I think that if Nessy isn't mafia, then piano must be.

Fine, I'm only arguing more for the case of Nessy being mafia based on her FA and the likelihood of it being higher than others.

#cancel
#lynch Archeia_Nessiah


For the record, if I die tonight, lynch anyone but YM, but I've got a bad feeling that YM will be the one dying tonight, if we've lynched correctly.
pianotm
The TM is for Totally Magical.
32388
It was an honest typo, Libby, and if Nessy isn't mafia, then you are. Just wanted to make my position clear.
Again though, I don't mind being lynched if it's for the Town's greater good but.
Actually how can we be really sure that Libby and Piano are town when they are also using the same excuse as 'I'm know for sure I'm town.' thrown around.

They even admit that this feels as a trap.

If there really are two mafias (which I feel like there isn't because otherwise, why wouldn't they have killed YM first and killed two towns in a row?)
pianotm
The TM is for Totally Magical.
32388
It's called a standoff, Nessy, and Libby isn't giving an inch. As a matter of fact, Nessy, if we can't lynch scum, you are the best choice to lynch because it prevents a double hit. We'll have one more day.
author=Archeia_Nessiah
Again though, I don't mind being lynched if it's for the Town's greater good but.
Actually how can we be really sure that Libby and Piano are town when they are also using the same excuse as 'I'm know for sure I'm town.' thrown around.

They even admit that this feels as a trap.

If there really are two mafias (which I feel like there isn't because otherwise, why wouldn't they have killed YM first and killed two towns in a row?)


This is the whole argument against you - that if there are two mafia you and YM should already be dead if YOU aren't mafia, meaning there's three cases:
- You are mafia and your partner decided to give a bigger chance of winning by not killing you off (two mafia vs three town)
- You aren't mafia because there's only one mafia.
- There's two mafia and they're both inexperienced (not likely with these last players) and missed the play that could have cemented them the game already.
author=pianotm
It was an honest typo, Libby, and if Nessy isn't mafia, then you are. Just wanted to make my position clear.

No you.
;p
pianotm
The TM is for Totally Magical.
32388