Full Games List
Featured Games
New Games
Reviews
Media
Images
Blogs
Game Updates
Images Feedback Summary
Game Design Highlights
Tutorials
Articles
Scripts
Utilities / Plugins
Resources
Engines
Engine Bulletins
What is Makerscore?
Past Events
Achievements
Misaos
Forums
Post History
Chat
New to RMN?
Full Store List
RMN Music Pack (free)
EDCHUY'S PROGRESS IN GIVING FEEBACK/REVIEWS OF ALL RS X RELEASES
Posts
edchuy
View playlists
Closepost=129667
My RS release was just a set of screenshots where we showed off a bunch of unseen stuff by the public. If you wanted to give us feedback I would best appreciate it through a comment on the blog! And it shouldn't take long to do that really. Thanks.
Yes, I am aware of them and since you posted it there, that's exactly where I intended to provide feedback. Except I am still dealing with released games, so I'll get to you eventually.
I have just submitted my review for Tears of the Sword. I have pending providing feedback for Coy13's Xelos: Sinner's Circle.
During this weekend I also:
- finished playing Dudesoft's Take Down and Pig of Benevolence demos (http://rpgmaker.net/games/1950/ ) -> will provide feedback on both of them
- finished playing SorceressKyrsty's Cosplay Crisis Demo 2.2 (http://rpgmaker.net/games/1741/ ) -> will provide feedback
- finished playing EnderX's Pizza Panic (http://rpgmaker.net/games/1930/ ) -> will provide feedback
- played both versions of Ratty524's Slimy the Sahagin (http://rpgmaker.net/games/1947/ ) -> I need to ask a question for each to find out if I have done as much as I can, once I am sure or finish playing I will provide some feedback for each
Given my progress, I'll give Liberty a little more time to address my questions regarding her demo before I do anything more about it.
During this weekend I also:
- finished playing Dudesoft's Take Down and Pig of Benevolence demos (http://rpgmaker.net/games/1950/ ) -> will provide feedback on both of them
- finished playing SorceressKyrsty's Cosplay Crisis Demo 2.2 (http://rpgmaker.net/games/1741/ ) -> will provide feedback
- finished playing EnderX's Pizza Panic (http://rpgmaker.net/games/1930/ ) -> will provide feedback
- played both versions of Ratty524's Slimy the Sahagin (http://rpgmaker.net/games/1947/ ) -> I need to ask a question for each to find out if I have done as much as I can, once I am sure or finish playing I will provide some feedback for each
Given my progress, I'll give Liberty a little more time to address my questions regarding her demo before I do anything more about it.
This is pretty wicked that you are doing this. I haven't been following all the gameprofiles, but have you been adding these comments to their comments section/blog? Also, halibabica wrote an article called Release Something! Day Roundup. I bet you could whip something like this up when you are finished.
Great work!
Great work!
post=129833
This is pretty wicked that you are doing this. I haven't been following all the gameprofiles, but have you been adding these comments to their comments section/blog? Also, halibabica wrote an article called Release Something! Day Roundup. I bet you could whip something like this up when you are finished.
Great work!
I have posted some things in their comments section.
- In Max McGee's case, I posted my feedback in his comments section for Starseed: Blood Machine demo. I didn't do the same Starseed: Eschatology demo because I felt it is an informative introduction to the game that I can I say at most is interesting, if nothing else.
- For Liberty's Even Day, I have posted several things since I ran into some missing files that were preventing me from advancing. With some other RMN user's help, I got most of what I need to continue playing. Now that I did, I bumped into another game-breaking issue, which I also posted there. I have posted the eventual feedback there yet, since I don't quite want to give anything away yet if there is hope to resolving the issue.
- For sbester's Mobile Suit Gundam RPG , I posted a question regarding whether I had reached the end of the demo, since it wasn't clear noted in the game. Since I had done this and gotten confirmation, I went ahead and let him know when I submitted my review.
- For Ratty524's Slimy the Sahagin demos, I posted a couple of question because for the original, it might have a game-breaking bug, while for the alpha of the remake, I wasn't sure whether in one of trial sections I had tried I could have.
My plan has been all along to submit feedback for the others in the blog if the release was announced there. Otherwise, it is likely to have announced in the comments section, so my feedback would go there. If I decide to write another review, I might announce it in the comments section if I had to get in touch with whoever released. As an alternative, I will post the review and once I see it get approved, I will send him/her a PM.
Regarding doing a wrap-up at the end similar to halibabica's, I guess I could do that. Makes me realize what I'm doing is a little less crazy than what he did just a year ago. Ranking my recommendations and justifying them ought to be very interesting ... By the way, could you forward me the thread for RS 6, I wanted to check something out (I checked the forum and couldn't find it!).
I think that RS6 and previous ones are lost to the now-defunct Game Releases forum. That forum was for people to post their games and discuss them there but that forum was removed back when WIP implemented game profiles.
So, unless you are an admin you can't see it!
So, unless you are an admin you can't see it!
post=129879
I think that RS6 and previous ones are lost to the now-defunct Game Releases forum. That forum was for people to post their games and discuss them there but that forum was removed back when WIP implemented game profiles.
So, unless you are an admin you can't see it!
That's OK, then. Thanks for letting me know.
The Tears of the Sword review is finally accepted. I didn't even get a chance to PM SquishyWizard.
Regarding yesterday's progress, I decided to replay Xelos: Sinner's Circle demo to be able to take note as I went along and try some of the features that the game has that I hadn't tried in my first playthrough. I expect to be posting my feedback in Coy13's blog. Thankfully he did two posts so I can separate my feedback: one for everything battle-related, one for everything else. I expect both feedback post to be long and detailed. Since the won't be reviews, I'll post a "WARNING: CONTAINS SPOILERS!" disclaimer for each.
Also, Ratty524 answered my questions. For his Slimy: The Sahagin remake, he confirmed I did all I could, while for his original he let me know what I need to do to continue. Thus, I was able to continue playing and finished playing the game. There was another tough spot where I seemingly got stuck, but the answer to my question helped me figure out to try something not so obvious to be able to continue. For the remake, I will provide feedback and for the complete game, I decide, instead, to give it a review.
Once done giving Tears of the Sword feedback, I will give Dudesoft's Take Down and Pig of Benevolence demos theirs. I expect doing this shouldn't take me that long and hope to do it by today.
Regarding yesterday's progress, I decided to replay Xelos: Sinner's Circle demo to be able to take note as I went along and try some of the features that the game has that I hadn't tried in my first playthrough. I expect to be posting my feedback in Coy13's blog. Thankfully he did two posts so I can separate my feedback: one for everything battle-related, one for everything else. I expect both feedback post to be long and detailed. Since the won't be reviews, I'll post a "WARNING: CONTAINS SPOILERS!" disclaimer for each.
Also, Ratty524 answered my questions. For his Slimy: The Sahagin remake, he confirmed I did all I could, while for his original he let me know what I need to do to continue. Thus, I was able to continue playing and finished playing the game. There was another tough spot where I seemingly got stuck, but the answer to my question helped me figure out to try something not so obvious to be able to continue. For the remake, I will provide feedback and for the complete game, I decide, instead, to give it a review.
Once done giving Tears of the Sword feedback, I will give Dudesoft's Take Down and Pig of Benevolence demos theirs. I expect doing this shouldn't take me that long and hope to do it by today.
Just posted the feedback for Take Down and Pig of Benevolence demos in Dudesoft's discussion section of this gamepage.
I did a second playthrough of SorceressKyrsty's Cosplay Crisis Demo 2.2 and should post my feedback in the corresponding blog tomorrow.
I did a second playthrough of SorceressKyrsty's Cosplay Crisis Demo 2.2 and should post my feedback in the corresponding blog tomorrow.
Just posted the feedback for Cosplay Crisis Demo 2.2 in SorceressKyrsty's corresponding blog.
I hope to post the feedback for the demo of the remake of Ratty524's Slimy the Sahagin later tonight.
Also, I have been playing outlander145's Suito Homu: The Second Coming (Secondary Early Techstration) . I am posting a question to make sure I did all I could in it.
I hope to post the feedback for the demo of the remake of Ratty524's Slimy the Sahagin later tonight.
Also, I have been playing outlander145's Suito Homu: The Second Coming (Secondary Early Techstration) . I am posting a question to make sure I did all I could in it.
Just posted the feedback for demo of the remake of Ratty524's Slimy the Sahagin. Also found out from outlander145 I have done all I could in his demo.
I hope to be able to submit the review for Ratty524's original version of the game later tonight.
I hope to be able to submit the review for Ratty524's original version of the game later tonight.
post=130468
Go, edchuy, go!
post=130470
You are a machine.
Yeah, as long as I don't lose my soul or mind in the process! Let's hope I can be done before Easter so at least I can take a little break from all this becoming coming back to do the wrap-up!
post=130528
review my bladder
As long as I don't have to do a manual prostate exam! (cue the fake laugh soundtrack)
I have just submitted the review for the original version of Slimy the Sahagin. I hope to post feedback for outlander145's Suito Homu: The Second Coming (Secondary Early Techstration) later today.
I just posted the feedback for outlander145's Suito Homu: The Second Coming (Secondary Early Techstration) demo in the corresponding blog. Next, I'll be playing EnderX's Pizza Panic.
Finished playing and posted feedback for Pizza Panic. Will be playing catmitts' Frog World RPG (http://rpgmaker.net/games/1940/ ) next.
