THEODUTCH'S PROFILE

I like you too, Isrieri. The reason why im not so active is because im busy with study, but I try to find my team to come back here :)

So MajoracanKing died because of us... If Cave_Dog and JJJ7 are townies (as Cave said) then Wes is the only one who could try to kill townies. Still I dont think that is the cases. Wildwes vote for MajoracanKing at the last moment as a "There aren't exactly any other viable options"-choice. He could acted that as mafia, but i doubt that.

I think we should look at the more silent-but-acting-strange people. For example Yellow Magic, Seiromen, Takyon and maybe Isreiri. Again Wildwes could be mafia, but we should not lose the quite people out of sight. And yeah, please look at me too. Not really active people could really be mafia. So lets not only watch the actives.

Sorry, i've been busy... I read every post tho. Firstly i want to cancel my vote against JJJ7. I was really convinced he was mafia, but Caves claim confinced me of the opposite. If Cave_Dog is not telling the truth, then respect! But I think he is indeed telling the truth.

#Cancel

I think most of us can agree that JJJ7 is (from what we know now) probably a townie. Isriri thinks lynching JJJ7 is still a good idea, as that would give us more info. I don't agree on that, as JJJ7 is probably a villager. I have not many clues.. I have people I trust more, and people I distrust.. But not enough to vote.

NoLynch

Hey all,

I’m new to the online version of this game, but i have played the card game many times :)
Let me let you all know what I think of all the players. Disclaimer: My english is probably bad, but I hope it’s still readable. Second Disclaimer: I probably don’t get your genders right (I’ll probably refer to everyone as he/him), maybe I’ll learn it in time :)

JJJ7: He immediately votes for NoLynch which is a bit strange. After that he claim two times that he is a villager. He also begs not to be lynched, which seems pretty desperate. Then he says ‘dont dare to lynch me, Wes’ while Wildwes didn’t want to. Lastly JJJ7 claims that Seiromen is the mafia without a reason. I don’t want to jump to conclusions too fast, but I find JJJ7 acting a bit strange.

author=JJJ7
But know I'm a townie so don't lynch me pls. :(

Liberty: Liberty also votes for NoLynch. In contrast to JJJ7, Liberty explains hes(/her?) choice really well. Liberty explains that lynching day 1 is not a good choice. I understand his arguments and I have nothing against him.

author=Liberty
Frankly I don't want to gamble with innocent lives. I, for one, don't believe that the loss of one life in exchange for information that would most likely be of no use to us is worth the cost.

Seiromen: He hasn’t said much. You could argue that being silent is suspicious, but I would say that this early.

Wildwes: Wildwes distrusts JJJ7 a bit (if I read correctly), which I understand as I do too. He has some good points against JJJ7.

author=wildwes
Oh and yeah, JJJ7, voting nolynch after being told it isn't a good idea AND saying yourself how it worked well last time when you were mafia is... strange. Very strange.

Takyon: Said nothing, again not yet suspicious.

Bart_Sol: Haven’t said much (only a reaction). Nothing to say ‘bout.

MajoracanKing: He has said a few things, but as far as I know not really relevant stuff. Can’t say a lot ‘bout that.

CAVE_DOG_IS_BACk: CAVE_DOG says he wants to murder Yellow Magic, which seems logical as Yellow Magic voted for him. Also CAVE_DOG gives a reason why you should not Lynch D1, which is a slightly more mafia thing, if you ask me. This is just something I noticed, but nothing to worry about.

author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
someone will never be scummy enough for you to lynch d1, liberty. you are simply too pure of heart, and also, a monster that i must destroy.

Isrieri: He claims to be a towny. He doesn’t trust JJJ7 and he has some good points against him. He also explains why day 1 NoVote isn’t good.

author=Isrieri
Okay, you admit that NoLynching was bad for town, last time.
So I ask again: What's with the NoLynch right now? If you know that, why opt for it when you're town this game?

author=Isrieri
Its that he posted for a NoLynch immediately - right out the gate. There's no town benefit from doing that as far as I'm aware. And if he remembers how we were going to crack down on silent players last game, he would logically try to make himself heard but not want to call immediate attention on himself. Its just a really fishy move on his part.

Gourd_Clae: He doesn’t trust Wildwes and he says JJJ7 is only reactionary. In hes next post he comes back on the last point and says that being reactionary isn’t a town thing. I find not trusting Wildwes a bit suspicious, as I don’t see any reason for it. The JJJ7 part is a little bit suspicious to me, as he seems to defend him. I really don’t know, but I is something we could keep in mind.

author=Gourd_Clae
Wes is being extremely jumpy. For, uh, no reason. Also he seemed to agree with the idea of a no lynch then berated someone for also thinking it's a good idea. Of course, it's a far cry from screaming he's an evil scumlord. I have my eyes on you, Wes.

Yellow Magic: He is the first one to vote for a Lynch. He votes for CAVE_DOG without a good reason (or its something personal, which I don’t know). He also defends JJJ7 with saying a mafia wouldn’t be so careless. I don’t think this is a really strong argument, but again no conclusions. The voting on CAVE_DOG is suspicious tho.

author=Yellow Magic
re: JJJ7: I hate to admit it, but I really doubt a Mafia member would be so careless with his posts as he's been up to now.

I join! :D