MAFIA: HIGURASHI NO NAKU KORO NI (GAME)
Posts
ivory, this is what Liberty said:
This leads me to believe that Despite and Liberty (now bennyguy) are linked somehow.
Fine, I was trying to protect myself (nice one, Despite. You had to bring up my special power didn't you? Now the mafia are gonna be gunning for me even more. Thanks for that.)
This leads me to believe that Despite and Liberty (now bennyguy) are linked somehow.
author=Gourd_Clae
Cave probably isn't mafia, but I am so calling Yellow Magic is.
Can you not see what you're doing?
"Hmm, I'm going to show everyone how innocent I am by gently asking players what they think of me." This is pretty transparent to me, dude.
Your baseless claim right now just adds to the argument.
I'm fairly positive itrombe was mafia, to flip flop on names and then cause an error- yeah let's just write him off as a mafia death for now.
Also what did liberty exactly say about me "running my mouth"? (sorry, fuck reading 17 pages)
Also what did liberty exactly say about me "running my mouth"? (sorry, fuck reading 17 pages)
@Despite:
author=Despite
Fine, I was trying to protect myself (nice one, Despite. You had to bring up my special power didn't you? Now the mafia are gonna be gunning for me even more. Thanks for that.)
How is it baseless? And how does yours even have a base? I'm not sure I fully understand your guys's reasoning because, as far as I can tell, you guys are lynching me for telling you guys what I was thinking with even a shred of confidence and then asking you guys to talk to me so I can prove to you I'm not mafia. And to make it worse you aren't even giving me a chance. When I die (which I don't suspect to be today as there are only a limited amount of mafia) I suggest town go directly for you as you are not playing with the conservation of town in mid, something I'd only expect mafia to do.
Despite, this one-->
"Fine, I was trying to protect myself (nice one, Despite. You had to bring up my special power didn't you? Now the mafia are gonna be gunning for me even more. Thanks for that.)"
If itrombe IS mafia, so there's probably 1 more left?
"Fine, I was trying to protect myself (nice one, Despite. You had to bring up my special power didn't you? Now the mafia are gonna be gunning for me even more. Thanks for that.)"
If itrombe IS mafia, so there's probably 1 more left?
Oh so that's what she said.
First off I know my partners power, but I don't know who it is. So for liberty to blurt out that I "ruined her power and her identity" is absolute nonsense and frankly, IF SHE TRULY KNEW WHAT POWER I GIVE HER THEN SHE SHOULD BE RECLINING IN A CHAIR AND KEEP HER MOUTH SHUT ABOUT IT.
I'm pretty damn positive liberty is mafia.
#lynch Liberty
First off I know my partners power, but I don't know who it is. So for liberty to blurt out that I "ruined her power and her identity" is absolute nonsense and frankly, IF SHE TRULY KNEW WHAT POWER I GIVE HER THEN SHE SHOULD BE RECLINING IN A CHAIR AND KEEP HER MOUTH SHUT ABOUT IT.
I'm pretty damn positive liberty is mafia.
#lynch Liberty
She admitted her power because, welp, I voted for her on 1st page, annnd cave's endless interrogation (ocelot much?) forced her to admit it.
@Despite: thatbennyguy is the replacement of Liberty, I will count your lynch vote as Lynch thatbennyguy so don't worry in changing your votes, but just to let you know.
author=Gourd_Clae
How is it baseless? And how does yours even have a base?
I've suggested why I think you might be Mafia. Have you suggested why you think I might be Mafia?
I'm not sure I fully understand your guys's reasoning because, as far as I can tell, you guys are lynching me for telling you guys what I was thinking with even a shred of confidence and then asking you guys to talk to me so I can prove to you I'm not mafia.
No, that's not the only reason. And I'll reiterate; you're just asking what we think without defending yourself.
And to make it worse you aren't even giving me a chance.
Uhh, no I'm not? You always have the right to speak your mind. There's hardly an overwhelming majority against you such that you'll die any minute.
When I die (which I don't suspect to be today as there are only a limited amount of mafia) I suggest town go directly for you as you are not playing with the conservation of town in mid, something I'd only expect mafia to do.
Both Cave and I, or just me?
author=Gourd_Clae
This is exactly why I asked that. Because I'm not avoiding the "issue", which doesn't even seem to exist.
I think the issue basically boils down to "what did you know, and when did you know it". You say you mistook a post that Joren_Sol made in the Mafia Host thread. I'm still trying to figure out how much belief I have in this line.
author=Liberty
...sigh,
Fine, I was trying to protect myself (nice one, Despite. You had to bring up my special power didn't you? Now the mafia are gonna be gunning for me even more. Thanks for that.)
I'm townie with the ability to kill one person of my choosing at night. First night, 100% hit. Second night, 50% hit, with a chance to kill someone by accident instead.
There it is. That is what I was looking for.
Why claim independent when you could've tried to see if I really was your partner? It's actually fairly easy. If you tell me the third letter in my ingame character name and the third letter of your ingame character name we could've gotten this show on the road.
There is still a slight chance that liberty really is townie and needs another townie to pull off her powers (like in my case) but my partner she is 100% MOST DEFINITELY NOT.
I'm gonna keep my lynch vote though, this is the most suspicious defense out of all so far.
My crackpot theory--->
People who are linked to each other:
Me --->Shion
Itrombe --->??? (might belong below)
Probably linked to each other:
Despite --->Lib/thatbennyguy
I'm not sure how that's gonna get us anywhere and it's still a bit blurry, but hopefully when the remaining lurkers posts the puzzle with become a bit clearer.
People who are linked to each other:
Me --->Shion
Itrombe --->??? (might belong below)
Probably linked to each other:
Despite --->Lib/thatbennyguy
I'm not sure how that's gonna get us anywhere and it's still a bit blurry, but hopefully when the remaining lurkers posts the puzzle with become a bit clearer.
@Ym In what world is the below not defending myself.
I didn't outright say it, but I think you're mafia because you're lynching me for no substantial reason and won't listen to it. Reason that is.
Being able to speak my mind doesn't automatically give me a chance to defend myself. If you're really set on lynching me for no reason you're obviously not going to listen to me even if I can speak.
Oh, and if you know why I'm saying all this (to prove I'm not mafia by debunking your reasons) and outright said that wasn't the only reason why aren't you telling me the other reasons?
author=Gourd_Clae
Um, what? People have talked about these sort of mason brothers multiple times. I was proabably thinking of Jereo_Sol and made a mistake. It was VERY likely that the other brother was mafia because there was no reason for someone town to be able to talk to someone else and just have absolyutely no idea who they are.
Yellow Magic even seems to agree: There is no reason for a townie to hide their identity.
I didn't outright say it, but I think you're mafia because you're lynching me for no substantial reason and won't listen to it. Reason that is.
Being able to speak my mind doesn't automatically give me a chance to defend myself. If you're really set on lynching me for no reason you're obviously not going to listen to me even if I can speak.
Oh, and if you know why I'm saying all this (to prove I'm not mafia by debunking your reasons) and outright said that wasn't the only reason why aren't you telling me the other reasons?
Despite-
...and the rest you can re-read on from page 2.
Yeah, it was only 1 vote from me and I have no idea why she overreacted and claimed indi.
author=ivoryjones
To my twin: We're not allowed to reveal ourselves in you-know-where. If you want to confirm each other's identity, please do it here.
Also,
#Lynch Liberty
author=Liberty
Ouch, why you going for me, ivory? I'm actually not a threat to anyone since I have no powers and am a friendly - (though not an actual townie, I am on their side... I just suck at it. le sigh). :(
I got the short end of the stick.
author=ivoryjones
Are you insinuating that you're an independent?
...and the rest you can re-read on from page 2.
Yeah, it was only 1 vote from me and I have no idea why she overreacted and claimed indi.
Ok I have no idea why the "" didn't show up.
Me (town) ---> Shion (mafia)
Itrombe (??) ---> ??? (??)
Despite (town?) ---> thatbennyguy (town?)
Despite said he's not connected to TBG but Lib said she is so there's a chance 1 of them is lying.
Me (town) ---> Shion (mafia)
Itrombe (??) ---> ??? (??)
Despite (town?) ---> thatbennyguy (town?)
Despite said he's not connected to TBG but Lib said she is so there's a chance 1 of them is lying.
author=Gourd_Clae
@Ym In what world is the below not defending myself.author=Gourd_Clae
Um, what? People have talked about these sort of mason brothers multiple times. I was proabably thinking of Jereo_Sol and made a mistake. It was VERY likely that the other brother was mafia because there was no reason for someone town to be able to talk to someone else and just have absolyutely no idea who they are.
Yellow Magic even seems to agree: There is no reason for a townie to hide their identity.
I didn't outright say it, but I think you're mafia because you're lynching me for no substantial reason and won't listen to it. Reason that is.
Being able to speak my mind doesn't automatically give me a chance to defend myself. If you're really set on lynching me for no reason you're obviously not going to listen to me even if I can speak.
Oh, and if you know why I'm saying all this (to prove I'm not mafia by debunking your reasons) and outright said that wasn't the only reason why aren't you telling me the other reasons?
That's weird; you seem to think I'm lynching you because of the same reason as CAVE_DOG. Here's the post that should clear things up:
Moi
Can you not see what you're doing?
"Hmm, I'm going to show everyone how innocent I am by gently asking players what they think of me." This is pretty transparent to me, dude.
Your baseless claim right now just adds to the argument.
Unless I'm mistaken you haven't really replied to this!



















