MAFIA: HIGURASHI NO NAKU KORO NI (GAME)

Posts

CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
On sunny days, I go out walking
1142
author=Yellow Magic
author=ivoryjones
he's doing it on purpose because there's a nasty after-effect when he dies.
This is a possibility...


Doubt it. If he was a town-aligned lynchbomb, the optimal strategy would probably just be to try and stay alive until lylo. Because the less targets you have, the higher chance you have of hitting scum. If he was a mafia-aligned lynchbomb, obviously committing suicide would be a bad idea.

So here's an alternate theory: He isn't doing it on purpose (well, maybe he is now to cause confusion) and is actually mafia.
Here's another likely one: He's probably town and got sick of always being the suspicious one that he doesn't mind if we lynch him just to see town screw over ourselves.
Bingo! :)
Well, I don't want to die, but if it's inevitable, then at least I can enjoy it.
Win-win. Sort of.
WELLLL, since you ARE going to be lynched anyways, care to enlighten us about your power? ...no? :)
CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
On sunny days, I go out walking
1142
author=ivoryjones
Here's another likely one: He's probably town and got sick of always being the suspicious one that he doesn't mind if we lynch him just to see town screw over ourselves.


Or he is mafia and wants you to think this and second-guess because there are two easy fixes to the problem you suggest.

a. don't sign up for mafia games

b. don't sign up for mafia games and act incredibly suspicious.
I wasn't and am not planning to retract my vote because tbh, out of the 3 Marrend/Jeroen/MM, he was in my most suspicious list anyways next to Despite/TBG. You are right about those 2 fixes though. But if he really do turn out to be town, then joke's on us.
author=ivoryjones
WELLLL, since you ARE going to be lynched anyways, care to enlighten us about your power? ...no? :)

No. I'm against role-claiming. :)
author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
author=ivoryjones
Here's another likely one: He's probably town and got sick of always being the suspicious one that he doesn't mind if we lynch him just to see town screw over ourselves.
Or he is mafia and wants you to think this and second-guess because there are two easy fixes to the problem you suggest.

a. don't sign up for mafia games

b. don't sign up for mafia games and act incredibly suspicious.

Why should I? I'm enjoying these games.
author=MirrorMasq
author=ivoryjones
WELLLL, since you ARE going to be lynched anyways, care to enlighten us about your power? ...no? :)
No. I'm against role-claiming. :)


Not even if I give you my whole Bieber CD set?

Jokes aside, it does seem incredibly stupid for him to act so scummy FROM THE START. As if intentional, actually. I'm not sure if this is actually a change of plan since chana was sick or something else.
CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
On sunny days, I go out walking
1142
I don't think he was acting really scummy from the start. He only got really terrible once pressure started to get put on him.
Well, you are Major Ocelot. *puts on shades*
Because I wasn't acting scummy. You people just see it this way thanks to Cave's false logic. TBG is acting scummy. Cave is (but he always do).
My previous actions:
1) bandwagoning against chana
2) saying that I suspect ivory and Cave
3) voting for TBG for obvious reasons
4) saying that I suspect ivory no more, but still suspect Cave
Is it so scummy in your eyes?
First off, I've voted for you first before cave did today. Second, your constant lurking and lack of posts/avoiding people's confrontation already made you in my possibly-scum list.
Yellow Magic
Could I BE any more Chandler Bing from Friends (TM)?
3229
author=MirrorMasq
1) bandwagoning against chana
2) saying that I suspect ivory and Cave
3) voting for TBG for obvious reasons
4) saying that I suspect ivory no more, but still suspect Cave

...yes. 100 times yes.
It is exactly for your 2nd action that you've jumped on my list. When I've roleclaimed, I honestly do not expect people to believe it and vice versa. People will always suspect roleclaims and it's only natural. You should already know that when playing FF2 with me. But the fact is even after rabitz put his cards on the table and you still want to lynch me is what is weird. Of course, again, you can choose to ignore him and think he's bluffing, but really? My first post already stated I'm Mion. The chance of me picking her randomly in the character lists and hit the jackpot is really little-to-none.
Marrend
Guardian of the Description Thread
21806
That's... quite a lot of posts made since last I visited this thread.

Anyway, I'm definitely more iffy on thatbennyguy. I would probably vote for him. MirrorMasq? I'm not sure what he's trying to do, but he's feeling a bit scummy to me. Gourd? I'm willing to forgive the mistake that he made with Joren_Sol's post. However, I'm seeing both Despite and Gourd claiming to have some kind of super-duper powers. I'm not sure, exactly, what's that indicative of, assuming it's indicative of anything.

For the moment, I'm slightly more confident with voting to #lynch thatbennyguy. Everything that guy says just confuses the issue of what he is.
Jeroen_Sol
Nothing reveals Humanity so well as the games it plays. A game of betrayal, where the most suspicious person is brutally murdered? How savage.
3885
Hey guys, back from the tour the France. Marrend, imma repeat myself: It's jeroen, not joren.:) I'm not sure about Mirror, but he seems not to be serious about the game anymore, so I guess we could lynch him... I think lynching thatbennyguy might be a good idea. He probably used his nightkill, so next will have 50% chance of hitting target, and 50% of hitting another target, so he could be dangerous. I still don't understand the town-aligned mafia thing, on top of which we already have one mafia, so we can afford losing TBG, if he's town. CAVE, how much do you know about the person who tried to kill you?

#Cancel
#lynch ThatBennyGuy
Gourd_Clae (0) - Cave_Dog, Yellow Magic
ThatBennyGuy (5) - Despite, Gourd_Clae, mirrormasq, Cave_Dog, Marrend, Jeroen_Sol
MirrorMasq (3) - ivoryjones, Cave_Dog, thatbennyguy, Jeroen_Sol
Cavedog (0) -thatbennyguy

They day will end in 50 hours or when there is a majority
with 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch
Changing your vote to him was a suspicious move, but regardless I'd still like to know if TBG is planning to use his power or not.