MAFIA: HIGURASHI NO NAKU KORO NI (GAME)
Posts
Whoops, sorry for the massive quote.
Yeah I just got done rereading pretty much everything up to page 11.
If at the very best just to clear up confusion I suggest we lynch lib/benny.
If at the very best just to clear up confusion I suggest we lynch lib/benny.
I'm not entirely comfortable with putting my vote up so fast, and I'd still like to hear more from Marrend/Jeroen/MM.
author=ivoryjones
Despite said he's not connected to TBG but Lib said she is so there's a chance 1 of them is lying.
IMO there are three cases here:
(1) Despite's speaking the truth and thebennyguy's definitely a Mafia
(2) thebennyguy's the Townie/Indithingy and Despite's a Mafia member
(3) Both are Mafia and are trying to distance themselves from each other (..stretch but you never know)
The thing that confuses me most?
thebennyguy claiming Townie-aligned Independent. How does that even work? I can't get my head around it at all.
thebennyguy claiming Townie-aligned Independent. How does that even work? I can't get my head around it at all.
author=Yellow MagicMoi
Can you not see what you're doing?
"Hmm, I'm going to show everyone how innocent I am by gently asking players what they think of me." This is pretty transparent to me, dude.
Your baseless claim right now just adds to the argument.
Unless I'm mistaken you haven't really replied to this!
Yes, I have? I'm going to use different words here but if you just CAN'T find it in my posts after I spell it out tell me.
1) Yes, I do.
2) I said earlier I wanted to debunk all your theories as to how I could be mafia, would you rather I say:
"I"M NOT FUCKING MAFIA !!!11! NOW TELLS ME WHAT U THINK!1"
I don't get how not freaking out or being aggressive when as you pointed out, I have very few votes on me makes me look mafia.
I'm waiting for you to come up with another weak one-liner for why I'm mafia because you just keeping looking more scummy.
author=Yellow Magic
The thing that confuses me most?
thebennyguy claiming Townie-aligned Independent. How does that even work? I can't get my head around it at all.
He said he read Lib's previous posts and got confused, then said his PM just wrote "town-aligned"-something like that.
author=Gourd_Clae
Yes, I have? I'm going to use different words here but if you just CAN'T find it in my posts after I spell it out tell me.
1) Yes, I do.
2) I said earlier I wanted to debunk all your theories as to how I could be mafia, would you rather I say:
"I"M NOT FUCKING MAFIA !!!11! NOW TELLS ME WHAT U THINK!1"
I don't get how not freaking out or being aggressive when as you pointed out, I have very few votes on me makes me look mafia.
I'm waiting for you to come up with another weak one-liner for why I'm mafia because you just keeping looking more scummy.At this point I hope you're not town because I don't want you on my team< another example of how you think I'm supposed to talk to people I guess.
Right.
1. I think you're a Mafia member because your nonchalantly asking people 'what they thought' seemed like a very Mafia method of disguising oneself.
2. Your "Cave probably isn't mafia, but I am so calling Yellow Magic is." didn't help matters.
3. You are definitely appearing aggressive to me, thanks to the above and your latest post (even bordering on ad hominem attacks), so I'm not convinced that you AREN'T Mafia.
If you don't want to be lynched, you'd be best off sharing your views on who YOU might think is a Mafia member. I think that could settle things nicely.
By the above, I mean this:
"Cave probably isn't mafia, but I am so calling Yellow Magic is."
"Cave probably isn't mafia, but I am so calling Yellow Magic is."
...I am more curious to what gourd said regarding his "super secret ultra special premium package".
His aggressiveness... is a familiar one... one that is... perhaps, an INDEPENDENT?
His aggressiveness... is a familiar one... one that is... perhaps, an INDEPENDENT?
I already said I think you're mafia.
Your reasons are getting ridiculous:
1) That's because that's how townies act. This reason is completely void becaus eI act like this in all other games and if this was avery mafia way of acting, no mafia would ever act this way.
2) Right, so saying who I think is mafia...is acting mafia. Even though like you said in your second most recent post, this is the best way to settle it. You've also said that you're giving me a chance to defend myself, now that you've just showed me that there is absolutely no way for me to be innocent in your mind because the way to do it is muddled by contradictions in your mind, I seriously doubt you're giving me a chance.
3)I don't get this. Note to self: Two examples is aggressive.
Unless I'm missing something which I probably am because that 3rd point didn't even make sense.
Your reasons are getting ridiculous:
1) That's because that's how townies act. This reason is completely void becaus eI act like this in all other games and if this was avery mafia way of acting, no mafia would ever act this way.
2) Right, so saying who I think is mafia...is acting mafia. Even though like you said in your second most recent post, this is the best way to settle it. You've also said that you're giving me a chance to defend myself, now that you've just showed me that there is absolutely no way for me to be innocent in your mind because the way to do it is muddled by contradictions in your mind, I seriously doubt you're giving me a chance.
3)I don't get this. Note to self: Two examples is aggressive.
Unless I'm missing something which I probably am because that 3rd point didn't even make sense.
author=ivoryjones
...I am more curious to what gourd said regarding his "super secret ultra special premium package".
His aggressiveness... is a familiar one... one that is... perhaps, an INDEPENDENT?
Again, I'm honestly not sure where I'm coming off aggresisve.
Gourd_Clae (2) - Cave_Dog, Yellow Magic
ThatBennyGuy (1) - Despite
MirrorMasq (1) - ivoryjones
The day will end in 67 hours or when there is a majority
with 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch
ThatBennyGuy (1) - Despite
MirrorMasq (1) - ivoryjones
The day will end in 67 hours or when there is a majority
with 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch
author=Gourd_Clae
1) That's because that's how townies act. This reason is completely void becaus eI act like this in all other games and if this was avery mafia way of acting, no mafia would ever act this way.
Honestly, I don't think so at all. I can't see a Townie going "Hey <person> what do you think of me?" And I haven't exactly monitored your playing style in each and every game, so I'm not sure how you act really! Maybe I should see what other people think.
2) Right, so saying who I think is mafia...is acting mafia. Even though like you said in your second most recent post, this is the best way to settle it. You've also said that you're giving me a chance to defend myself, now that you've just showed me that there is absolutely no way for me to be innocent in your mind because the way to do it is muddled by contradictions in your mind, I seriously doubt you're giving me a chance.
From what I can tell, you think I'm a Mafia member because I am accusing you without any real reason. I've outlined my reasons. They may be dumb reasons to you but they are 'real' reasons nonetheless.
Is there no one else you can think of that may be a Mafia member at the moment?
3)I don't get this. Note to self: Two examples is aggressive.
Unless I'm missing something which I probably am because that 3rd point didn't even make sense.
Two examples out of a handful of posts? Yes, that is aggressive!
It's not just the fact that you're aggressive but that you seem to have a slight tinge of panic in your posts; the two combined seem like a very Mafia trait.
Basically, your asking peoples' opinions from you seems to have evolved into this strange aggressiveness towards me, and that's what I have a problem with.
That all said, I still want to hear from MirrorMasq and the like though, and I think I got all the reaction I could from you, so for now:
#Cancel (Because I don't want anything nasty to happen while I'm asleep)
Seems like I'm late to the party.
Also, I don't think itrombe was mafia.
Actually he could have been, if what cave says is true: the mafia tried to kill him and he had BP, and it was a vigilante who targeted itrombe.
hmmm... questions questions...
give me a moment to sort my thoughts.
Also, I don't think itrombe was mafia.
Actually he could have been, if what cave says is true: the mafia tried to kill him and he had BP, and it was a vigilante who targeted itrombe.
hmmm... questions questions...
give me a moment to sort my thoughts.
thatbenny guy is the only other suspect I can think of.
Also, I could believe exasperated or sarcastic but not aggressive.
And now I'm confused, I don't get what you're trying to suggest by those last bit of words in your post.
And I'm just going to put this out here:
You cannot read posts in the internet like you can in an actuall verbal conversation. My tone in the posts is subject to the way you think someone would say them, so something that may sound mean or panic-y in this situation could just be you reading it the wrong way. And from what I gathered from your posts, I will eat my underwear if you're not mafia.
Also, I could believe exasperated or sarcastic but not aggressive.
And now I'm confused, I don't get what you're trying to suggest by those last bit of words in your post.
And I'm just going to put this out here:
You cannot read posts in the internet like you can in an actuall verbal conversation. My tone in the posts is subject to the way you think someone would say them, so something that may sound mean or panic-y in this situation could just be you reading it the wrong way. And from what I gathered from your posts, I will eat my underwear if you're not mafia.



















