MAFIA: HIGURASHI NO NAKU KORO NI (GAME)

Well, first time playing with him, I had no idea of his play style, but I did point out a few things that I thought were inconsistant - such as the fact he was sure I wasn't mafia when it'd be the logical conclusion for any townie to make if they knew or even heavily supposed I'd been lying. His first call was to mark me as independent, which was odd.

Secondly, he , for some reason, never out-right denied his mafia role when pushed about it. THAT seemed rather odd to me.

So yes, as much as one can know anything in a mafia game without being mafia or having an investigative role - I knew.

author=Liberty
Well, first time playing with him, I had no idea of his play style, but I did point out a few things that I thought were inconsistant - such as the fact he was sure I wasn't mafia when it'd be the logical conclusion for any townie to make if they knew or even heavily supposed I'd been lying. His first call was to mark me as independent, which was odd.

Secondly, he , for some reason, never out-right denied his mafia role when pushed about it. THAT seemed rather odd to me.

While I see your first point, the second is pretty moot because seeing as you were the suspicious one to begin with and you were the only one who suspected him.

In all honesty I think your lynch is something that could have been avoided had you not claimed to be an Independent from the get-go...although TBG didn't help matters, but I guess that was a ~lost in translation~ kinda thing.

author=Yellow Magic
Those particular two just didn't have enough ~synergy~ I guess...

EDIT: Liberty, you ~knew~ that CAVE_DOG was a Mafia member? Right...and I'm the Sultan of Somalia. ~_~

I totally called Cave and Marrend though.

author=ivoryjones
Is it me or does the role-generator love making chana mafia? :D

It also loves making me cop.

author=Yellow Magic

author=Liberty
Well, first time playing with him, I had no idea of his play style, but I did point out a few things that I thought were inconsistant - such as the fact he was sure I wasn't mafia when it'd be the logical conclusion for any townie to make if they knew or even heavily supposed I'd been lying. His first call was to mark me as independent, which was odd.

Secondly, he , for some reason, never out-right denied his mafia role when pushed about it. THAT seemed rather odd to me.

While I see your first point, the second is pretty moot because seeing as you were the suspicious one to begin with and you were the only one who suspected him.

In all honesty I think your lynch is something that could have been avoided had you not claimed to be an Independent from the get-go...although TBG didn't help matters, but I guess that was a ~lost in translation~ kinda thing.

To be honest, I was actually confused, since this was my first mafia game. I tried reading up on all the posts done so far, and in my rush, I mistakenly thought that Liberty&I was somehow independent, even though we were "town-aligned".

On that note, nobody was independent-aligned, were they? Strange.

Yes gourd, and you should take it as practice to become better to avoid cave going apeshit on you.

@Ym Sorry. Ha, Cave even got an interesting role in PW Mafia.

@ Ivory
I think I can already do so, but I played like crap this game.

I think next time I'll resist claiming independent or at least muddying the issue. It was an interesting experiment though, I'm only sorry I couldn't see it through to the end and ended up screwing benny's chances of a longer game.

Sorry mate. ^.^;

Top priority in the game if I lose:

Town: Not getting killed so I can be a detective conan wannabe.
Mafia: Have fun bitching in the QT and yelling how fucked we are.
Indi: Probably same with town.