RMN'S FANTASY VANILLA MAFIA (GAME THREAD)

ADON: A CASE STUDY. I KNOW IT'S LONG BUT READ IT IF YOU ARE TOWN

#lynch Chana
Just a starter lynch.

Here we have a very self-conscious post. This is on the first page of the thread. It would seem obvious that Adon's vote was not entirely 'serious,' since, you know, Chana had not posted yet, but he still felt the need to qualify it with 'just a starter lynch.' because he was very worried about people jumping on him, perhaps? It is notable that Adon never responded to anyone's assertions that this post was self-conscious and scummy. Indeed, he tried to play buddy buddy with the one person pushing him the hardest: me

Well anyway, I do not believe that Cave is scum, or at least not yet, in spite of his posts which really aren't to convincing either way, I think we should lay off him. For now. I have suspicions of tbg or shinan. Not sure which.

What would his motive for doing this be? An ill-conceived attempt to get me to not suspect him. Adon also says that he has suspicions of tbg or shinan, but he's not sure which one. Why is he not sure? Why not both of them, in any case, since there are multiple scum in this game? Adon is very wishy-washy here, unwilling to place suspicion on any one person. He continues this trend later:

So Jeroen, what are your thoughts so far?

Marrend you have not said much...

Here, he just asks for people's opinions. It's all fine and dandy to try and draw opinions from the crowd, but Adon had given none of his own at this point! An attempt to appear to be 'in the game' without contributing anything.

Why do you think that MM is scum? I mean he doesn't SEEM scummy.

Here Adon states that MM does not seem scummy to him at all. Would you like to see the second time he talks about Mirrormasq?

I too wonder what was up with MM's eagerness to lynch him. Maybe he is scum?

A weak assertion that "someone" (who? MM?) is scum for wanting to lynch someone else. Indeed, all town must be scum by such logic. Would you like to see the THIRD time he mentions Mirrormasq?

#cancel
#lynch MM
I have been convinced for now.

Amazing. "I have been convinced for now." By what, exactly, Adon never mentions, probably because he was never actually convinced that Mirrormasq was scum at all, if you catch my drift. Regardless, Adon hops on the tailend of the Mirrormasq bandwagon, saying that he has been convinced for now. This implies that he could be convinced otherwise.

I kinda still think that Mirror is scummy. Though YM is definitely an alternative lynch.

But apparently not. Adon only "kind of" thinks that mirrormasq is scummy in this post, but is still voting for him. But Yellow Magic could be an alternative lynch. Why? For what reasons? There are none, because Adon was never interested in hopping off the Mirrormasq bandwagon. Let's go back in time.

wait are you guys like admitting your what what what stop

yeah i am going to say it is a joke because nobody would ever announce themselves as mafia, unless they are scewing with us and actually are mafia but ohh god

Here, Adon pretends that he is getting his mindfucked. I don't think I should need to point out why this is insincere since the thing he was responding to was just someone saying "yo I'm mafia this game." Why would you freak out like this over that?

So anyway, Cave, lynching people all over the place the whole game doesn't really make anybody side with you, and you look very scummy. Of course there is the possibility that you are so used to being scum that being a townie isn't really your thing. Regardless, I have not been convinced of anybody being mafia, but there are still mafia among us!

Here, Adon calls me scummy for voting a bunch of people. He has yet to explain how this is exactly behavior a mafioso would display, but I digress. Regardless of apparently looking very scummy to him, somehow, in his eyes, I am still not scum. If he was town, why would a person that was acting scummy not appear to be scum to him? He states, right here, that I am VERY SCUMMY. remember this important fact for two seconds.

Chana, there is no way that Cave is scum, an indie maybe, possibly a town. But I assume chears killed shinan.

EVEN THOUGH I AM VERY SCUMMY, THERE IS NO WAY THAT I AM SCUM. This is, without a doubt, the single most damning thing anyone in this thread has said. Which begs the question: Why would Adon post this? Simple, he wanted to get me on his side. After all, I have been the person pushing him the most.

You were acting scummy by lynching so many people with little fact. How does that make me scum for pointing that out? I mean how many times have you switch lynched in the last two pages? Acting scummy are being scummy are two different things.

If we were all wrong lynching mirror, then Cave's accusations should be accurate.

Here, Adon attempts to mischaracterize my arguments. I did not say that he was scummy for calling me scummy for voting a bunch of people. I said he was scummy for calling me scummy AND insisting that I could not possibly be scum in the same breath. Acting scummy and being scum are literally two different things, but they are inherently connected. Acting scummy is something scum naturally do. To paint it any other way is a lie, so if I am acting scummy, I should be scum to him. But I'm not. Because he is. Thanks for reading lynch him now.