Full Games List
Featured Games
New Games
Reviews
Media
Images
Blogs
Game Updates
Images Feedback Summary
Game Design Highlights
Tutorials
Articles
Scripts
Utilities / Plugins
Resources
Engines
Engine Bulletins
What is Makerscore?
Past Events
Achievements
Misaos
Forums
Post History
Chat
New to RMN?
Full Store List
RMN Music Pack (free)
MILLER'S HOLLOW MAFIA - GAME THREAD
Posts
Yellow Magic
View playlists
Closeauthor=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
"i've seen zero reasoning as to why we should kill him today" pretty obviously, to me, refers to the votes cast for him by other people. literally my only post that could be construed as me wanting to lynch him said that he would be an okay lynch but that there were better options available. this is not contradictory because half of the people in this game would be okay lynches.
Are you referring to this post:
Both Platinum and Trihan are framing this potential lynch as a way to kill both wildwes and me (well, obviously we have to kill cave tomorrow if wildwes is scum!!!) which implies they know his alignment. Platinum is the scummier of the two.
because I'm not getting that vibe from this at all.
Out of interest do you not think that this reason holds anymore? Why not?
and more importantly can you put into plain english comprehensible by a 15 year old why you suspect Zeuzio?
author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
well believe this. i just daycopped your ass. surprise motherfucker!!!!!! ##lynch yellow magic
LOL
PlatinumAshes
I am now certain that you are not scum and are just town trying to play scum as hard as possible.
0
I am very tempted to
Does this leave your second argument(My ratio post) to be the primary reason you're voting for me?
author=Yellow Magic
I've already acknowledged several times that the election thinking may have been a bad reason, and I readily admit that! I'm still not convinced that PlatinumAshes is in the clear, though, and debating with you's not helping - so yeah, I do believe that you and PA are in cahoots.
Does this leave your second argument(My ratio post) to be the primary reason you're voting for me?
author=Adon237
Wildwes is really new at this, so I am going to assume any odd behavior is him fudging up because he has the same problem I do. Unless there is undeniable proof that he is scum, lynching him won't make any sense.
SOMEONE THAT UNDERSTANDS ME. THANK GOD.
author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
well believe this. i just daycopped your ass. surprise motherfucker!!!!!! ##lynch yellow magic
LOL I find this extremely hilarious! :D
author=PlatinumAshes
I am very tempted to
Very tempted to what? Don't leave me hanging! D:
author=PlatinumAshes
Does this leave your second argument(My ratio post) to be the primary reason you're voting for me?
This is still one of the reasons (and it's not just about the numbers - the whole post, including the numbers and the 'obviousness', just stand out to me).
Reason number 2 is how CAVE_DOG put up a reasonable argument against you, but never voted for you. Then, as votes started piling up, he dismissed the votes as awful, and so far hasn't given me adequate reasoning as to why he's changed course from "Platinum looks scummy" to "I haven't seen a single reason for lynching Platinum today".
Hell, it's almost as if he were trying to pretend that the incident between you and him never happened...
think I'll leave it at that lest I divert everyone else's attention from potential leads they may have. I do have a tendency to get maybe too focused sometimes, so it'd be nice to hear from the others now.
think I'll leave it at that lest I divert everyone else's attention from potential leads they may have. I do have a tendency to get maybe too focused sometimes, so it'd be nice to hear from the others now.
PlatinumAshes
I am now certain that you are not scum and are just town trying to play scum as hard as possible.
0
I'm just as confused as you are, though I think he's strongly following his hunches and emotions with the way he accuses people. Mind you, he's two people short of having accused every single other player of scummyness in some way.
You're right that someone acting overly nice, and very obvious can be a scumtell, but take a look at my other 30-or-so posts. There's enough posts in there that are far sought, speculative or accusative, to make in sort of illogical for me to take up that happy-go-lucky persona at that point.
You're right that someone acting overly nice, and very obvious can be a scumtell, but take a look at my other 30-or-so posts. There's enough posts in there that are far sought, speculative or accusative, to make in sort of illogical for me to take up that happy-go-lucky persona at that point.
author=Yellow Magicauthor=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACKthat was so early on that i forgot about it. No, I don't. firstly because the hypothetical was bad reasoning on my part (lynching the cop claim after his supposed guilty target flips town is something with town motivations behind it as well) secondly because it's day 1 and the information present in the game has at least doubled since then.
Out of interest do you not think that this reason holds anymore? Why not?author=Yellow Magicauthor=PlatinumAshesVery tempted to what? Don't leave me hanging! D:
I am very tempted to
author=PlatinumAshes
Does this leave your second argument(My ratio post) to be the primary reason you're voting for me?
This is still one of the reasons (and it's not just about the numbers - the whole post, including the numbers and the 'obviousness', just stand out to me).
Reason number 2 is how CAVE_DOG put up a reasonable argument against you, but never voted for you. Then, as votes started piling up, he dismissed the votes as awful, and so far hasn't given me adequate reasoning as to why he's changed course from "Platinum looks scummy" to "I haven't seen a single reason for lynching Platinum today".
That's not what I said. What I said was that I have not seen reasoning as to why we should do it. That sentence was in specific reference to Gourd and Adon's votes on him, which seemed to have zero motivation behind them. it's usually a bad sign when a bunch of people start voting someone for seemingly no reason.
the reason I want to kill zeuzio, adon, is because he has been regularly posting while staying in the background. Reading stuff but not forming an opinion or straying to one side of any kind of argument. the most he did was say "well better follow this cop claim" which seems out of character since he expressed his disbelief in the claim and has played a fair share of mafia games. (This means that if Wildwes is scum, Zeuzio also is.)
yellow magic's play here in contrast with his play last game (after he became scum) has at least convinced me that he is earnest and most likely town. for now!!!!!!
Zeuzio has promised to say something of substance. I am waiting for him.
Zeuzio has promised to say something of substance. I am waiting for him.
I really didn't explain my vote very well, but there was reasoning behind it. My main reason being since he's a new player, he'd probably make the mistake of putting a fellow scum mate on a podium, so I figured if we lynched him and he flipped scum the player he was putting on a podium would be another scum player. (Said player being Trihan.)
Zeuzio
3787
Okay.
I think Cave is likely town, but due to his playstyle I simply can't put enough faith in him to elect him! XD I modded a game where he duped the entire town, even when a person who had just died and saw incriminating flavor and then was revived was convinced.
Liberty is playing her usual town style, though I don't think she's been mafia very many times so I don't know. There's also the fact that what she proposed about being sheriff would be pretty ballsy thing for a mafia to suggest and, like Cave said, wouldn't even help them much until lylo.
I'm not seeing what's so scummy about Platinum. I've guessed the mafia/town ratio as a townie before, and imo that's hardly enough to justify being on my radar. and what I said about his point being fair was just me trying to say something even though I was really tired and couldn't think! XD
and uh, that's all I've got for now. I'd have to read everything again in order to really get a read more. ugh.
I think Cave is likely town, but due to his playstyle I simply can't put enough faith in him to elect him! XD I modded a game where he duped the entire town, even when a person who had just died and saw incriminating flavor and then was revived was convinced.
Liberty is playing her usual town style, though I don't think she's been mafia very many times so I don't know. There's also the fact that what she proposed about being sheriff would be pretty ballsy thing for a mafia to suggest and, like Cave said, wouldn't even help them much until lylo.
I'm not seeing what's so scummy about Platinum. I've guessed the mafia/town ratio as a townie before, and imo that's hardly enough to justify being on my radar. and what I said about his point being fair was just me trying to say something even though I was really tired and couldn't think! XD
and uh, that's all I've got for now. I'd have to read everything again in order to really get a read more. ugh.
I just read through three pages to catch up and I have no idea what the hell is going on still. >.<;
I'm gonna keep to my no lynch at this point because frankly, you all suck as candidates. Besides, it's best not to shorten our odds on the first day when we know that more than likely we'll get a town death tonight and the chances of us hitting a werewolf the first night is rather low.
(I'm not even gonna count the clusterfuck of crazy that was the last mafia game because that was just a fluke. It really was.)
That said, while my gut is telling me no, Cave is really confusing the issue with his jumping about calling everyone werewolves. Hell, you called me one twice but didn't act on it despite your willingness to jump on YM for shady. It doesn't really make sense at all. Can you explain your logic for not jumping on me when you claimed me to be highly suspicious and werewolfy?
I'm gonna keep to my no lynch at this point because frankly, you all suck as candidates. Besides, it's best not to shorten our odds on the first day when we know that more than likely we'll get a town death tonight and the chances of us hitting a werewolf the first night is rather low.
(I'm not even gonna count the clusterfuck of crazy that was the last mafia game because that was just a fluke. It really was.)
That said, while my gut is telling me no, Cave is really confusing the issue with his jumping about calling everyone werewolves. Hell, you called me one twice but didn't act on it despite your willingness to jump on YM for shady. It doesn't really make sense at all. Can you explain your logic for not jumping on me when you claimed me to be highly suspicious and werewolfy?
no I haven't. I have been asking you who is on the scumteam. That is me asking you what your scumreads are, not saying that you are a werewolf. Also, WHAT ARE THEY.
i'm not very convinced, zeuzio, it would be very easy for a scum player to just pick three people and say "yeah, they're town."
i'm not very convinced, zeuzio, it would be very easy for a scum player to just pick three people and say "yeah, they're town."
Jeroen_Sol
Nothing reveals Humanity so well as the games it plays. A game of betrayal, where the most suspicious person is brutally murdered? How savage.
3885
I'll be gone for most of the day, so if hammer falls today I expect everybody to respect that and stop posting at that time.
You could have worded it better, then. :/
So far I'm leery of Happy, Kyrsty and maybe Mirror. Usually Mirror is a lot more combative when playing but she's been quiet. Happy, I feel suspicious of due to his first few posts and Kyrsty... well, she's been pretty quiet and didn't really say anything after her small 'yo guys I was away' message.
Nothing strong. Of course, I'm still gathering opinions, so...
So far I'm leery of Happy, Kyrsty and maybe Mirror. Usually Mirror is a lot more combative when playing but she's been quiet. Happy, I feel suspicious of due to his first few posts and Kyrsty... well, she's been pretty quiet and didn't really say anything after her small 'yo guys I was away' message.
Nothing strong. Of course, I'm still gathering opinions, so...
Hey guys, sorry yesterday was kind of a write off. I was at a 12-hour comic drawing marathon. On the bright side, Issue 2 of Templat Knights is complete!
It's about Tyrone from Maui --aka Blue Nanaue Knight -- facing off against more of Rita MacNeil's shadow monsters.
Not as explorative a story as Issue 1, but definitely better storytelling.
That's all TMI. How about I get caught up on the game!
It's about Tyrone from Maui --aka Blue Nanaue Knight -- facing off against more of Rita MacNeil's shadow monsters.
Not as explorative a story as Issue 1, but definitely better storytelling.
That's all TMI. How about I get caught up on the game!
