Full Games List
Featured Games
New Games
Reviews
Media
Images
Blogs
Game Updates
Images Feedback Summary
Game Design Highlights
Tutorials
Articles
Scripts
Utilities / Plugins
Resources
Engines
Engine Bulletins
What is Makerscore?
Past Events
Achievements
Misaos
Forums
Post History
Chat
New to RMN?
Full Store List
RMN Music Pack (free)
MILLER'S HOLLOW MAFIA - GAME THREAD
Posts
Yellow Magic
View playlists
Close
Why do people suspect me again? Just because I trusted someone who I had no idea their alignment does not mean I am scum! I even repented by preventing another death for town! Happy, why are you lynching Dudesoft, just because he lynched Cave? Really, if you don't believe Cave is scum at this point, then town is doomed. :(
author=Yellow Magicauthor=HappyYay we found Werewolf number 3
#lynch Dudesoft
that was my thoughts, but i rather not get ferociously attacked from any additional accusations.
author=Happy
Jesus this bandwagon is growing fast. I want to state I'm not exactly opposing lynching Cavedog, I even consider jumping on the wagon myself, but could we at least try to generate a bit more discussion before the man is dead, or we won't really have much benefit of his death, regardless of his alignment.
There's already 4 people voting to lynch Cavedog.
4 people
I'd love to hear some reasoning before we kill him. There's a big chance he's werewolf, but chance also a chance he isn't. Adon, why do you think Cavedog is werewolf? Dudesoft, is there chance he isn't?
I find it highly likely that one of those 4 people is a werewolf, Yellow Magic. If it's not Dudesoft, is it you or MirrorMasq? I find it highly unlikely that Adon is a werewolf, mainly because I feel he hasn't got a clue most of the time about what to do.
I am pretty sure Mirror is town. After all, he has generally been pretty accurate. Yeah I am pretty clueless.
author=Happy
I'd love to hear some reasoning before we kill him. There's a big chance he's werewolf, but chance also a chance he isn't. Adon, why do you think Cavedog is werewolf? Dudesoft, is there chance he isn't?
author=Happy
Cavedog appears so obviously guilty that it makes me wonder if any werewolf would be as stupid as to set themselves in such a spotlight.
You tell me, Happy. Why's CAVE_DOG so obviously guilty?
And if there is any way CAVE_DOG can be seen as so obviously guilty, why in God's name aren't you voting to lynch him?
Guilty, as in responsible for lynching Zeuzio, and yeah he could be werewolf if his thought pattern would be as simple as "dohoho, I want to kill a town player so let's lynch this guy."
But
Also, I am voting for Dudesoft because he hasn't elaborated on his lynch at all.
But
author=Happy
See Adon, here's what I'm thinking: His actions resulted to Zeuzio's death, true, I agree with that. However, this pattern is obvious to everyone, including himself.
Now if we assume Cavedog is a werewolf he would still be aware that he is responsible for Zeuzio's death. If you were a werewolf, would you like to be visibly responsible of anyone's death? I find it highly unlikely, or at least very very risky.
As I said earlier, it's still possibly that Cavedog is bluffing and he is a werewolf, but it would be super risky move this early in the game.
This is why I'm not certain if he's a werewolf, and why I'd like to see more discussion. However, I would prefer someone else for sherif, that's for sure, considering Cave had much influence on Zeuzio's death.
Also, I am voting for Dudesoft because he hasn't elaborated on his lynch at all.
What in the world is happening?
No, no guys this stupid. I don't even see why Cave had one vote on him: Someone reiterate the claim against Cave.
Also, why are people acting like I helped kill Zeuzio? I didn't. I retracted my vote because I didn't think that mafia Zeuzio would just give up like he did. You guys only have yourselves to blame, not Cave. even if Cave is a werewolf, seriously, YM is just being INCREDIBLY scummy. He started a bandwagon on Cave (who did nothing scummy, unless you count being wrong scummy), then he's asking Happy why Cave is so suspicious. Whether this is an actual question or not is irrelevant - if it is then he's had his vote on Cave for way too long not knowing what he was doing. If he's just testing Happy, how many people has he called scummy by now? Honestly, it looks like he's just using the scum tactic of pointing out everyone's scummy tendencies whether they're there or not.
Also someone said I haven't talked much and wanted my scum reads. I'd agree that I haven't talked much but I have said my scumreads.
Town: Me (Duh), Cave (Cave is always a hard read, but I think he's town this game), Libby (100% town), Dudes(Acting normal, not sure though), Adon (Way too confused to be mafia)
Mafia: YM (Reasona above) PA(preoccupation with Trihan) Kyrsty (was lurking, but isn't anymore so I'm not sure of this), Trihan (Grouped with PA, not scummy in and of himself)
#Lynch Yellow Magic
No, no guys this stupid. I don't even see why Cave had one vote on him: Someone reiterate the claim against Cave.
Also, why are people acting like I helped kill Zeuzio? I didn't. I retracted my vote because I didn't think that mafia Zeuzio would just give up like he did. You guys only have yourselves to blame, not Cave. even if Cave is a werewolf, seriously, YM is just being INCREDIBLY scummy. He started a bandwagon on Cave (who did nothing scummy, unless you count being wrong scummy), then he's asking Happy why Cave is so suspicious. Whether this is an actual question or not is irrelevant - if it is then he's had his vote on Cave for way too long not knowing what he was doing. If he's just testing Happy, how many people has he called scummy by now? Honestly, it looks like he's just using the scum tactic of pointing out everyone's scummy tendencies whether they're there or not.
Also someone said I haven't talked much and wanted my scum reads. I'd agree that I haven't talked much but I have said my scumreads.
Town: Me (Duh), Cave (Cave is always a hard read, but I think he's town this game), Libby (100% town), Dudes(Acting normal, not sure though), Adon (Way too confused to be mafia)
Mafia: YM (Reasona above) PA(preoccupation with Trihan) Kyrsty (was lurking, but isn't anymore so I'm not sure of this), Trihan (Grouped with PA, not scummy in and of himself)
#Lynch Yellow Magic
I'm pretty sure I've made my stance on Cavedog clear from the start; and today is no different. Bandwagoning on him was the best choice I've made all day, and my last post was a tongue-in-cheek retort to his whimsical x8 lynch
author=Happy
Also, I am voting for Dudesoft because he hasn't elaborated on his lynch at all.
My last post was for this.
PlatinumAshes
I am now certain that you are not scum and are just town trying to play scum as hard as possible.
0
Why I'm sure Cavedog is not guilty.
MirrorMasq, even townies have things they can know with certainty. At this point, in fact, I know two things
1) I know with infallible certainty I am innocent
2) I know with infallible certainty zeuzio was innocent
If you look back at the ed of day of Day 1, you'll see I was the prime suspect. If things had kept quiet from then on, I'd have been hung by the ~3 man majority of you, Yellow Magic and Gourd, and maybe a small scum following too. What Cave did end Day one, was throw all his credibility and reputation away to swtich the target from one townie to the next.
Of course, you're not even going to consider the validity of my Fact 1, at least, not until you and your bandwagon unveil what I've concluded already.
MirrorMasq, even townies have things they can know with certainty. At this point, in fact, I know two things
1) I know with infallible certainty I am innocent
2) I know with infallible certainty zeuzio was innocent
If you look back at the ed of day of Day 1, you'll see I was the prime suspect. If things had kept quiet from then on, I'd have been hung by the ~3 man majority of you, Yellow Magic and Gourd, and maybe a small scum following too. What Cave did end Day one, was throw all his credibility and reputation away to swtich the target from one townie to the next.
Of course, you're not even going to consider the validity of my Fact 1, at least, not until you and your bandwagon unveil what I've concluded already.
PlatinumAshes
I am now certain that you are not scum and are just town trying to play scum as hard as possible.
0
author=Gourd_Clae
What in the world is happening?
No, no guys this stupid. I don't even see why Cave had one vote on him: Someone reiterate the claim against Cave.
Also, why are people acting like I helped kill Zeuzio? I didn't. I retracted my vote because I didn't think that mafia Zeuzio would just give up like he did. You guys only have yourselves to blame, not Cave. even if Cave is a werewolf, seriously, YM is just being INCREDIBLY scummy. He started a bandwagon on Cave (who did nothing scummy, unless you count being wrong scummy), then he's asking Happy why Cave is so suspicious. Whether this is an actual question or not is irrelevant - if it is then he's had his vote on Cave for way too long not knowing what he was doing. If he's just testing Happy, how many people has he called scummy by now? Honestly, it looks like he's just using the scum tactic of pointing out everyone's scummy tendencies whether they're there or not.
Also someone said I haven't talked much and wanted my scum reads. I'd agree that I haven't talked much but I have said my scumreads.
Town: Me (Duh), Cave (Cave is always a hard read, but I think he's town this game), Libby (100% town), Dudes(Acting normal, not sure though), Adon (Way too confused to be mafia)
Mafia: YM (Reasona above) PA(preoccupation with Trihan) Kyrsty (was lurking, but isn't anymore so I'm not sure of this), Trihan (Grouped with PA, not scummy in and of himself)
#Lynch Yellow Magic
If a player being 'affiliated' with another player is your tell for concluding they must both be scum, then you honestly can't really have Yellow Magic and in Maffia together. I don't know where I'm going with that, it's just very very illogical.
PlatinumAshes
I am now certain that you are not scum and are just town trying to play scum as hard as possible.
0
* "then you honestly can't really have Yellow Magic and I in Maffia together"
Why is it illogical for me to have different reasons for players being suspicious? The scum are going to act different, they don't want to be easily picked out as acting all the same. Besides, that was all I had day one, and nothing has changed with you since then, so I kept the conclusion.
author=PlatinumAshes
Why I'm sure Cavedog is not guilty.
MirrorMasq, even townies have things they can know with certainty. At this point, in fact, I know two things
1) I know with infallible certainty I am innocent
2) I know with infallible certainty zeuzio was innocent
If you look back at the ed of day of Day 1, you'll see I was the prime suspect. If things had kept quiet from then on, I'd have been hung by the ~3 man majority of you, Yellow Magic and Gourd, and maybe a small scum following too. What Cave did end Day one, was throw all his credibility and reputation away to swtich the target from one townie to the next.
Of course, you're not even going to consider the validity of my Fact 1, at least, not until you and your bandwagon unveil what I've concluded already.
So...Cave isn't scum because he diverted attention from you? That hardly makes him innocent even while I believe he's not scummy.
PlatinumAshes
I am now certain that you are not scum and are just town trying to play scum as hard as possible.
0
If Cave were scum, then he knowingly threw everything away to accomplish nothing. I guess there's always a chance, but Cave is not stupid, certainly not THAT stupid.
PlatinumAshes
I am now certain that you are not scum and are just town trying to play scum as hard as possible.
0
So you're conclusion of me being affiliated with the Mafia is based on the observation that I trusted one of them, and highly distrusted the other?
Earlier, I said that you were probably just attaching yourself to one of your mafia buds. I'm assuming you could've later decided to differentiate the two by acting differently toward them, or just acting suspicious against people who happened to be your fellow scum as it would be weird if you trusted both Cave and YM.
