MILLER'S HOLLOW MAFIA - GAME THREAD

I was, actually, though it would be hard to enforce. All it takes is the Sheriff jumping on a bandwagon and boom - another lost townie (though, yes, it could also mean a dead werewolf, but currently there's no really good leads).

Basically we need to be very sure about who we vote for. We can be sure that it'll be hard to find that last werewolf due to them being the last one. We have a one in eight chance of getting them which means that unless we're very lucky or very good at reading the signs, we may mislynch.

Frankly, I think this day should be the one where everyone is pressured to talk. We have a lead on the werewolf clan, so pressure should be applied to everyone to at least talk more. The last day was very quiet bar a few moments, and town can't afford to let anyone just glide under the radar.

Well, out of those who voted last night, I'm getting the feeling there wasn't any werewolf ploys and votes, it just doesn't seem plausible. Which leaves us with Happy, Gourd_Clae and wildwes. I think wildwes is indeed bad at this game and is town, so it's a toss up between Gourd and Happy for me...

I'm leaning toward Gourd myself.

No, Kyrsty, I don't think so. I think Gourd is town.

I'm still up in the air about you, though. But it's nice to see you participating. Let's see if we can get the others to talk as well, shall we?

author=Liberty
And by lead, I mean there are significantly more town than werewolf - we outnumber him/her 7 to 1, so we should make sure each and every one of us actually talks so that we can get a feel for each other.

M, 45, Detroit, likes long walks on the beach and abject poverty

In all seriousness, questions should, as always, be raised of those who did not vote for the prime suspect. Not that they are VERY DEFINITELY werewolves simply for not voting for the right person (otherwise I would be VERY DEFINITELY werewolf myself), but their reasoning is always important. What're your thoughts: Liberty, Gourd, Wildwes, maybe Happy?

Also, I think we're giving wildwes too much doubt just because he doesn't seem like a great Townie. Maybe he isn't a great Werewolf either? He DID outright no-lynch last time.

Well, as always, I said why I voted for who I did. I'll retrieve that post for Ym but in the meantime, Liberty doesn't seem scum to me and I was voting against Wildwes despite it being useless because that is honestly who I thought was scum at the time (and still do think is scum.) Happy is on Kyrsty's list whose scumdar I think is busted this game so for that reason I say, er.... probably not. A better place to examine the votes would be at the end of the list against Trihan as scum who don't want to look suspicious would probably be the ones to hammer a fellow scum. We know this didn't happen here however, so working our way through the people who voted against Trihan backwards, we come to Kyrsty and then YM. Like I said before I don't think Kyrsty is scum though in light of this I'd very possibly be closer to lynching her. And YM has been on my suspicious list since he lead a bandwagon on Cave for very little reason and didn't give Cave much of chance to defend himself when Cave even said he didn't understand the accusations against him.

So, in my eyes, the potential scum are Kyrsty, Wes, and YM. That would be in increasingly scummy order.

author=Gourd_Clae
Well, I'm in favor of lynching Wes. Like I said earlier, he's voting people for reasons that aren't his own and it seem s to me that Wes is using other people's logic so that if he makes a mistake he can blame the person who actually thought about it. I think this was pretty evident when I asked him to explain Kyrsty's fallacies of logic, and he said I'd have to take it up with Cave.

I do, however, believe him when he says he's bad at this game. I just think that he's a bad mafia member.

#Lynch Wildwes

This was my reasoning against Wes.

Back to my YM theory, being scum could be part of the reason he wanted to know who was the Seer so badly.

@Gourd: Yeah, that post you made did make me more suspicious of Wes, because as you say, he may very well be a bad werewolf. Especially if Dudes and Trihan weren't around to guide him very well (and we know that Dudes was awol for most of the first day, while Trihan didn't say much, really.)

One of the reasons I'm pushing for people to talk - so we can get a better read of them, their arguments and style of play. Town would talk, so any lurkers become suspicious for seemingly hiding.

author=wildwes
I didn't vote to lynch anyone because I was unsure of who to lynch.

I think it's been elaborated hundreds of times why no-lynching does more harm to the villagers than the good. At the very least you could have assisted in the bandwagon...although maybe that would have made you look more like a Werewolf. But then, why would you care what you looked like as long as you were innocent?

author=Gourd_Clae
Back to my YM theory, being scum could be part of the reason he wanted to know who was the Seer so badly.

I wanted to know who the Seer was so badly? I said, like, one line, something along the lines of "This is getting tedious. Where on Earth is the Seer...". Flimsy argument that's almost grasping at straws. +100 suspicion points.

Or we could assume that the strongest supporters of Cave are actually town. oh that is nobody

they attempted to kill mirror, but i save him

but i do find it strange among other things cave wasn't dead sooner. Probably because everyone had their doubts of him in the first place.

#elect Adon237

I don't trust nobody, and I have no reason to elect anyone else... besides Mirror. Maybe.