MILLER'S HOLLOW MAFIA - GAME THREAD

#lynch Happy I feel like I could be mistaken here, yet I remember playing with him as a mafia (or was it YM? x_X) and he's kinda mafia-like for me right now. Doesn't prove anything, yet this is my vote for now.

Like I think I said, if P_A isn't scum, it's an entirely different scumteam to what I thought it was- and it clearly is, so I'm thinking it might be Trihan, Gourd, YM, or MM. Happy's on that list as well.

Might even be a Trihan/Dudes/Happy scumteam.

This is an earlier quote of mine, and I'm following it. To add to the argument against Gourd_Clae, he's been following along with other people's reasoning; in fact his post straight after Liberty's on page 41 basically quotes her. He's not coming up with any original reasons for his votes, and he's been off of both of the scum lynches, iirc. Happy voted for Dudesoft fairly early, and I voted for Trihan and stuck to it. Still, I'm not entirely swayed on Happy, either, but unless Gourd can come up with a genuine argument to prove his innocence I'm not changing my vote.

However, I do find it interesting that you named 2/3 confirmed scum members before they were lynched or before you had any reason to want to lynch them.

Actually, I'm of the opinion that Happy is the final mafia. I understand I'm suspect (For playing badly really. My fault not yours.) though Happy and Kyrsty are the only two that could be mafia here. Happy looks more suspicious to me in general due to him pointing a finger at everyone though not really resting it on anyone. Kinda weak, I'm not going to vote against him for it, but it's there. I understand the need to be cautious though I'm not sure why Happy is deliberating as much as he is - his posts are long though there's not that much of actual use in them.

Kyrsty seems deadset on lynching me (I happen to know I'm a townie), though her decisiveness is pretty town. I began to doubt her when it came down to her and Happy as I didn't find him scummy either though I see now that he's clearly more suspicious than her.

I'm not pointint my finger at everyone, because I don't really have idea about the last werewolf. I'm trying to find anything that could hint towards it. Also, no one has elaborate why me and kyrsty are the only potential werewolves.

What makes Liberty so definite town?

Once you've lynched me and if kyrsty turns out town too, then what? If I die now and you're pointing out Kyrsty only next logical target, and lynch her next day, you've already went through two nights, which means we're 4 players shorter and werewolves win. This would be the scenario if Kyrsty's town too.

Though, I'm leaning towards kyrsty, but if she turns up town, there's no way I can consider anyone else than MM and Adon certain town players.

Before I vote I'll try to find time to read through Lib's and Kyrsty's posts once more.

Adon's words.

still leaning towards kyrsty being scum, that last question of hers seems like an attempt to make her seem innocent by supposedly not knowing who scum has targeted

I had actually forgotten about that fact Adon defended MirrorMasq. Which means you two are our only confirmed town, leaving myself, Liberty, Happy and Gourd the remaining suspects.

So, since I know for a fact I'm a vanilla town, that leaves three left. If we had a Thief, there's a possibility that two are werewolves.

Liberty is pushing either Happy or myself, though there's no legitimate evidence as to Gourd's innocence. However, both myself and Happy have had periods of lurking, so it's justified.

Gourd is following other's arguments, but claims town, which isn't surprising.

Happy is writing long posts in defense of others, including myself, but has no definite thought.

Honestly, I'm not entirely sure whether to trust Adon or not, but we haven't had a counterclaim in regards to the witch, so I guess my scumdar is broken as fock. I just never liked the fact we had two nights with no werewolf kills.

Liberty has put up a strong town front the whole game, but I'm not sure whether to trust that anymore, because it has been very forceful. However, I don't think a werewolf has the gall to force a sheriff vote like that.

Of Gourd and Happy, it's a toss up. I'd almost say that Gourd is the werewolf and Happy is the thief, but there's strong possibility he picked a Town card at the beginning. I think the both of them are flavour characters, at the very least.

Adon, I ask that you give Gourd a chance to make his case before you hammer on him. You'd have to be the one to do it, because I won't lynch him and with Mirror (if she jumps on the lynch) there will be 3/4. So in this case your vote is the most vital.

There is a reason for this.

Gah, sorry! >.<;
For some reason I keep thinking you're female. I have no idea why! Usually it's the other way around.