MINI-MAFIA - STIK WARZ
Posts
author=MajoracanKing
(to guord) He seemed to cocky like he knew exactly what to do. It also seemed like he was trying to manipulate other players.
I think that's just his playing style. He did that in the last mafia game and I think he does it in most other mafia games. And yes, I know you were talking to Gourd, I said something anyway.
That is most certainly his play style. I wouldn't hold it against Majoracan for not knowing.
So far Adon and Mirror look the most likely to get my vote.
So far Adon and Mirror look the most likely to get my vote.
author=MajoracanKing
not that it matters but who has talked the least?
Adon, he hasn't spoken at all since the game started. I think Mirror popped in and said something once, but that was it.
Erm, I hasn't spoken alot because there is not much to talk about in day 1 without even being able to vote. And then it was 3 days of paused game or so. :)
Let me catch up a bit and I'll join discussion, I just woke up.
Let me catch up a bit and I'll join discussion, I just woke up.
Wtf, 3 died at once... From the glance of it I could say that Cave probably have died because of Seppuku? But there is no kill power on PA and TBG, so I have just two theories here... Either someone else who's town have tried to kill Cave and was protected itself or PA have selected a killer and was killed instead (not sure how exactly this Shadow ability works).
Also, maybe we should voteclaim to add something to discuss today? I personally haven't voted at all day 1. I was thinking about either not voting or voting Cave, but missed the end of the day.
Also, maybe we should voteclaim to add something to discuss today? I personally haven't voted at all day 1. I was thinking about either not voting or voting Cave, but missed the end of the day.
And yes, I'm always inactive day 1 especially without voting, because it's boring, unproductive and quite useless. I'm also sick of playing town on and on and on. But I can vote for whoever majority wants to lynch today, no problem.
author=MirrorMasq
Either someone else who's town have tried to kill Cave and was protected itself or PA have selected a killer and was killed instead (not sure how exactly this Shadow ability works).
PA's shadow grants him the ability to 'shadow' a person, he's affected by the same actions as the person he's shadowing but in return he gets to become more knowledgable. Now PA must have either shadowed benny or cavedog, it doesn't really matter anymore. The thing is, cavedog was indeed killed by a town (has to be benny then) and since benny is not the Murderer with capital 'M', cavedog got killed himself.
This leaves us with some questions: where did benny get the ability to kill and if not granted by the Murderer, what did the Murderer do this night?
Is it possible that the Murderer himself can't kill (or can choose not to kill) but instead let's someone else do it?
Is it possible that the Murderer targeted an untargetable player?
The 1st seems like the most obvious answer since the 2nd doesn't explain both cavedog's and benny's death.
Other than that is seems the best to get the majority to vote for someone now that we still have the chance, my vote would go out to either mirrormasq or wildwes.
author=MirrorMasq
And yes, I'm always inactive day 1 especially without voting, because it's boring, unproductive and quite useless. I'm also sick of playing town on and on and on. But I can vote for whoever majority wants to lynch today, no problem.
Everyone can make mistakes, I wouldn't be inactive knowing there is a chance at all someone already screwed up, we have to take all we can. Unless, of course, you don't want to chance getting revealed yourself. I don't have enough evidence to mark you as scum, but you certainly raise suspicion.
Pfft. I'm always missing day 1. But well, you haven't played with me last games, so I can understant this.
I am also suspicious about you. You have so much good theories about murderers like you know for sure. Ofc maybe they just seems good enough to me and you're actually wrong. But it is suspicous.
About murderer, yes, it is possible. Wouldn't really matter right now though. The only really important thing is - was or wasn't TBG a Murderer. Or murderer. Whatever.
My other suspicion is MajoracanKing. First time playing with him, so it's hard to say, but I'll keep an eye on you. Maybe even vote.
Wildwes looking like his usual self, Gourd... well... not sure yet, but not so much of a scum-like.
What about Adon... don't know if we should even considering voting him. Looks like he's just missing the game and not lurking here. There is a chance of him being one of the killers even if he is missing the game. But still, he shouldn't be our priority here, we should focus on active players.
I am also suspicious about you. You have so much good theories about murderers like you know for sure. Ofc maybe they just seems good enough to me and you're actually wrong. But it is suspicous.
About murderer, yes, it is possible. Wouldn't really matter right now though. The only really important thing is - was or wasn't TBG a Murderer. Or murderer. Whatever.
My other suspicion is MajoracanKing. First time playing with him, so it's hard to say, but I'll keep an eye on you. Maybe even vote.
Wildwes looking like his usual self, Gourd... well... not sure yet, but not so much of a scum-like.
What about Adon... don't know if we should even considering voting him. Looks like he's just missing the game and not lurking here. There is a chance of him being one of the killers even if he is missing the game. But still, he shouldn't be our priority here, we should focus on active players.
author=PsychoWaffle
my vote would go out to either mirrormasq or wildwes.
What have I done to seem like scum? State your reasoning.
And I'll go ahead with what Mirror said and voteclaim. I... didn't actually vote for anyone on Day 1. Right now I'm... not really sure who to lynch today, I have a bad feeling about Mirror but no real evidence to show for it.
Why is everyone suspicious about me? Suspicious yourselves. :\
There is no reason behind it. So stick with facts, shall we? Or do you want to lose another town so much when we have 4 town and 2 killers alive (should be right numbers)?
Also, let's play more active while I'm still here. Time zones and stuff... I'm gonna miss all the action again.
There is no reason behind it. So stick with facts, shall we? Or do you want to lose another town so much when we have 4 town and 2 killers alive (should be right numbers)?
Also, let's play more active while I'm still here. Time zones and stuff... I'm gonna miss all the action again.
author=MirrorMasq
Why is everyone suspicious about me? Suspicious yourselves. :\
There is no reason behind it. So stick with facts, shall we? Or do you want to lose another town so much when we have 4 town and 2 killers alive (should be right numbers)?
Also, let's play more active while I'm still here. Time zones and stuff... I'm gonna miss all the action again.
Well, there isn't much evidence to use is there?
Majoracanking is kind of being ignorant about the whole mafia game but I won't blame him for that, this is my first mafia game too but I kinda know what to expect already since I've watched my friends play it. Wildwes you're hardly theorizing here and kind of covering it up by being good guy wildwes towards majoracanking it seems though again, I could be perfectly wrong.
author=MirrorMasq
Pfft. The only really important thing is - was or wasn't TBG a Murderer. Or murderer.
That's what I'm saying, I think he's not the Murderer (cavedog died) but it gives us a good understanding of what the killer is capable of.
My theories are solely based on logic and reading everything well, plus my motivation of finding the killer by looking at his/her victims is the only thing I can do. The fact I'm confident about it just indicates I think I did a good job doing so; I was assuming you would all do the same. Of course we can all point fingers at each other while night phase is nearing and yet another townie will die, but I think this is the least we can do next to that with an actual purpose with the information provided.
My theories are solely based on logic and reading everything well, plus my motivation of finding the killer by looking at his/her victims is the only thing I can do.
Since editing is not a posibility (I didn't check my post well enough before posting it) here's my intended formulation.
My theories are solely based on logic and reading everything well, plus my motivation of finding the killer. By looking at his/her victims is this (theorizing) the only thing I can do.
Feels like discussion between us two. I would like to hear more from others, because someone's definately lurking here, everyone aside of maybe Adon know there is day phase and not a single word in last... 16 hours or so? Well, wildves appeared once.
I'm still not sure if we have enough time or not... Dudesoft? What about "17th"?
So I'm going to sleep now, I'll check your activity tomorrow morning and probably will cast my vote then. Also, don't bother with Adon today, ignore him, yet take a closer look at lurking people. At least one of them should be a killer.
I'm still not sure if we have enough time or not... Dudesoft? What about "17th"?
So I'm going to sleep now, I'll check your activity tomorrow morning and probably will cast my vote then. Also, don't bother with Adon today, ignore him, yet take a closer look at lurking people. At least one of them should be a killer.


















