THE COUNCIL OF DEATH - LET THE BLOODBATH BEGIN!

As far as lynching him because he isn't posting, I just don't like it. It isn't like he was posting and ignoring the question, it seems more likely he just hasn't had time to get on to post.

How did that happen?

author=MajoracanKing
How did that happen?

Looks like you accidentally delorted a close bracket.

author=Gourd_Clae
@Yellow What makes you think they're on the same team? One could be in a colored faction or scum or neutral. I do think two watchers is a little... ridiculous.

Yeah, I don't think they're on the same team - which is why I wrote that they can't be on the same team.

I don't understand how that's a chnage of heart for piano? I think he was just trying to figure out if I was a lord so he could murder me.

By checking your items when he already knew that one of them cured you of poison? Also, I say 'change of heart' because at the beginning of the day it seemed he knew that all Lords are scum - and then went on to say that he still wasn't sure whether it was the case (that's my understanding, anyway). The whole thing seems like a lot of back-pedalling by several people to me.

author=Gourd_Clae
Jeoroen:

While the neutral town faction the traditional objective of lynching all members of the scum faction, the other town factions need to meet other objectives,

And the whole game setup suggested the factions were going to kill each other.

The thing is - if it were so set in stone, why did Jeroen have to use the phrase 'other objectives'? Also, I went back to have a look at the Death-posts of the previous Lords/bodyguards and I don't see anything about goals. I have a feeling that you're assuming that your goal is the same as the other factions, i.e. that you're a lord/bodyguard. If so, and you have indeed that objective, I think it's in our best interests to have you lynched.

the only way a lord wins this is if three lords and scum die. If all four lords die, scum wins.

Can we really be certain of these objectives though? I mean I might be missing something but isn't it possible that a lord only has to kill two other lords or something like that?

author=JJJ7
In day 1 you suspected me for posting a "thougs so far" kind of post,
Which is understandable because it does not apport any new info,
But, how should I put this, it was day ONE,
There's no info in day ONE, just conjectures.

People like CAVE_DOG were actively trying to find leads (albeit with more sinister motives, but I digress) while you made that one one-liner post that, as you wrote, didn't add any new info. It seemed that coupled with your lack of actual posts (this one's your second in the whole game) you were playing the typical scum lurker game. Of course I could be mistaken, but this is how I saw it.

Why would he post this? He barely said something during the game,
And when he says something this is what comes out?
I was wondering if he was trying to help,
Until I realised he was just trying to divert the attention
from his mafia buddy YM.
Oh, and that is why you decided to nightkill Cave, right?

If he wanted attention to be diverted from me, why would he post about me at all, considering that the point he made was already made previously by others (including CAVE_DOG himself)?



For the record: Sooz, your jokes and stuff were funny on Day 1 but now they're, while still funny, pretty distracting. Mind taking the game somewhat seriously please???

My item was a lockpick. What do you do with lockpicks? I didn't want to say what the item was because what followed was obvious. I wanted to learn more about Gourd and that seemed as good a way as any. Yes, I stole the antidote.

Thinking about it, though Gourd has probably outed himself as Lord/Bodyguard... why do we care who's a lord and who isn't, when it seems like there's a non-Lord mafia faction that we're presumably supposed to get rid of?

Getting rid of the lords and their doodz just means we're getting rid of lords: it doesn't seem to support Town at all.

Why'd you abscond with the antidote, then? Doesn't seem too lily-white to me!

It was the only item Gourd had. I just used the lockpick. I thought there'd be a list or something and then I could just choose to steal something or walk away. Instead, I just got a message that I stole his only item.

author=pianotm
When SuNa saw me and broadcast it to the group, I knew how it looked, so I went on the attack, and accidentally outed Gourd as Lord Gourd. Now, he's probably going to be night killed because of it, and I'm entirely to blame. If we out the other lord, scum will probably win the game.

Are you sure? Usually scum's objective is to have dead people in general, so it shouldn't matter whether the corpses are Lords or just regular fancy-pants. Unless this is special Kill Blueblood mafia.

Hey, anyone who's scum, what's your objective?