[MAFIA] PRISONER'S DILEMMA. GAME OVER

Posts

Oh, shit, sorry my bad. No tale, she didn't actually "sold" him out. What I wanted to say was PA, which actually turned out to be piano, since I had like 5 hours worth of sleep the other day.

The post which I was referring to was this.

https://rpgmaker.net/forums/topics/24686/?post=887856#post887856

Also contrary she wasn't selling psy out, more like protecting him which ended up not in her favor after her death. I really, really doubt she'd be able to say something like that if she didn't know who her teammates were..!
author=Fomar0153
Why? Surely if I was the remaining scum I would have night killed you, you're confirmed town, and while you're the person who has consistently voted for me, it wouldn't have been that suspicious if you were the night kill. Also we'd be on track to lynch PA.

Whomever chose Shinan may have wanted you to think it had been a rookie mistake being as you seem consistently convinced that a new player is scum.


If we go by the assumption that scum couldn't communicate with each other during the day phase, there was no way for them to confirm if either me or kitten only had 1-shots. As psy died D1, his flavor upon death did not confirm nor deny his claim being 2-shots only. Hence scum being on fence on lynching one of us. Scum can't risk getting a no kill again, hence, going after the most logical option (as mentioned above).

"and while you're the person who has consistently voted for me, it wouldn't have been that suspicious if you were the night kill"?????

what is dis. this is so confusing. explain.
author=Fomar0153
We still have plenty of time, I'm leaning more to Shinan was a deliberately calculated play.

People who looked more scummy following a Shinan kill:
AlaskanEmily, tale, myself

Everyone else who aren't confirmed town:
oddrabbit, PlatinumAshes, demonlord

Assuming killing Shinan was a calculated move, I can't see it allowing a scum PlatinumAshes to win, if they some how survive to the final three they'd be lynched based on everything that's happened so far. It's unlikely that future night kills will be sub-optimal otherwise scum is pretty much guarenteed to lose. If we were lynching randomly then by not lynching a confirmed town they slashed their odds of winning to 1 in 3.

Anyway the two people who have probably benefitted were demonlord who I felt was town and oddrabbit who I was neutral on.

Anyone else got any new thoughts now we've had more time?


Welp, since you did put yourself up there on the suspicious list, you're good to go

#Cancel
#Lynch PA

In honor of keeping our promise to piano, also since he doesn't care about the game to post today, let's all lynch him pls

Yes I'm being serious
or am i?

Yup.
or am i?
ivory, thank you for your explanation! About earlier when Liberty's shared her list-
She probably thinks that I'm scum for canceling my vote on her or something. here's the post-

https://rpgmaker.net/forums/topics/24686/?post=887373#post887373

odd, that's fine. You're right. I should've put more into context into my posts.
Did piano really make that promise or was that PA? I hope piano wants for town to win.
um i really don't know about that but okay

#lynch PlatinumAshes
OzzyTheOne
Future Ruler of Gam Mak
4698
#cancel

#lynch Fomar


AE, PA or Fomar, who shall it be?
author=kittenfood
um i really don't know about that but okay

#lynch PlatinumAshes


Kitten you need to look more closely at my post, I wrote something on the left side after my "lynch" on PA
I hope kitten post limit isn't used up today..
OzzyTheOne
Future Ruler of Gam Mak
4698
#cancel

#lynch Kittenfood


Time to talk.
noo there's a post limit on kitten, don't used it up
author=kittenfood
well i still think it's emily but if no one else agrees i guess i would lynch fomar or demonlord. i believe odd after he outted the full thing about his role, and i don't think tale or PA are scum. it just leaves those two by process of elimination.


That sounds about right.

#Cancel
#Lynch demon
author=ivoryjones
author=kittenfood
um i really don't know about that but okay

#lynch PlatinumAshes
Kitten you need to look more closely at my post, I wrote something on the left side after my "lynch" on PA


god im sorry i didnt even notice at all. i need to pay closer attention u_u;

#cancel

also this is my sixth post today so i may or may not be able to post after it depending on if the post limit stuff actually got fixed if cave's not on.
author=ivoryjones
"and while you're the person who has consistently voted for me, it wouldn't have been that suspicious if you were the night kill"?????


I was simply saying that you are the person who has put their lynch vote on me the most. I'm sure most of us expected you (or maybe Ozzy) to be the night kill, particularly in case you were lying about being one shot. My point was that being as you were the expected kill it wouldn't have necessarily put any suspicion on me. If I was the final scum, Shinan was an awful play.
Urgh, lots of ninjas, need to sleep though.
Oh shit. Yeah I thought cave should have mentioned it to lib already? He did a short vote count earlier so lib should have fixed/is trying to fix it by now.
It just took me minutes to spot that tiny text, unless I'm ninja'd again this is my last post before bed. We still have plenty of time so I won't be leave a lynch up overnight.

My position remains the same, Demon feels like town for me. I'd be ok with lynching PA or Emily.
CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
On sunny days, I go out walking
1142
A MESSAGE FROM THE UNABLE TO POST KITTENFOOD


: "ozzy what do you mean? is this another joke vote thing im not getting"
OzzyTheOne
Future Ruler of Gam Mak
4698
#cancel

It was something akin to that yes. Nothing to lose sleep over.