[MAFIA] PRISONER'S DILEMMA. GAME OVER
Posts
Sorry one last thought, we don't need to say how we'll vote tomorrow, you can just tell us who to vote for to trigger the double elimination.
A MESSAGE FROM THE UNABLE TO POST KITTENFOOD THAT CAME TO ME BEFORE HAMMER. WAS THAT HAMMER IDK. TABULATING VOTES

OFFICIAL END OF DAY 3 VOTECOUNT
AlaskanEmily (5):Tale, demonlord, Ozzy, PlatinumAshes, Ozzy, Ozzy, Fomar, ivoryjones
demonlord (0):ivoryjones
PlatinumAshes (0):Ozzy, ivoryjones, kittenfood, Fomar
Fomar (0):ivoryjones, Ozzy
kittenfood (0):Ozzy
Not Voting: Oddrabbit, AlaskanEmily, tale, kittenfood
AlaskanEmily, town-aligned vanilla, was executed Day 3.
Night 3 Begins. Please get your night actions in within 24 hours.
AlaskanEmily (5):
demonlord (0):
PlatinumAshes (0):
Fomar (0):
kittenfood (0):
Not Voting: Oddrabbit, AlaskanEmily, tale, kittenfood
AlaskanEmily, town-aligned vanilla, was executed Day 3.
Night 3 Begins. Please get your night actions in within 24 hours.
kittenfood, town-aligned Jack of All Trades, was killed Night 3.
Day 4 Begins. With 7 alive, it takes four votes to execute. Deadline is Tuesday at 10 PM EST. That's in about 72 hours.
Oh darn, RIP kittenfood, you played very well for your first game :(
Anyhow, this verifies that Tale is indeed town.
Anyhow, this verifies that Tale is indeed town.
It's too bad that Emily turned out to be town instead of scum, we fell for scum's framing of Emily, we can't let scum lead us on any further!! We should also be a little more careful with votes on Day 4 seeing as it's now only 4 votes to lynch.
So, confirmed Town: IvoryJones, OzzyTheOne, Tale, Odd(?)
Potential Scum: Demonlord, Fomar, PlatinumAshes.
I say we got with the main suspect first before going after crazy theories.
#lynch DemonLord5000
Your reign of terror has ended.
So, confirmed Town: IvoryJones, OzzyTheOne, Tale, Odd(?)
Potential Scum: Demonlord, Fomar, PlatinumAshes.
I say we got with the main suspect first before going after crazy theories.
#lynch DemonLord5000
Your reign of terror has ended.
I think maybe we got it backwards, we need to hear demonlord about current role balancing. kittenfood's role seems powerful for a town and maybe scum team has could be a role but that just a theory. I'm so sorry emily.
Kitten, you played well. I guess I was wrong about emily. We all thought she was suspicious so it was bound to happen. I just happened to go after her first.
Unfortunately, lynching me is a lynch for another down townie. I can't really argue against it since I'm just as good a target as any of the two though. Keep in mind I was actively scum hunting, whereas PA was weird day 1, and fomar has been pretty passive all around. He agrees on who needs lynched but hasn't attempted any strong arguments.
I could go either route on those two since both are suspicious for completely different reasons. We should be able to win even with my lynch though, so I'll leave you all to decide if I am the one to go first.
Unfortunately, lynching me is a lynch for another down townie. I can't really argue against it since I'm just as good a target as any of the two though. Keep in mind I was actively scum hunting, whereas PA was weird day 1, and fomar has been pretty passive all around. He agrees on who needs lynched but hasn't attempted any strong arguments.
I could go either route on those two since both are suspicious for completely different reasons. We should be able to win even with my lynch though, so I'll leave you all to decide if I am the one to go first.
author=tale
ozzy, why are you so quick on silencing?
What do you mean with so quick on silencing? I was so quick to jump on my vote because I want Demonlord to talkkkk.
author=tale
ozzy, why are you so quick on silencing?
I think he's going based on Fomar's logic earlier.
That is, we lynch each unconfirmed town, one by one? Something like that?
Obviously we failed with AE, which just leaves a bad taste in my mouth, alongside the fact that I can't seem to be of any help. Everyone feels like town, to me.
Looking back at earlier, fomar has been talking mostly game theory day 3 whereas PA brought up some interesting points. PA was weird day 1, but made some interesting points in the other day phases. He's also traveling so I can forgive PA for not being super active. I'm going with...
#lynch fomar
#lynch fomar
Fomar's logic.. Town would win either way?
Okay, I feel a bit off if scum turns out to be one of the power roles instead unconfirmed town.
Okay, I feel a bit off if scum turns out to be one of the power roles instead unconfirmed town.
Oh, I do not want to mislynch town until we hit scum, I'm just going with my gut, and my gut tells me to lynch PA, Demonlord and Fomar all at the same time.
I know right? The last scum is doing an incredible job at hiding that they're scum, which leads me to believe that it is either Demonlord or you Odd.
author=oddRABBIT
Obviously we failed with AE, which just leaves a bad taste in my mouth, alongside the fact that I can't seem to be of any help. Everyone feels like town, to me.
I know right? The last scum is doing an incredible job at hiding that they're scum, which leads me to believe that it is either Demonlord or you Odd.
Why do we have two masons for example? what if one goes to scum? Liberty is certain that ivory is probably town but not sure with the rest..
author=tale
Fomar's logic.. Town would win either way?
Okay, I feel a bit off if scum turns out to be one of the power roles instead unconfirmed town.
That could definitely be a problem, yeah. Personally, the only power role that I could think of that might be scum is Ozzy, though I do think my role is the most suspicious.
However, if we look at scum, I'd say it's reasonable that the last scum has a power role, it might be something weaker than or about the same level as rolecop. For example, in... Piano's(?) Spy mafia game, there was a double agent role who could side with either the mafia or the town. In this case, wouldn't it be plausible for Ozzy (since I don't think he has a role other than mason?) to be a scum working with town?
But I think Ozzy himself feels pretty town-like, so I'm probably incredibly wrong. Still, it is possible, I guess?



















