MISAOS 2012

Posts

Pages: first 12 next last
The nominations for the Misaos 2012 are enabled.

Best Storytelling and Direction*
The project you think is most effective at telling its story. Think in terms of its presentation, writing, clarity, cutscene direction, and originality.

Best Characters
Vote for your favorite heroes or villains! Choose the project whose characters are the most effective in terms of presentation and writing.

Best Setting
The game you feel had the most clever, inventive, interesting and immersive setting for the game to take place in. This may include such things as best use of lighting effects or ambient sound.

Best Atmosphere*
The game you feel did the best at delivering an experience. This would include such factors as presentation, graphics, music and sounds, and style.

Best Graphics & Artwork
Vote for the project you feel has the best graphics. (In general, this category should favor original artwork over ripped or commercial graphics)

Best Sound & Music
The project you think has the best soundtrack and creative use of sound! (In general, this category should favor original compositions over ripped or commercial music)

Most Technical Prowess
The project you feel got the most out of is engine! This might include well-made battle systems or other custom systems or engines.

Best Level/Dungeon/Puzzle Design
The game you think has the best stages, levels, or dungeons. Voting should be based on layout, aesthetics, interactivity, and other related factors.

Best Gameplay Mechanics
The game with the best gameplay idea(s) and implementation. Or, more simply, the game you think is the most fun to play!

Best Interface Design
Interaction with the game's systems, custom menu graphics, responsiveness of menus, clear display of elements like fonts, headers, etc.

Most Promising Demo**
Vote for the demo released this year you think has the most potential.

Best Non-RPG*
Vote for what you think is the best game released this year that is not an RPG!

Game of the Year*
The absolute best game you played from RMN for the current year (RPG or otherwise).


*Completed games only eligible for this award.
**Demo games only eligible for this award.

Please commence your ranting about why everything we do is wrong!
The current categories are good enough and cover all the bases. Demos are eligible for more awards this year. I am looking into how to incorporate Episodic games into RMN/Misaos and ways to automatically detect when someone blanket votes for the same game across all categories.

Games with a download added in the year 2012 are eligible.

Remember, nominations run throughout the year, and you can change your nominations at any time. So if you play a good game, nominate it (before you forget)! You can always change it later.

After 2012 concludes, nominations will be closed and a voting round will commence for the games with the highest number of nominations.
Ocean
Resident foodmonster
11991
Most episodic game
Craze
why would i heal when i could equip a morningstar
15170
I am all for the less anti-demo Misaos. (You could have always separated them - best story in a demo, best story in a full game, but EVERYTHING YOU DO IS WRONG RMN IS A CESSPOOL THE MAYANS ARE COMING I AM FULL OF NAPALM AND BULLSHIT etc.)

Time to blanket-vote for Star-Stealing Prince.
author=Craze
I am all for the less anti-demo Misaos. (You could have always separated them - best story in a demo, best story in a full game, but EVERYTHING YOU DO IS WRONG RMN IS A CESSPOOL THE MAYANS ARE COMING I AM FULL OF NAPALM AND BULLSHIT etc.)

Time to blanket-vote for Star-Stealing Prince.

This x255.
author=k
Best Setting
The game you feel had the most clever, inventive, interesting and immersive setting for the game to take place in. This may include such things as best use of lighting effects or ambient sound.

How do those things qualify under Settings?
halibabica
RMN's Official Reviewmonger
16948
Yeah, those really sound more like atmosphere things. Likewise, the atmosphere description doesn't quite fit that category either. Perhaps we should simply change Best Setting to Best Atmosphere, and Best Atmosphere to Best Presentation.
The timeline kind of puts games released in October or later at a big disadvantage in terms of exposure :x
this is only for nominations. And on the flipside, games released late in the year have the advantage when it comes to voting (being fresh and awareness of them is higher)
author=Craze
Time to blanket-vote for Star-Stealing Prince.


For sure. I hope the fact that it's coming out so early in the year doesn't work against it. I would have nominated the demo for a few additional awards if I could have.
Max McGee
with sorrow down past the fence
9159
author=Craze
I am all for the less anti-demo Misaos. (You could have always separated them - best story in a demo, best story in a full game, but EVERYTHING YOU DO IS WRONG RMN IS A CESSPOOL THE MAYANS ARE COMING I AM FULL OF NAPALM AND BULLSHIT etc.)

Time to blanket-vote for Star-Stealing Prince.


Because we all definitely know in February what the best game of the year will be.
Versalia
must be all that rtp in your diet
1405
author=kentona
this is only for nominations. And on the flipside, games released late in the year have the advantage when it comes to voting (being fresh and awareness of them is higher)


it's like awards season for movies!

author=Max McGee
Because we all definitely know in February what the best game of the year will be.


can you NOT be a douche for two seconds or maybe just not respond to Craze? it's not going to do anything good if everybody just keeps throwing elbows FYI.

author=halibabica
Yeah, those really sound more like atmosphere things. Likewise, the atmosphere description doesn't quite fit that category either. Perhaps we should simply change Best Setting to Best Atmosphere, and Best Atmosphere to Best Presentation.


This seems like an excellent suggestion, given that the "setting" and "atmosphere" descriptions are somewhat redundant, and "atmosphere" is for completed games only, reinforcing the idea that it is for the overall presentation of the game in its entirety.
I shortened up the description for Best Setting, and I *was* going to change Best Atmosphere to Atmosphere/Presentation, but then I saw that the description already has "...presentation, graphics, music and sounds, and style." So Atmosphere is probably good enough!
author=Max McGee
author=Craze
I am all for the less anti-demo Misaos. (You could have always separated them - best story in a demo, best story in a full game, but EVERYTHING YOU DO IS WRONG RMN IS A CESSPOOL THE MAYANS ARE COMING I AM FULL OF NAPALM AND BULLSHIT etc.)

Time to blanket-vote for Star-Stealing Prince.
Because we all definitely know in February what the best game of the year will be.

I could be the best so far. So nominate it now, and if something better comes along, update your nominations. That's how the system is *supposed* to work :\
author=v
This seems like an excellent suggestion, given that the "setting" and "atmosphere" descriptions are somewhat redundant, and "atmosphere" is for completed games only, reinforcing the idea that it is for the overall presentation of the game in its entirety.

I don't think they are redundant, they are just misleading.
Setting is only where and possibly when a game takes place.
author=FG
Since the community doesn't have the intelligence required to put their GOTY bias to one side when considering which games deserve the invididual category awards, we shouldn't bother with any categories beyond the following: "Best <Genre> Game", "Best <Genre> Demo", "Game of the Year" and "Demo of the Year".

pretty much this. I don't think it's really the community itself but rather the only people voting are

A. People who make RM games and PLAY them (they are becoming instinct PLEASE DONATE http://wwf.panda.org/ )
B. part of a fanbase of said GOTY game

Basically not enough vocal people play RM games in general. Not that this is a problem... but the awards seem built for some kind of mass general audience when there isn't really.
I am also voting for star stealing prince..seems like this will be the best game of this year!
author=Fallen-Griever
author=heisenman
author=v
This seems like an excellent suggestion, given that the "setting" and "atmosphere" descriptions are somewhat redundant, and "atmosphere" is for completed games only, reinforcing the idea that it is for the overall presentation of the game in its entirety.
I don't think they are redundant, they are just misleading.
Setting is only where and possibly when a game takes place.
All of the categories are redundant. Not because it's a bad idea to try and section things up into categories, but because the community is so retarded that people "blanket vote" for a single game in every category regardless of that category's relevance towards the game in question (see the results of the previous two Misaos if you don't believe me).

Since the community doesn't have the intelligence required to put their GOTY bias to one side when considering which games deserve the invididual category awards, we shouldn't bother with any categories beyond the following: "Best <Genre> Game", "Best <Genre> Demo", "Game of the Year" and "Demo of the Year".

This is why I have almost always abstained from voting in Misaos. I don't play anywhere near enough RM games to even remotely qualify as a learned source of opinion. I literally have only played Star Stealing Prince to a respectable amount in the last ~8 years.

I don't think its necessarily that we lack the intelligence (I imagine that was just a stab) but a lot of people in this community just don't play the games. Why do you think we have such a low amount of Reviews? There are certain people that play every game that comes out, and there are certain people who only play the really popular ones, and there are people like me who don't play shit. I only played Star Stealing Prince on a whim and was so impressed by it that I don't want to play any more games because they'll instantly be compared to it and likely not live up.



That being said, I don't think a year goes by that tons of people don't complain about Misaos. It's either how they are done and/or who wins; but invariably there will be complaining. Lots of it.
Anyone know when the award nominations end?
Pages: first 12 next last