PHOENIX WRIGHT: ACE MAFIA

Posts

Does it matter? Read his post, I think he made his decision already.
rabitZ
amusing tassadar, your taste in companionship grows ever more inexplicable
1349
Also, we should keep an eye on Shinan and Chana, they're flying waaay to low under the radar for my taste.
chana
(Socrates would certainly not contadict me!)
1584
I'll follow CAVE_DOG's advice I guess and lynch MirrorMask first, before Marrend, particularly considering he's 100% sure scum, so :
#Cancel
#Lynch MirrorMask
rabitZ
amusing tassadar, your taste in companionship grows ever more inexplicable
1349
oh, there you are chana :P
rabitZ
amusing tassadar, your taste in companionship grows ever more inexplicable
1349
I just find it weird that CAVE claimed doctor, being that one of the top priorities of the doctor is staying safe and out of harms way. Guess his "bulletproof" works like it did when I was squall?

I'm gonna go to sleep today and vote tomorrow after thinking.
chana
(Socrates would certainly not contadict me!)
1584
No, I haven't suddenly appeared because you mentioned being "waaay to low under the radar", I've been following closely and posting, much less I must say than I usually do but there are quite a bit of big expert mouths in this game, so...
CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
On sunny days, I go out walking
1142
author=rabitZ
I just find it weird that CAVE claimed doctor, being that one of the top priorities of the doctor is staying safe and out of harms way. Guess his "bulletproof" works like it did when I was squall?

I'm gonna go to sleep today and vote tomorrow after thinking.


I did not claim doctor. I claimed bodyguard. I die in place of the person I visit after my bulletproof is used up. And I claimed to act as the town scumdar.
chana
(Socrates would certainly not contadict me!)
1584
Above post following this :
author=rabitZ
oh, there you are chana :P

author=rabitZ
Also, we should keep an eye on Shinan and Chana, they're flying waaay to low under the radar for my taste.

Just because day phase starts at midnight and it's now 9am I'm flying under the radar.

Well I guess I didn't do much in day 1 either.

Speaking of bananas though. Bulletproof means he can't die during the night right? Just so I'm remembering this right. That's a sweet advantage to have at the moment but it also means there's not much for me to say. I'll follow the herd and lynch whoever you guys want me to lynch.
Yellow Magic
Could I BE any more Chandler Bing from Friends (TM)?
3229
Holy shit, development.

There's always the chance that CAVE_DOG is lying about his role but I'm going to give him the benefit of the doubt (although tbh it's hard to imagine Franziska as a bulletproof bodyguard...)

Meanwhile, while MirrorMasq is indeed suspicious there's no hard evidence as to the fact. I'm not sure if we should risk anything given we are two vital roles down.

About the other suspicious people:

Zeuzio: Similiar scenario to MirrorMasq, really. May or may not be Mafia, but these two are definitely the most likely ones at the moment.
ldida1: I don't think so. He's done this whole disappearing act thing before when he was a Hero in previous games.
Shinan: Seems like a Hero to me (for once...)
Chana: Basically screaming 'Subordinate' right now.
Marrend: No idea, honestly, but his vagueness doesn't help matters at all. Probably Subordinate #2 (or even '?????' - still very curious about '?????'s role in all this).

Yellow Magic
Could I BE any more Chandler Bing from Friends (TM)?
3229
(btw CAVE, if you want to use Fransizka's avatar for the sake of authenticity I'd be happy to relinquish hold of her)
Trihan
"It's more like a big ball of wibbly wobbly...timey wimey...stuff."
3359
That's a pretty big reveal, CAVE. It would take something pretty...heeheehee...spectacular to top that.
author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
You've got nothing and you know it. I'm going to be protecting Trihan tonight unless someone claims something.


Do you know anymore about how your role works CAVE_DOG? If you’re out visiting people can you be killed in the conventional way, or only if you visit mafia? Because now you’ve come out, won’t you just get killed at night? You’re a smart player, but I’m not sure if you revealing who you’re protecting next is a good idea either. If the mafia kill you tonight, you’ve just framed Trihan =(

If there’s something I can take away for this, it’s that I’m now 100% sure that SorceressKyrsty is innocent. If I was mafia, claiming to be a bullet proof, I wouldn’t choose a fellow team member to put attention on incase something went wrong.

author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
That said, about the visit I received in the night. I think it's important to note that it came in the middle of the night phase. Which makes me think that it may have either been decided during the day or may have been a mechanic that didn't involve any players. After all, why would Gourd_Clae spend time writing two paragraphs if I might just get killed at the end of the night?
That said, the flavor indicated that the person telling me to do this was a good guy and was pretty certain of Idida1's guilt.


Yesterday CAVE_DOG appeared to be the most innocent in my eyes, so if I had that power and I was aligned with town, I would have also chosen him. But like I said, I still feel that it is an independent role, and one that I don’t trust yet. If I’m going to vote for Idida, it’s because I suspect him, and not because of an unknown source.

Idk what to do yet. I’ve still got more things to decide and read up again.
Marrend
Guardian of the Description Thread
21806
If CAVE is telling the truth about his role, I figure that he would die during this night phase, the next night phase's target being the person he cleared, SorceressKyrsty. I wonder if we still have a role with a protect ability?

Even if he didn't reveal, I can understand his point about the ldida1/Despite discrepancy, and his list o' scum. Do I have a defense against that? No, not really!
Another point to consider is mafia and neutral roles. There might be a roleblocker present that would disable CAVE's powers and then the mafia could kill him off. I don't know if disablement will disable bulletproof too though.

So technically it MIGHT be a decent idea to protect CAVE in case a protector type still exist. (I guess though that guy died already)
Trihan
"It's more like a big ball of wibbly wobbly...timey wimey...stuff."
3359
CAVE's reveal seems too convoluted to be a lie, so again I'm taking him at his word.

Hmm...heeheehee...

Would anyone like some...coffee?

I had debated the wisdom of coming out, but CAVE's painted a target on my head anyway by saying he's going to protect me. I don't want to die before I'm at least some use, so here we go.

I am...?????, also known as Viola Cadaverini.

At the beginning of the game I was given the choice of which team to be on, and I chose town.

During the night I can offer to reveal a player's role to someone in exchange for them voting for a person of my choice. As should be obvious by now, last night I offered to give Chearlie's role to CAVE if he voted for ldida1.

And I'm not a weirdo. :(
Trihan
"It's more like a big ball of wibbly wobbly...timey wimey...stuff."
3359
I was also persuaded by the almost precognitive guesses as to what the secret role was. Yellow Magic pretty much nailed it, and I'd also decided that I would reveal (or at least heavily hint) if anyone noticed I had changed my avatar to Viola, which ivoryjones did.
I knew there was something wrong when you changed your avatar. I just couldn't pinpoint what and why. Also I've just remember you've wrote 'heeheehee' in your previous post derp :S

So, if we take your word for it, then we now have:

8 Innocents
4 Mafias
2 Subordinates

We still managed to fill 1 more person to innocent, but it WILL be dangerous if the subordinates choose to stay sides with the mafia.
*also wtf am I doing here i need to get my ass back on liberal studies sagdfghghfd

Gah pressed the submit button too fast =-=
Trihan
"It's more like a big ball of wibbly wobbly...timey wimey...stuff."
3359
You know, I was about to say I revealed so early so we wouldn't end up in a situation where I died and people were falling over themselves theorising about who ????? is/was when I'm not there to set things straight.

I've just realised how stupid that was. If I die you'll be told my role anyway. :P Oh well, it's out there now.